Quick Answer
FINRA's Code of Procedure sends Department of Enforcement complaints to a Hearing Panel (a Hearing Officer plus two industry panelists), which issues a written or default decision if the respondent fails to appear. Either side may appeal to the National Adjudicatory Council (NAC) within 25 days, then to the FINRA Board, SEC, and U.S. Court of Appeals.
The Code of Procedure is what happens after a FINRA investigation produces evidence the Department of Enforcement believes warrants formal discipline.
Application of the Code
The Code of Procedure governs FINRA proceedings for:
- Disciplining members and associated persons (APs), including review by the NAC and the FINRA Board, and applications to the SEC for review
- Regulating the activities of members experiencing financial or operational difficulties
- Suspensions, cancellations, and bars, including expedited proceedings for failure to comply with FINRA information requests, failure to pay fines, and other procedural defaults
The Code is the procedural backbone for everything from a routine disciplinary case to a financial-condition emergency action.
Definitions, Service, and Conduct
- Definitions: The Code's definitional vocabulary parallels the investigations framework's terminology: Adjudicator, Department of Enforcement, Hearing Officer, Hearing Panel, Office of Hearing Officers (OHO), National Adjudicatory Council (NAC)
- Service; Filing of Papers: The Code specifies how the Department of Enforcement and respondents serve and file papers (hand delivery, mail, overnight courier, or electronic methods authorized by FINRA)
- Proceedings: General provisions govern the conduct of disciplinary proceedings (representation, ex parte communications, motions practice, conduct standards)
Complaint and Answer
The disciplinary case starts when the Department of Enforcement files a complaint with the Office of Hearing Officers (OHO).
| Step | Detail |
|---|---|
| Authorization | The complaint may be authorized by the Office of Disciplinary Affairs when Enforcement believes a violation has occurred or is occurring |
| Filing | Department of Enforcement files the complaint with OHO; Hearing Officer assigned |
| Answer | Each respondent serves an answer on the other parties within 25 days after service of the complaint and files it with OHO; the Hearing Officer may extend the period for good cause |
| Content of the answer | Admit, deny, or state a lack of information for each allegation; an allegation not denied is deemed admitted, and affirmative defenses must be raised in the answer |
| Late answer | Enforcement sends a second notice requiring an answer within 14 days; continued failure allows the Hearing Officer to treat the allegations as admitted and issue a default decision |
| Amendment | Complaint may be amended; the answer period is the greater of the original period or 14 days after service of the amended complaint |
The complaint mirrors a civil pleading: it identifies the respondent, recites the alleged violations, cites the rules violated, and states the relief sought (sanctions).
Settling Without a Hearing
A member or associated person who does not dispute a violation can resolve it by letter instead of litigating:
| Route | What It Does |
|---|---|
| Acceptance, Waiver, and Consent (AWC) | Accepts a finding of violation, consents to the sanctions, and waives a hearing and any appeal to the NAC, the SEC and the courts. Once accepted, it is deemed the complaint, answer and decision |
| Minor rule violation plan letter | For a violation of a rule on FINRA's minor-rule list, FINRA or the NAC may impose a fine of no more than $2,500 and/or a censure, with the same waivers |
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The complaint answer and Hearing Panel appeal each have a 25-day period, measured from service of the respective document.
- A missed answer prompts a second notice with 14 more days; negotiations do not pause the clock, but an accepted AWC resolves it.
Appointment of the Hearing Panel
A Hearing Panel consists of:
- A Hearing Officer who is an attorney appointed by the Chief Hearing Officer and chairs the panel, handling procedural and evidentiary issues. The definition permits a current FINRA employee or a former FINRA employee who previously acted as a Hearing Officer
- Two eligible industry panelists associated with a FINRA member or retired from that association, who also meet the specified committee, council or board-service criteria. A professional title or industry experience alone does not establish eligibility
The Chief Hearing Officer may designate an Extended Hearing after considering the complexity of the issues, probable hearing length or other material factors. An Extended Hearing Panel normally has the same three-person composition: one Hearing Officer chair and two eligible panelists. Extended designation does not add voting seats. Specified withdrawal and replacement provisions can affect participation in either type of panel.
Why the Panel Composition Matters
- The Hearing Officer is a lawyer who handles legal and procedural issues but does not vote on industry-norm questions in isolation
- The two industry panelists provide market expertise; they understand whether the conduct deviates from industry norms
- Decisions are by majority vote of the panel, so a respondent must persuade at least two of three panelists
Discovery
The Code separately governs Enforcement's disclosure obligations and the respondent's discovery rights.
- Enforcement must disclose, among other things, documents and witnesses it intends to use at the hearing
- Enforcement must produce exculpatory or material information in its possession (a Brady-style obligation, narrower than criminal due process but broader than typical civil discovery)
- The respondent has limited discovery rights; FINRA proceedings are not full civil litigation, and the respondent generally cannot depose Enforcement witnesses
Hearing and Decision
Hearings are conducted before the Hearing Panel. The respondent has the right to:
- Present evidence (documents, witness testimony)
- Cross-examine Enforcement's witnesses
- Be represented by counsel
The Decision
The Hearing Officer drafts a written decision that includes:
- Findings of fact (what the panel concluded happened)
- Conclusions (whether the facts violate the cited rules)
- Sanctions imposed
- Effective date
The Hearing Officer prepares the decision, reflecting the panel's majority vote, within 60 days after the final date allowed for filing proposed findings of fact, conclusions of law and post-hearing briefs, or by a date the Chief Hearing Officer sets. The Chief Hearing Officer's date is an alternative deadline, not the start of the 60 days.
When Do Sanctions Take Effect?
