Recordkeeping for Compensation

Quick Answer

Broker-dealers must supply each associated person's compensation-attributable securities purchases and sales, with monetary amounts or non-monetary descriptions. Prompt production on regulatory request is an alternative to making that transaction record. Separately maintain a record of all relationship agreements, compensation-plan summaries, applicable schedules, and determination methods for compensation based on factors other than remuneration per trade.

Compensation information connects documented terms with actual transactions and payments. General contest rules or grids alone are insufficient when they omit required information. Integrated records may supply it, and a reliable production process may supply the transaction information promptly.


SEA Recordkeeping Authority

The Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (SEA) gives the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) authority to require broker-dealers to:

  • Make and preserve records of their business activity
  • File reports, including Financial and Operational Combined Uniform Single (FOCUS) reports under the reporting requirements
  • Submit to examinations by SEC staff

This authority supports the broker-dealer books-and-records regime. The recordmaking requirements identify what must be made and kept current; the preservation requirements govern retention, storage, access, and production.


Per-AP Transaction Record

For each associated person (AP), the firm must make a record listing each purchase and sale of a security attributable for compensation purposes to that person, or elect to produce the required information promptly on a securities regulator's request.

The record must include, for each transaction:

ElementRequired Content
Attributable purchases and salesIdentify each person's securities transactions attributable for compensation purposes
Compensation amountIf monetary (commission, concession, override, asset-based fee)
Compensation descriptionIf non-monetary, such as an attributable gift, trip, or merchandise prize

Transaction identifiers can link this information with other required transaction records. The compensation provision does not itself prescribe a customer, quantity, and date field template.

What "Attributable for Compensation Purposes" Means

Attribution follows actual compensation credit. It is not automatically established by execution, order entry, supervision, or an intended contractual split.

  • A trade executed by a desk trader on behalf of an AP's customer is attributable to the AP if the AP receives the production credit
  • A team trade may be attributable to multiple APs when they actually share compensation credit
  • A registered person's confirmation of an order transcribed by a clerical employee does not itself establish production credit; identify who actually receives the credit

Occasional transcription when an appropriately registered person is unavailable, followed by that person's customer confirmation before entry, is a narrow registration provision. It does not independently authorize every proposed payment or impose a blanket transaction-pay ban. The firm must reasonably support and record its determination of whether payment and actual related activities require broker-dealer registration.

Non-Monetary Compensation Detail

For non-monetary compensation attributable to securities purchases and sales, supply a description with each person's attributable transactions. A securities-sales trip can be covered, but a sales threshold is not a necessary condition. A general employment benefit unrelated to securities transactions falls outside this transaction-information duty.

For a trip earned through qualifying securities sales, the required information identifies the credited person, the attributable sales, and the trip's description. This provision does not prescribe allocating the trip's dollar value among qualifying trades. Separate product-compensation records may require nature and value information.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A non-monetary description is required for compensation-attributable securities transactions; contest eligibility terms alone are insufficient.
  • A reliable link to separate compensation data can supply complete per-person information promptly.

Compensation Agreement Summaries

The firm must make and keep current a record of all agreements pertaining to each AP's relationship with the firm, including:

  • A summary of the compensation arrangement or plan, including applicable payout, salary, draw, and override terms
  • Applicable commission and concession schedules
  • The method of determining compensation, to the extent compensation depends on factors other than remuneration per trade

Why the Summary and the Schedules Are Both Required

The information must describe the applicable arrangement for each person. A shared schedule can form part of that information; the rule does not universally define schedules as firm-wide product rate cards or summaries as payout percentages. Separate physical documents are not mandatory.

For example, suppose an arrangement calculates pay using a commission rate applied to an identified monetary base, followed by a representative payout percentage. The base, rate, and payout terms yield an expected payment. Compare it with the actual transaction compensation amount.

A discrepancy can warrant appropriate supervisory follow-up under the firm's reasonably designed procedures. Possible causes include calculation errors, off-grid payments, inaccurate records, or omitted terms. The record must reflect actual compensation even when payment departed from the agreement; replacing it with the intended payment would conceal the discrepancy.

Both the per-AP transaction record and the compensation agreement record are preserved for at least 3 years, the first 2 in an easily accessible place, under the SEC's records-retention rule.

Electronic preservation must meet applicable integrity, verification, download, redundancy, and access conditions. Outside recordkeeping does not transfer the firm's responsibility; applicable undertakings and access conditions remain. Fully disclosed clearing arrangements may avoid duplicating compliant records maintained by the clearing firm, while the introducing firm retains responsibility for accurate maintenance and preservation. Office-related records also have location or prompt-production conditions.


Alternative Compliance: Produce on Request

A firm may elect not to make the transaction compensation record if it can promptly produce its complete required information on a securities regulator's request. This alternative does not replace the separate agreement records.

  • The "produce on request" alternative is not a permission to skip recordkeeping
  • The firm must still have systems capable of generating the information promptly
  • A firm that cannot reconstruct per-rep, per-transaction compensation on regulatory request fails the rule even if no continuous "record" was prepared

Trade-processing, payroll, or linked systems can support this alternative if complete information is reliably producible promptly. Promptness depends on applicable production requirements and the request's circumstances, without a universal fixed clock in this alternative. Preservation and electronic-record immediate-access duties also remain.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The prompt-production alternative applies to complete transaction information, not the separate agreement records.
  • Retained data must remain promptly producible; missing arrangement terms cannot be cured merely by knowing payments.

Connection to Compensation Supervision

The compensation information gives the firm and regulators a transaction-level audit trail of attributable securities purchases and sales. It supports review of:

Risk AreaWhat the Per-AP Record Surfaces
Sales-incentive abuseWhether a rep is pushing a higher-comp product over a better-suited alternative (look at the rep's product mix versus the firm-wide mix)
Production credit allocationWhether team-account or split-credit arrangements are allocating credit consistently with the written agreement (look at the per-rep aggregation against the team agreement)
Non-cash compensation trackingDescriptions of attributable awards and their transaction links; separate product and covered giving-side gift records have their own contents, triggers, and exceptions

The firm must maintain and enforce reasonably designed written supervisory procedures (WSPs) using adequate information. If a procedure requires comparing each representative's contest credits by issuer with qualifying sales, unavailable credits and transaction links prevent that specific comparison. Other adequate data may support other reviews; no universal issuer-bias report is prescribed.

Transaction recordkeeping does not authorize an award arrangement. Variable-contract and investment-company product rules separately address offeror records, permitted arrangements, and applicable Regulation Best Interest duties. Gifts from a member to its own associated persons are outside the giving-side gifts rule, while product restrictions may still apply. A description of an attributable trip does not prove that its arrangement is permissible.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you identify compensation-attributable securities purchases and sales, monetary amounts, and non-monetary descriptions?
  • Can you distinguish a trip description from an unsupported dollar-value allocation requirement?
  • Can you identify all relationship agreements, arrangement summaries, applicable schedules, and conditional determination methods?
  • Can you limit the prompt-production alternative to transaction information while preserving agreement, retention, access, and supervision duties?