Quick Answer
Insider trading is governed by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (SEA) antifraud rule, the prearranged trading plan affirmative-defense conditions, duties of trust or confidence, and the broker-dealer information-barrier requirement. The SEC may seek a civil penalty up to three times a violator's profit gained or loss avoided. Private contemporaneous-trader damages and controlling-person penalties follow separate requirements.
The Series 24 expects principals to know how awareness and duties affect insider trading, what firms must do to prevent misuse of MNPI, and how SEC penalties differ from private damages.
The Prearranged Trading Plan Rule: Trading "On the Basis Of" MNPI
A purchase or sale is "on the basis of" material nonpublic information if the trader was aware of the MNPI at the time of the trade. Awareness alone is sufficient; the SEC does not need to prove the MNPI motivated the trade.
The Prearranged-Plan Affirmative Defense
The trader is not "on the basis of" MNPI if, before becoming aware of the information, the person:
- Entered into a binding contract to purchase or sell the security
- Instructed another person to purchase or sell the security for the trader's account
- Adopted a written prearranged trading plan for trading the security
Only the third alternative must be written. The rule does not require a binding contract or an instruction to another person to be in writing.
All three alternatives must meet the same conditions:
- Specify the amount, price, and date of trades, or include a written formula or algorithm for these terms, or not permit the trader to influence trades after adoption
- Be made in good faith
Plan Conditions
The SEC tightened the prearranged-plan conditions. The current conditions:
| Plan Condition | Officers and Directors | Other Insiders | Issuers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cooling-off period before first trade | For a domestic issuer, the later of 90 calendar days after adoption or 2 business days after Form 10-Q or 10-K disclosure of results for the completed fiscal quarter in which the arrangement was adopted; capped at 120 calendar days after adoption | 30 days after adoption | None mandated under the rule |
| Good-faith requirement | Required at adoption AND throughout the plan | Required at adoption AND throughout the plan | Required at adoption AND throughout the plan |
| Written certification at adoption | Required: (1) not aware of MNPI, (2) adopting in good faith and not as part of a scheme to evade the antifraud rule | Not required | Not required |
| Overlapping-plan restriction | Generally one plan at a time | Generally one plan at a time | Multiple plans permitted |
| Single-transaction affirmative-defense condition | No other qualifying single-transaction arrangement adopted during the prior 12 months | No other qualifying single-transaction arrangement adopted during the prior 12 months | Does not apply |
For foreign private issuers, the officer/director disclosure branch uses the specified Form 20-F or Form 6-K financial-results disclosure. An earlier quarter's results do not supply the adoption-quarter event.
The single-transaction condition concerns qualifying open-market arrangements designed to execute their entire purchase or sale as one transaction and excludes eligible sell-to-cover arrangements. It limits the affirmative defense, not adoption of every other plan.
Effect of a False Certification
The officer or director certification is a condition of the affirmative defense. If the officer was aware of MNPI on the adoption date, the certification is untrue and the defense is unavailable. A signature does not protect the officer. The rule does not create a separate charge for the false certification. A false statement can still bring separate exposure under other law.
Effect of Plan Modification
A change to the amount, price or timing of purchases or sales terminates the old arrangement and constitutes adoption of a new one. The new arrangement must satisfy the pre-awareness requirement and applicable cooling-off period. A broker substitution retaining the trading instructions does not by itself create that event. An administrative label does not excuse changed instructions, prohibited influence, bad faith or another unmet defense condition.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- A plan provides an affirmative defense only when all applicable conditions are met; amount, price or timing changes create a new arrangement.
- Officer/director cooling-off uses the later of 90 calendar days or two business days after adoption-quarter results disclosure, capped at 120 days.
The Misappropriation Theory Extension to Non-Business Relationships
The family-and-non-business-relationship insider-trading rule defines circumstances creating a duty of trust or confidence for misappropriation insider-trading liability. Misappropriation turns on deception of the information's source through trading in breach of that duty. The source can be the issuer or another person, and the classical and misappropriation theories can overlap.
A duty exists when:
- The person agrees to maintain information in confidence
- The persons have a history, pattern, or practice of sharing confidences such that the recipient knows or reasonably should know the speaker expects confidentiality
- The information comes from a spouse, parent, child, or sibling (presumption of confidentiality)
Misappropriation vs Classical Theory
| Theory | Source of MNPI | Whose Duty Is Breached | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classical (Cady, Roberts) theory | Issuer (a corporate or qualifying temporary insider obtains its confidential information) | Insider's duty to shareholders | CEO trades before earnings release |
| Misappropriation theory | A source to whom the recipient owes a duty of trust or confidence, including the issuer | Recipient's duty to the source | Lawyer trades on client information |
The misappropriation theory closes the gap left by classical insider trading: a person who is not an insider of the issuer can still be liable if they breach a duty to the source of the information.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The specified family relationships create a rebuttable presumption of a confidence duty.
- Misappropriation can involve a duty to an information source without a relationship to the issuer.
The Information-Barrier Requirement
Every registered broker-dealer must establish, maintain, and enforce written policies and procedures reasonably designed to prevent the misuse of MNPI by the firm or any associated person.