Unless the decision itself says otherwise:
- A sanction other than a bar or expulsion takes effect on a date FINRA determines
- A bar or expulsion takes effect immediately once the decision becomes FINRA's final disciplinary action
No fixed 30-day waiting period applies to sanctions.
Default Decisions
A default decision may issue if a respondent fails to answer the complaint, fails to appear at a pre-hearing conference, or fails to appear at a hearing of which the party has due notice.
- Allegations may be deemed admitted
- Sanctions may issue without a full evidentiary hearing
- The respondent may move to set aside the default for good cause, but the standard is demanding
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- A three-person Hearing Panel decides by majority vote; the Hearing Officer has no controlling substantive vote.
- Failure to answer or to appear at a duly noticed conference or hearing can result in default.
Appeal to the National Adjudicatory Council (NAC)
A respondent or the Department of Enforcement may appeal a Hearing Panel decision (or a default decision) to the NAC.
| Requirement | Detail |
|---|---|
| Form | Written notice of appeal |
| Deadline | 25 days after service of the Hearing Panel decision |
| Effect | A timely appeal stays the Hearing Panel decision, including a fine, until the NAC decides or, if the FINRA Board calls the case for review, until the Board decides; a permanent cease-and-desist order is not stayed |
| Ordinary decision call-for-review | A NAC member or authorized Review Subcommittee member may call a Hearing Panel decision within 45 days after service; the NAC reviews it |
| Default decision call-for-review | The General Counsel may call a default decision within 25 days after service; the Review Subcommittee or NAC reviews it |
If all appeals and cross-appeals are withdrawn, the applicable 45-day or 25-day call-for-review period instead starts when FINRA receives the last filed withdrawal notice. This does not create a new party appeal period.
What the NAC Can Do
The NAC may:
- Affirm the Hearing Panel's findings and sanctions
- Modify them
- Reverse them
- Increase or reduce sanctions
- Remand for further proceedings
The NAC's decision is FINRA's final decision on the matter unless the FINRA Board of Governors calls it for discretionary review.
The Code ordinarily uses calendar days. Exclude the triggering day and include the last day, rolling a Saturday, Sunday or federal-holiday ending to the next day that is none of those. For a prescribed period of ten days or less, exclude intermediate Saturdays, Sundays and federal holidays; disregard added mail-service days when testing that ten-day threshold.
Service by USPS first-class, certified or registered mail adds three days to the response period. Do not apply that addition to every delivery method.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Party appeal is due 25 days after service; separate call-for-review periods apply to ordinary and default decisions.
- Apply the Code’s calendar-day, weekend, holiday and qualifying mail adjustments.
- The NAC may increase sanctions as well as affirm, reduce or reverse them.
Discretionary Review by FINRA Board
The FINRA Board of Governors may, on its own motion, call a NAC decision for review.
- The Board may affirm, modify, or reverse the NAC decision
- The respondent does not have a unilateral right to Board review; it is discretionary, called only when the Board chooses to revisit the NAC outcome
Application to SEC for Review
A respondent aggrieved by a final FINRA disciplinary decision may file an application for SEC review.
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| Forum | SEC (the Commissioners and the SEC's adjudication staff) |
| Standard | SEC reviews the FINRA record; new evidence is generally not admitted |
| Outcome | SEC may affirm, modify, reverse, or remand the FINRA decision |
| Deadline | Within 30 days after FINRA's notice of the action is filed with the SEC and received by the aggrieved person, or a longer period the SEC allows |
| Effect of filing | Stays any sanction other than a bar or an expulsion |
| Exhaustion | The SEC will not review a FINRA action if the applicant did not first use FINRA's own review. A respondent who lets the NAC appeal and call-for-review periods pass has not exhausted FINRA review, even though the unappealed Hearing Panel decision has become FINRA's final disciplinary action |
| Further appeal | Decision is appealable to the U.S. Court of Appeals under federal securities laws |
Why the FINRA Record Matters
Because SEC review is not a de novo hearing, the OHO Hearing Panel record is the critical record for any subsequent appeal:
- New evidence is generally not admitted on SEC review
- The SEC reviews whether the FINRA decision was supported by the record
- A respondent who fails to develop a full evidentiary record at OHO has limited later opportunities to introduce new facts
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- SEC review generally uses the FINRA record; new evidence is generally not admitted.
- A final FINRA decision does not itself establish exhaustion of available FINRA review.
The Disciplinary Sequence (End-to-End)
| Stage | Body |
|---|---|
| Investigation | Department of Enforcement |
| Authorization | Office of Disciplinary Affairs |
| Initiation | Department of Enforcement files complaint with OHO |
| Trial | Hearing Panel (1 Hearing Officer + 2 industry panelists) |
| First-level decision | Hearing Officer drafts written decision |
| Internal appeal | National Adjudicatory Council (25-day appeal window) |
| Discretionary review | FINRA Board of Governors |
| External appeal | SEC |
| Final external appeal | U.S. Court of Appeals |
Think of it this way: Investigation produces a complaint; the Hearing Panel is the trial level; the NAC handles internal appeal or review; the FINRA Board may take discretionary review; and the SEC and federal Court of Appeals provide external review. Each route has its own trigger, deadline and conditions. The 25-day party appeal period is not the deadline at every level.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you state that a Hearing Panel decides by majority vote of a Hearing Officer and two industry panelists, so a respondent must persuade two of three?
- Do you know the respondent's deadline to answer a disciplinary complaint, and what follows a missed deadline?
- Do you know the 25-day window to appeal a Hearing Panel decision to the National Adjudicatory Council runs from service of the decision?
- Can you state that the National Adjudicatory Council may increase sanctions on appeal, not just affirm or reduce them?
- Do you know SEC review of a FINRA disciplinary decision is a record review, not a de novo hearing, so new evidence is generally not admitted?