Quick Answer
FINRA's borrowing/lending rule bars a registered person from borrowing from or lending to a customer. Five exceptions apply (immediate family, financial institutions, same-firm registered persons, outside personal relationships, outside business relationships), each requiring the firm's written supervisory procedures (WSPs) to permit it. Recent amendments modernized the immediate-family definition, replacing "husband or wife" with "spouse or domestic partner."
The borrowing/lending requirement addresses conflicts in the customer relationship. A permitted loan does not waive separate commercial-honor or improper-use duties. Whether those duties have been violated depends on the conduct, not merely on the existence of a loan.
The General Prohibition
A registered person may not borrow money from or lend money to a customer.
For this requirement, a customer includes a person whose securities account is assigned to the registered person now or was assigned to them within the previous six months, at any member firm. The conditions also apply when an existing loan is followed by a new broker-customer relationship.
The conditions also reach arrangements a registered person instructs or asks a customer to enter with someone related to the representative, such as a relative or outside business. They also apply when the representative asks the customer to have a related person enter an arrangement with the representative. Changing the named party does not avoid the conditions.
The prohibition reaches:
- Cash loans in either direction
- Borrowing in substance, including owner-financing arrangements; a personal repayment obligation can establish debt even if the parties call it an investment
- Both secured and unsecured loans
The prohibition is the default. An exception requires firm procedures permitting the activity, a qualifying relationship and compliance with the applicable notice-and-approval requirements. An unrecorded investment is not automatically a loan; examine the actual repayment terms.
The Five Exception Categories
| # | Exception | Notice and Approval Requirement |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Customer is a member of the registered person's immediate family | Firm WSPs may waive notification and approval |
| 2 | Customer is a financial institution or other person or entity regularly extending credit in the ordinary course of business, acting in that business | Firm WSPs may waive notification and approval when the loan meets the commercial-terms condition |
| 3 | Both parties are registered persons of the same firm, with a broker-customer relationship between them | Prior written notice and prior written firm approval required |
| 4 | The loan is based on a bona fide, close personal relationship maintained outside of and formed before the broker-customer relationship | Prior written notice and prior written firm approval required |
| 5 | The loan is based on a bona fide business relationship outside the broker-customer relationship | Prior written notice and prior written firm approval required |
The exception categories do not override the firm's WSPs. If the firm's WSPs prohibit any borrowing or lending, the exceptions do not authorize the activity. The exceptions only function when the firm has chosen to permit them.
The financial-institution exception fits only when the customer is acting in the course of its credit business, such as a bank making a personal loan to the registered person.
For the lending-business waiver, the loan must be on commercial terms the customer generally offers to similarly situated members of the public as to need, purpose and creditworthiness. For the other three categories, the rule itself requires prior written notice and prior written firm approval, so firm procedures cannot waive them.
The personal-relationship exception turns on timing. The close personal relationship must exist outside the brokerage relationship and must have formed before it. A friendship that begins after the account opens does not qualify.
Those requirements also cover modifications and, when an existing loan precedes the customer relationship, approval before that relationship begins. On receiving notice, the firm must reasonably assess the risks and determine whether to approve the arrangement or relationship; it need not approve it.
"Immediate Family" Definition (Modernized)
Recent amendments updated the immediate-family definition for new arrangements and modifications on or after the effective date. The amendments:
- Replaced "husband or wife" with "spouse or domestic partner"
- Added explicit inclusion of step and adoptive relationships
- Tightened the catch-all "any other person" clause to require both same-household residency AND material financial support
The Updated Definition
"Immediate family" includes:
- Parents, grandparents, mother-in-law and father-in-law
- Spouse or domestic partner (replacing "husband or wife")
- Brother or sister (and step-brother, step-sister, adoptive variants)
- Brother/sister-in-law
- Son/daughter-in-law
- Children and grandchildren (including step and adoptive)
- Cousin
- Aunt or uncle, niece or nephew
- Any other person who resides in the same household as the registered person AND whom the registered person financially supports, directly or indirectly, to a material extent
Effective-Date Mechanics
The amendments apply to:
- New borrowing or lending arrangements entered into on or after the effective date
- New broker-customer relationships entered into on or after the effective date
- Modifications made on or after the effective date to arrangements that were entered into before then
The amendments do not apply retroactively to arrangements entered into before the effective date. A later modification or new broker-customer relationship can bring the applicable current requirements into play; an old loan does not exempt a newly established customer relationship.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Immediate-family status does not automatically waive notice or approval; firm procedures may waive them.
- The current catch-all requires both same-household residency and material financial support.
Interaction with Other Requirements
The borrowing/lending requirement does not exist in isolation. A borrowing/lending-compliant loan can still violate other requirements:
| Conduct | Potential Charges |
|---|---|
| Qualifying family loan, but the representative uses wrongful pressure or deception to obtain it | Loan compliance does not excuse a separate commercial-honor concern |
| Loan from a customer without firm procedures permitting it | Borrowing/lending failure; separate improper-use or commercial-honor claims depend on the conduct |
| Loan reported to firm but not in writing as WSPs require | Borrowing/lending notice or approval defect; assess any separate commercial-honor concern on its own facts |
| Loan from a customer-friend without required prior written notice and approval, plus a compensated private securities transaction without prior written notice | Separate borrowing/lending and private-securities-transaction failures; assess commercial-honor exposure on the conduct facts |
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Every exception requires firm procedures permitting the activity; a family loan does not waive separate conduct duties.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you name the five exception categories to the borrowing and lending prohibition, and confirm each requires the firm's WSPs to permit it?
- Do you know the modernized immediate-family definition replaced spouse or domestic partner for husband or wife, and added step and adoptive relationships?
- Can you state the "any other person" catch-all now requires both same-household residency and material financial support, not just one?
- Can you distinguish new arrangements, new broker-customer relationships and later modifications of older arrangements from unchanged older loans that are not retroactively subject to the amendments?