Misuse of Customer Assets

Quick Answer

The FINRA customer-assets prohibition bars improper use, guarantees against loss, and unauthorized sharing. Contribution-based sharing requires prior written firm and customer authorizations plus direct proportionality, with immediate-family relief from proportionality. Separate advisory performance compensation requires both authorizations and all applicable performance-fee conditions.

The misuse-of-customer-assets prohibition is the most direct trust-violation rule in the FINRA conduct rules. A registered person who borrows from a customer's account, promises to cover losses, or splits profits without authorization violates the rule even if the customer was not financially harmed and even if the customer agreed.


The Improper-Use Prohibition

No member or associated person may make improper use of a customer's securities or funds. The rule applies to any control over customer assets, including discretionary authority, beneficial-interest authority, and operational handling.

"Improper use" includes:

  • Unauthorized borrowing of customer securities or funds for any purpose, including short-term loans the registered person intends to repay
  • Pledging fully paid or excess margin securities that must remain in possession or control, without an applicable compliant securities-lending arrangement or other exception
  • Commingling customer assets with the associated person's own accounts, or using customer cash for the firm's own purposes (such as payroll or firm trading), which the SEC customer-protection rule does not allow
  • Using customer assets for personal purposes, including paying personal expenses or trading for the registered person's own account

Under the customer-protection reserve formula, amounts included in customer credit items may be used only for the specified debit-item purposes. The excess of credits over debits must remain in the required reserve account; the formula does not authorize funding the firm's own expenses.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Short-term unauthorized borrowing can be improper use even when repayment is intended.
  • Customer cash used for firm expenses can also violate the separate customer-protection rule.

Collateral market value is not the customer's debit balance. Excess margin securities are identified using 140% of the customer's debit balance. With a $300,000 debit and $750,000 in securities, $330,000 is above the $420,000 margin-securities amount and requires possession or control, absent an applicable exception. Do not treat every dollar of collateral value above the debit as forbidden, or confuse that market-value test with separate limits on bank-loan principal secured by customer securities.


The Prohibition Against Guarantees

No member or associated person may guarantee a customer against loss in connection with any securities transaction or any securities account.

  • The prohibition covers express guarantees ("I will cover any loss") and implicit promises (verbal or written assurances that loss is impossible)
  • A guarantee is a violation regardless of whether a loss ever occurs. A rep who tells a customer "you cannot lose money on this trade" violates the guarantee prohibition even if the trade is profitable
  • A guarantee is a violation regardless of whether the firm's policies allow it. Individual reps cannot guarantee loss prevention even if the firm has not specifically prohibited it

Limited Safe Harbors

A member firm (not the associated person personally) may, on an after-the-fact basis:

  • Reimburse a customer for transaction losses (subject to applicable reporting, e.g., reporting as a settlement on the customer's account history)
  • Correct a bona fide error (an operational mistake by the firm or its agents)

These are two separate permissions. The firm does not need a bona fide error to reimburse a transaction loss after the fact, and the firm can correct a bona fide error without waiting for a complaint. Either way, the safe harbors apply only to the firm acting as a corporate entity. A registered person's personal promise to cover losses is never within the safe harbor.

Think of it this way: The firm can pay the customer back after a trade goes wrong. The rep cannot promise upfront that the firm or the rep will pay if a trade goes wrong. The first is a settlement; the second is a guarantee.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A representative cannot guarantee against loss even if no loss occurs.
  • A firm’s after-the-fact reimbursement or bona fide error correction differs from a representative’s pre-trade promise.

The Sharing-in-Customer-Accounts Prohibition

The general prohibition: No member or associated person may share, directly or indirectly, in the profits or losses of a customer's account.

Contribution-Based Sharing

A registered person using this permission must obtain both authorizations in advance:

  1. Prior written authorization of the member firm
  2. Prior written authorization of the customer

Plus the Proportionality Requirement

Under the contribution-based sharing permission, even with both written authorizations, the registered person's share of profits and losses must be in direct proportion to the registered person's financial contribution to the account.

This is an exact match, not a ceiling: a rep who funds 60% but takes 40% still fails this test for a non-family customer. A 10% contribution paired with a 50/50 split fails for the same reason.

The Immediate-Family Exception to Proportionality

The proportionate-contribution requirement does NOT apply to accounts of the registered person's immediate family.

This permission sets three conditions for sharing: prior written firm authorization, prior written customer authorization, and proportionate contribution. The family exemption lifts only the third one. Waiving proportionality does not make the firm's approval automatic.

  • "Immediate family" for sharing-in-account purposes includes parents, a mother-in-law or father-in-law, a husband or wife, children, and any relative to whose support the registered person contributes, directly or indirectly
  • This list is narrower than the borrowing/lending definition. It names no sibling, brother- or sister-in-law, son- or daughter-in-law, grandparent or domestic partner, so one of those relatives qualifies only if the registered person contributes to that relative's support. Do not carry the borrowing/lending list over to sharing
  • The family member must still grant the authorization, and the firm must still approve in writing

The following examples use the contribution-based sharing permission.

Sharing ScenarioFirm Written OK?Customer Written OK?Proportionate?Permitted?
Outside customer, 50/50 split, rep funds 10%YesYesNoNO (fails proportionality)
Outside customer, 50/50 split, rep funds 50%YesYesYesYes
Outside customer, 50/50 split, rep funds 50%NoYesYesNO (fails firm approval)
Spouse account, 50/50 split, rep funds 10%YesYesNoYes (immediate-family exception)
Spouse account, 50/50 split, rep funds 10%NoYesNoNO (still needs firm approval)
Sister's account (rep does not support her), 50/50 split, rep funds 10%YesYesNoNO (a sibling is not on the sharing rule's family list)

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Contribution-based sharing requires prior written firm and customer authorizations and, for non-family customers, direct proportionality.
  • Immediate-family relief waives proportionality only; both prior written authorizations remain required.

Separate Advisory Performance Compensation

An associated person acting as an investment adviser may receive compensation based on account profits or gains if they obtain prior written firm and customer authorizations and meet all applicable Advisers Act performance-fee conditions. This separate permission does not require a matching capital contribution.

A member firm acting as an investment adviser may also use this permission with prior written customer authorization and those performance-fee conditions. Adviser status alone is insufficient.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Do you know the improper-use prohibition reaches even short-term unauthorized borrowing a registered person intends to repay?
  • Can you state that a guarantee against loss is a violation regardless of whether a loss ever occurs, even if the trade turns out profitable?
  • Can you distinguish a firm's after-the-fact reimbursement of a loss, which is allowed, from a rep's pre-trade promise to cover losses, which is not?
  • Can you distinguish contribution-based sharing, with both prior written authorizations and applicable proportionality, from separate advisory performance compensation that requires both authorizations and all applicable performance-fee conditions?