Quick Answer
The FINRA fiduciary-information requirement prohibits a member firm that obtains information about the ownership of securities in a fiduciary capacity (paying agent, transfer agent, or trustee) from using that information to solicit purchases, sales, or exchanges. The only exception: solicitation at the request and on behalf of the issuer is permitted (e.g., a tender offer or proxy solicitation).
A firm that acts as a transfer agent sees holder lists and beneficial-owner data that no retail competitor can access. The fiduciary-information prohibition prevents the firm from monetizing that data through its retail brokerage division.
The Rule
A member who, in the capacity of paying agent, transfer agent, trustee, or any similar fiduciary capacity, has received information about the ownership of securities shall not use that information to solicit purchases, sales, or exchanges.
The prohibited capacities include:
- Paying agent (firm that disburses dividends, interest, or principal on behalf of the issuer)
- Transfer agent (firm that maintains the issuer's record of shareholders and processes ownership changes)
- Trustee (firm acting under a bond indenture or trust agreement)
- Any similar fiduciary capacity (proxy solicitor on behalf of the issuer, escrow agent, dividend reinvestment plan administrator)
The information protected (ownership-of-securities data obtained in a fiduciary capacity):
- Identity of the security holders
- Quantity of securities held
- Account-level ownership data not available to the public
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The protected data is securities-ownership information obtained in a fiduciary capacity, not every fact a fiduciary learns.
The Issuer-Solicitation Exception
Solicitation at the request and on behalf of the issuer is permitted. Examples:
- A tender-offer solicitation conducted by the issuer (the firm contacts holders to encourage tender)
- A proxy-vote solicitation conducted by the issuer in advance of a shareholder meeting
- A rights-offering solicitation conducted by the issuer
The fiduciary firm acts as the issuer's agent in these contexts; the issuer is the principal directing the use of its own holder data.
The Use-Based Test
The fiduciary-information prohibition turns on the use of fiduciary-derived information, not its acquisition. The information may have been lawfully obtained in the fiduciary capacity. The violation is using it for a non-issuer solicitation purpose.
| Activity | Fiduciary Capacity | Solicitation | Violates the prohibition? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Firm uses its transfer-agent holder list for Issuer Y to select Customer X for a call recommending a sale of Y shares | Transfer agent | Retail brokerage's own solicitation | YES |
| Firm uses its paying-agent holder list for Issuer Y to select Customer X for a call recommending Y bonds | Paying agent | Retail brokerage's own solicitation | YES |
| Firm acts as transfer agent for Issuer Y; firm contacts Customer X to tender Y shares in Issuer Y's tender offer | Transfer agent | At the request of the issuer | NO (exception applies) |
| Firm acts as paying agent for Issuer Y; a research piece naming Y's largest bondholders from the agent file goes to retail clients and prospects to prompt trades in Y bonds | Paying agent | Firm's own solicitation | YES |
| Firm has Customer X as a retail brokerage client; retail division calls Customer X about Issuer Y | Not a fiduciary | Retail brokerage's own solicitation | NO (The fiduciary-information prohibition not triggered) |
Think of it this way: The firm cannot pass a transfer-agent holder list to the retail desk for the desk's own solicitation campaign. Solicitation using that information requires the issuer's request and action on its behalf. Independently sourced recommendations do not become prohibited merely because the firm also acts as transfer agent.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Lawful receipt of fiduciary ownership data does not authorize its use to solicit purchases, sales or exchanges.
- Planning a sales campaign using the data is use for solicitation even before a call; a second list does not cure that targeting.
- The exception requires solicitation at the issuer’s request and on its behalf; independently sourced solicitation is distinct.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you name the fiduciary capacities covered: paying agent, transfer agent, trustee, and any similar fiduciary capacity?
- Do you know the fiduciary-information prohibition triggers on the use of ownership data, not on how it was lawfully obtained?
- Can you state the only exception: solicitation at the request and on behalf of the issuer, such as a tender offer?
- Can you distinguish a firm's own retail solicitation using fiduciary data from a solicitation the issuer directs, such as a proxy vote?