Code of Arbitration Procedure

Quick Answer

FINRA runs two parallel arbitration codes: Customer Code (customer vs. member/AP) and Industry Code (member/AP). Customers may compel arbitration unilaterally, without a predispute agreement. Claims of $50,000 or less, exclusive of interest and expenses, get simplified arbitration: one arbitrator decides on the pleadings unless the customer (Industry Code: the claimant) requests a hearing.

The arbitration codes handle the bulk of customer and intra-industry private disputes, distinct from the regulatory disciplinary process driven by FINRA investigations and the Code of Procedure.


Two Parallel Codes

CodeScope
Customer CodeDisputes between customers and members or APs
Industry CodeDisputes among or between members and APs (employment, partner separations, branch transitions, compensation, Form U5 defamation)

The two codes have parallel structure with corresponding provisions. For example, the customer-arbitration mandate parallels the industry-arbitration mandate, and the customer-side simplified arbitration parallels the industry-side simplified arbitration.

Most provisions match, but some details differ, such as who may request a simplified hearing and which respondents qualify for default proceedings. Both are FINRA arbitration codes, so the difference between them is the parties and disputes each covers, not who runs the arbitration.


Failure to Act Under the Codes

The Interpretive Material to each code states that it may be deemed conduct inconsistent with just and equitable principles of trade, and a violation of FINRA's standards of commercial honor, for a member or AP to:

  • Fail to submit a dispute for arbitration as the Code requires
  • Fail to comply with an injunctive order issued under the Code
  • Fail to appear or to produce a document in the person's possession or control as directed under the Code
  • Fail to honor an award, or comply with a written and executed settlement agreement obtained in an arbitration, where no timely motion has been made to vacate or modify the award
  • Fail to comply with a written and executed settlement agreement obtained in a FINRA mediation

Awards must be honored by a cash payment of the exact dollar amount stated in the award, upon receipt or within any other period the award prescribes. Crediting the prevailing party's account does not honor an award unless the award expressly authorizes it or the parties consent in writing.

The same material states that it may be deemed a violation for a member to require APs to waive arbitration contrary to the Code.

Expedited Suspension for an Unpaid Award

FINRA's expedited suspension proceeding for unpaid awards lets FINRA act faster than an ordinary disciplinary case. FINRA staff may serve written notice that failure to comply within 21 days of service will result in a suspension or cancellation of membership or a suspension from associating with any member.

  • The suspension or cancellation takes effect 21 days after service unless the respondent requests a hearing, which stays it
  • For an award or related settlement involving a customer, a claim of inability to pay is no defense (since July 2, 2010)
  • Four defenses remain: the respondent paid the award in full or fully complied with the settlement; the claimant agreed to installment payments or otherwise settled; the respondent filed a timely motion to vacate or modify that has not been denied; or a bankruptcy proceeding is pending or the bankruptcy court has discharged the award
  • This regulatory path runs in addition to the customer's separate path through the courts

Agreement of the Parties

Where the Code itself provides that the parties may agree to modify a provision of the Code, or a decision of the Director or the panel, the written agreement of all named parties is required. The Director or the panel may dispense with the agreement of a party that is inactive or has failed to respond after adequate notice, while it stays that way.

The power to modify is limited to the choices the Code offers. Nothing in the Code lets the parties pull a claim above $50,000 into simplified arbitration, so a $60,000 claim stays under the regular procedure even if both sides agree.

The agreement-of-the-parties rule says nothing about waiving the FINRA forum. That limit comes from other rules:

  • Customers: FINRA's predispute-arbitration agreement rule bars, among other conditions, any predispute agreement condition that limits or contradicts the rules of a self-regulatory organization or limits a party's ability to file any claim in arbitration. In FINRA's view, a customer's right to request FINRA arbitration at any time cannot be superseded by a separate agreement, such as a forum selection clause
  • Associated persons: FINRA considers a member that requires APs to waive Industry Code arbitration at FINRA in a predispute agreement to have violated FINRA rules (covered under Industry Arbitration)

Some federal appeals courts have enforced forum selection clauses against these rights, and FINRA has stated it disagrees. For the exam, know FINRA's position: requiring the waiver is a rule violation.