The policies must reflect the firm's specific business:
- Investment-banking firms need stricter information barriers between IB (the side that learns deal-specific MNPI) and trading and research (the public side)
- Pure retail firms can have simpler procedures because they are less likely to encounter MNPI in the ordinary course
Common elements of an information-barrier program:
- Watch list (deals the firm is working on, monitored but trading not yet restricted; CONFIDENTIAL within compliance)
- Restricted list (issuers the firm cannot trade for the firm or its customers without compliance approval; usually publicly disseminated within the firm)
- Physical and electronic access controls (separate file rooms, locked drawers, IT-segregated systems)
- Employee-trading reviews under the supervisory transaction-review framework
- Trade-monitoring surveillance that flags trades by personnel with potential MNPI access
Compliance should assess list treatment using the firm's activities and the MNPI it still holds. A public deal announcement prompts review rather than automatically ending restrictions: the firm may still know nonpublic developments or earnings information. No universal watch-to-restricted sequence follows merely from an announcement.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The information-barrier duty requires written policies and procedures that are established, maintained and enforced.
- The watch list is confidential within compliance; the restricted list is communicated firm-wide.
Liability to Contemporaneous Traders
The contemporaneous-trader civil liability provision creates a private right of action: any person who violates the Exchange Act or rules thereunder by trading on MNPI is liable to any person who, contemporaneously with the violation, traded the same class of security on the other side of the market.
- "Contemporaneously" is interpreted by courts to mean roughly the same trading day or short window
- Damages are capped at the profit gained or loss avoided by the violator
- The action is independent of SEC enforcement; private plaintiffs can sue without waiting for the SEC
- Private damages must be diminished by qualifying disgorgement required under a federal court order obtained at the SEC's instance in its enforcement proceeding for the same transactions. This does not automatically apply to voluntary payments or administrative orders, and SEC civil penalties do not reduce private damages
- The action must be brought within 5 years after the date of the last transaction in the violation
Can a Private Plaintiff Name the Firm?
A firm is not liable to contemporaneous traders solely because it employs the violator. A private plaintiff can still reach the firm as a controlling person. That liability is subject to the Exchange Act's general controlling-person provision. Under it, the firm is liable jointly and severally with the violator unless the firm acted in good faith and did not directly or indirectly induce the violation.
- The private suit's damages cap (profit gained or loss avoided) still applies
- The SEC penalty test (knew or recklessly disregarded, and failed to take preventive steps) is a separate test for SEC penalties. It is not the test for a private suit
- A firm with real, enforced information barriers is better placed to show good faith
SEC Civil Penalties for Insider Trading
For a covered insider-trading violation, the SEC may seek a civil penalty up to three times the violator's profit gained or loss avoided. The court determines the penalty in light of the facts and circumstances. This is an enforcement penalty, not private treble damages.
Controlling-Person Liability
The SEC must establish control and one of two statutory routes:
- Knowledge or reckless disregard that the controlled person was likely to engage in the violation, plus failure to take appropriate steps to prevent it before it occurred
- A knowing or reckless failure to establish, maintain or enforce required policies or procedures that substantially contributed to or permitted the violation
Employment or knowledge of a surveillance gap alone does not establish the complete test.
The controlling person's maximum penalty is the greater of the applicable inflation-adjusted fixed component or three times the controlled person's profit gained or loss avoided. For penalties imposed after January 15, 2025 for violations after November 2, 2015, the fixed component is $2,626,135. The SEC made no adjustment for 2026. Earlier violations use the applicable earlier schedule.
The fixed component belongs to the maximum calculation; it is not a mandatory minimum penalty. A controlling-person penalty is separate from the violator's own penalty and from private damages.
Statute of Limitations
The SEC may bring an insider-trading civil penalty action up to 5 years from the date of the trade.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Controlling-person penalties require an applicable statutory liability route and compare the fixed component with three times the controlled person’s gain or avoided loss.
- Private contemporaneous-trader actions and SEC civil-penalty actions have separate requirements.
SEC Investigations, Injunctions, and Prosecution Powers
The Exchange Act's general enforcement provision authorizes the SEC to:
- Conduct investigations of suspected Exchange Act violations
- Issue subpoenas for testimony and documents
- Seek injunctions in federal court to halt ongoing violations
- Refer matters for criminal prosecution by the Department of Justice
The SEC investigates, seeks authorized insider-trading civil penalties, and may refer matters to the Department of Justice for criminal prosecution. A criminal case requires its own legal basis and proof.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you identify the officer/director disclosure event as results for the completed fiscal quarter of adoption, then apply the later-of-90-days-or-2-business-days formula and 120-day cap from adoption?
- Can you distinguish amount, price or timing changes requiring a new qualifying arrangement from a genuinely administrative broker substitution retaining instructions?
- Can you distinguish the watch list, which stays confidential within compliance, from the restricted list, which is firm-wide and communicated to the desks?
- Can you state the SEC's insider-trading civil penalty: up to three times the profit gained or loss avoided, brought within 5 years of the trade?