Customer Arbitration (Unilateral Right)

Parties must arbitrate a customer dispute under the Customer Code if:

  • Arbitration is required by a written agreement between the parties, OR
  • The customer requests arbitration, AND
  • The dispute is between a customer and a member or AP, AND
  • The dispute arises in connection with the business activities of the member or AP, except insurance business activities of a member that is also an insurance company

The Unilateral Customer Right

Customers have a unilateral right to compel arbitration at FINRA against members and APs, even without a written predispute agreement.

  • The customer can demand arbitration; the member must comply
  • The reverse is not true: a member cannot compel a customer to FINRA arbitration absent a written agreement requiring arbitration, such as a predispute arbitration agreement the customer signed
  • This is the asymmetry that defines the customer-vs-broker arbitration system

Elective Arbitration

Parties may agree in writing, after the dispute arises, to submit a dispute to FINRA arbitration that is otherwise not required to be arbitrated.

  • Elective arbitration needs a dispute between a customer and a member, AP, or other related party, arising in connection with a member's or AP's business activities. Consent does not replace customer status
  • Example: A customer has a dispute with a related party that is neither a member nor an AP, arising from a member's securities business. Their written post-dispute agreement can provide an elective route when the mandatory customer-arbitration rule does not reach that related party
  • The insurance-business exclusion for a member that is also an insurance company applies to elective arbitration too. Written post-dispute consent does not bring an excluded insurance-business dispute into FINRA arbitration
  • A service-contract dispute between a member and an outside vendor that is neither a customer, member nor AP is outside both codes. Neither the Industry Code nor elective arbitration brings it into FINRA

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A customer can demand arbitration of a qualifying dispute without a predispute agreement; the member cannot compel the customer without a written agreement.
  • The insurance exception concerns insurance business of a member that is also an insurance company; a fixed annuity alone does not establish it.

Industry Arbitration (Mandatory)

Except as otherwise provided in the Code, disputes must be arbitrated under the Industry Code if:

  • The dispute arises out of the business activities of a member or AP, AND
  • Is between or among members, members and APs, or APs

One exception: disputes arising out of the insurance business activities of a member that is also an insurance company are not required to be arbitrated under the Code.

Common Industry-Code Disputes

  • Employment claims: compensation disputes, defamation on Form U5, restrictive covenants, breach of employment contract
  • Branch-separation / promissory-note disputes: a rep who leaves a firm and is then sued on a promissory note tied to upfront recruiting compensation
  • Member-vs-member disputes: clearing-firm disputes, branch-transition disputes between firms

The Statutory Discrimination Carve-Out

The Industry Code mandate applies "except as otherwise provided in the Code." One exception covers a claim alleging employment discrimination in violation of a statute.

  • Such a claim is not required to be arbitrated under the Industry Code
  • The claim may be arbitrated only if the parties have agreed to arbitrate it, either before or after the dispute arose
  • A rep who sues a firm for statutory discrimination can therefore go to court unless an agreement sends the claim to FINRA arbitration
  • The carve-out reaches the discrimination claim only. A compensation, contract, or Form U5 defamation claim in the same dispute stays inside the mandate

Predispute Waivers Are Themselves Violations

FINRA considers a member that requires APs to waive their right to Industry Code arbitration at FINRA in a predispute agreement to have violated the industry-arbitration mandate, and to have acted inconsistently with just and equitable principles of trade.

  • A member firm that puts a "you must arbitrate at AAA / JAMS / a state court" clause in its rep employment contracts is, in FINRA's view, violating FINRA rules
  • In FINRA's view the Industry Code requirement to arbitrate at FINRA cannot be waived in advance of a dispute; a federal appeals court has held otherwise, and FINRA disagrees
  • FINRA recommends a non-exclusive forum selection clause that states it does not prohibit the AP from filing a FINRA arbitration claim

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Statutory employment discrimination claims require agreement to arbitrate; otherwise-mandatory compensation and Form U5 defamation claims remain subject to the Code.
  • FINRA treats a required predispute waiver of an associated person’s Industry Code arbitration right as a rule violation.

Six-Year Eligibility Limit and Former APs

Each Code bars a claim from arbitration once six years have elapsed from the occurrence or event giving rise to the claim. The arbitration panel decides any question about eligibility.

  • The six years run from the event, not from the date the AP left the firm and not from the date the customer found the problem
  • This is an eligibility limit on the FINRA forum. A claim dismissed as ineligible may still be pursued in court
  • A former AP is treated as an AP under the Code. A customer can arbitrate a claim about the former AP's conduct while registered, if the claim is still eligible
  • Ending registration does not end the customer-arbitration mandate. The six-year clock is the limit, not the AP's departure

FINRA's 2-year tail over former APs is a different rule. It limits when FINRA may file a disciplinary complaint or demand information after registration ends (see FINRA Investigations). It does not set customer-arbitration eligibility.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The six-year arbitration eligibility period runs from the event, not registration termination; it is distinct from the disciplinary tail.

Simplified Arbitration

For claims involving $50,000 or less, exclusive of interest and expenses, the Codes apply a simplified arbitration procedure.

RequirementDetail
Threshold$50,000 or less, exclusive of interest and expenses
ArbitratorA single arbitrator appointed from the FINRA chairperson roster (a public arbitrator under the Customer Code), unless the parties agree in writing otherwise
HearingNo hearing by default; the arbitrator decides on pleadings and submitted materials
Who may request a hearingUnder the Customer Code, only the customer; under the Industry Code, the claimant
No prehearing conferenceIf no hearing is requested, no prehearing conference is held
Claim increased above $50,000If any pleading raises the amount in dispute above $50,000, the case leaves simplified arbitration and the regular provisions of the Code apply

Customer Control of the Hearing Right

In a Customer Code simplified arbitration, the customer retains the right to demand a hearing. The respondent member does not have an equivalent unilateral right to demand a hearing. Members preparing for $50K-or-less customer claims should expect the customer to control whether there is a hearing.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • For claims of $50,000 or less excluding interest and expenses, Customer Code simplified arbitration is decided on papers unless the customer requests a hearing.

Default Proceedings

A claimant may request default proceedings against a respondent that:

  • Falls within one of the default-proceedings categories, AND
  • Fails to file an answer within the time provided by the Code
RespondentQualifying status
MemberMembership terminated, suspended, canceled, or revoked; the member has been expelled (under the Customer Code, expelled or barred); or the member is otherwise defunct
Associated person (AP)Registration terminated, revoked, or suspended. The Customer Code also reaches an AP whose registration is cancelled or who has been expelled or barred, and a terminated AP regardless of the number of days since termination

An AP whose registration FINRA has suspended is in a qualifying category. If that AP fails to answer a customer's claim in time, the customer may request default proceedings. The reason for the suspension does not matter, and it does not need to relate to the customer's claim.

How Default Proceedings Work

StepDetail
ArbitratorDirector appoints a single arbitrator through the list selection algorithm
HearingNo hearing is held; the arbitrator may ask the claimant for more information
Standard for awardThe arbitrator may NOT issue an award based solely on nonappearance; the claimant must present a sufficient basis to support the award
Damages capDamages awarded may not exceed the amount requested in the statement of claim, and the arbitrator may not award other relief that was not requested. After the Director notifies the parties that the claim proceeds as a default case, the claimant may not amend the claim to increase the relief requested from the defaulting respondent
TerminationIf the defaulting respondent files an answer before an award issues, default proceedings terminate and the case proceeds under the regular Code

The default mechanism handles the practical reality that suspended or expelled firms, and suspended or terminated APs, often disappear from the process. The claimant still has to prove the case on submitted materials; nonappearance is not itself sufficient grounds for an award.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Do you know a customer can compel FINRA arbitration without a predispute agreement, but a member cannot compel a customer without one?
  • Can you state the simplified arbitration threshold: claims of $50,000 or less, exclusive of interest and expenses, get a single arbitrator deciding on the pleadings unless the customer (or, under the Industry Code, the claimant) requests a hearing?
  • Can you distinguish disputes the Industry Code requires, such as compensation and Form U5 defamation, from statutory discrimination claims, which are not required to be arbitrated?
  • Do you know an arbitrator in a default proceeding may not award damages based solely on the respondent's nonappearance?
  • Can you state the six-year arbitration eligibility limit, say when it starts, and tell it apart from FINRA's 2-year tail over former APs?