New Product Due Diligence and Approval

Quick Answer

A firm needs written procedures reasonably designed for reviewing new products and must tailor its controls to its business. Review considers mechanics, risks, customer profiles, conflicts and operational capacity. A committee is one approach, not a prescribed structure. Complex products warrant careful due diligence and appropriate training before recommendation.

The new-product review framework is the firm-level gate that feeds the reasonable-basis prong of suitability: a product the firm cannot understand cannot be recommended to anyone.

The reasonable-basis duty also reaches the rep who makes the recommendation. FINRA's suitability rule requires the diligence to give the member or associated person an understanding of the product's potential risks and rewards, so committee paperwork does not excuse a rep who cannot explain the product. Customer-specific suitability is a separate question: whether the product fits this customer's profile.


The Supervisory Mandate

The new-product framework rests on two FINRA requirements covered in detail in the Written Supervisory Procedures and Controls unit:

  • The FINRA supervisory system requirement directs each member to establish and maintain a supervisory system reasonably designed to achieve compliance with securities laws and FINRA rules, backed by written procedures the firm must also enforce. The duty extends to the products and services the firm offers
  • The FINRA internal supervisory controls requirement directs designated principals to test and verify that the firm's written supervisory procedures (WSPs), including new-product procedures, are reasonably designed; results feed an annual report to senior management

Together, the supervisory system and internal supervisory controls requirements require the firm to define how products are vetted, who approves, what training is required, and how risk is reassessed post-launch through written procedures that are then tested and reported.


The New-Product Review Committee

A firm should review new products and material modifications before offering them. FINRA describes a formal committee as a practice used by some firms; the appropriate process depends on the firm's size, structure and operations.

Committee Composition

The committee should include representatives from all relevant business areas:

  • Compliance, Legal, Risk Management
  • Finance, Operations, Trading
  • Marketing, Sales Supervision
  • At least one member of senior management with formal decision-making authority

The firm may also consult outside counsel or other outside advisors. That advice informs the review, but it does not replace the committee's own decision. Under FINRA's supervisory-system requirement, final responsibility for proper supervision rests with the member, so a law firm's sign-off never becomes the firm's approval.

Possible Outcomes

A committee or other decision-making group can approve, disapprove, or table a proposal. Approval may be conditioned on limitations, including:

  • Restrictions on whom the product may be sold to (e.g., speculative-objective customers only, minimum net worth, accredited-investor only)
  • Mandatory training for any rep selling the product
  • Holding-period or rebalancing alerts for time-sensitive products (e.g., daily-reset leveraged ETFs)
  • Limited rollout to a subset of branches or producers before broader release

Each condition limits how the firm sells the product. A condition cannot change the product's own terms or promise customers that principal will not decline. Principal protection that an issuer builds into a note is a product feature. The committee evaluates it, and FINRA flags protection that is conditional, partial, or withdrawable as a complexity risk.

Later sales material requires its own communications review. Retail communications generally need an appropriately qualified registered principal's approval before the earlier of use or filing with FINRA, subject to applicable exceptions and alternative approval routes. Product approval alone does not satisfy that requirement.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Review material modifications based on their substance, not a version label.
  • Enforce product restrictions and assess each recommendation under the applicable customer-specific standard.
  • Product approval does not replace required review of later sales communications.

Required Due-Diligence Topics

The committee should document its analysis of each topic below. A blank or boilerplate entry is itself a supervisory red flag.

TopicWhat the Committee Documents
Product structure and mechanicsHow payoffs are calculated, embedded derivatives, fees and expense layers, tax treatment
Risk characteristicsMarket risk, credit risk, liquidity risk, leverage, complexity, correlation behavior
Appropriate accountsCustomer profiles (objectives, risk tolerance, experience, time horizon, liquidity needs) the product fits, and which it does not
Issuer / sponsor due diligenceFinancial condition, regulatory history, prior product performance
Marketing and disclosureWhether prospectus / offering materials accurately convey risk; whether marketing materials comply with the FINRA communications-with-the-public framework
Conflicts of interestCompensation differentials, revenue-sharing, affiliated-underwriter relationships
Operational capabilityWhether systems can clear, settle, custody, value, and report on the product
Post-approval reviewPeriodic reassessment, exception reports, complaint trends, customer-outcome data

Think of it this way: The due-diligence checklist is the firm's case file. If a customer later complains, the firm's defense rests on the file showing that the product's risks were understood, that the customer profile was identified, and that the surveillance reports caught the issue before regulators did.


Application to Complex Products

"Complex products" carry heightened supervisory expectations because their payoffs, leverage, or holding-period sensitivity are not intuitive to most retail customers.

Examples of Complex Products

  • Structured products (issuer notes with derivatives-linked payoffs)
  • Leveraged and inverse ETFs / ETPs (daily-reset products targeting 2x, 3x, -1x of an index)
  • Principal-protected notes
  • Commodity futures-linked products
  • Reverse convertibles
  • Volatility-linked products
  • Non-traditional and alternative funds (e.g., interval funds, business development companies, commodity-pool funds)

Heightened Expectations

For each complex product, the firm should impose additional supervisory layers:

  • Enhanced due diligence beyond standard product review
  • Specific training for any rep recommending the product
  • Product-specific analysis of material terms and risks, including differences among issuers' structured notes
  • Enhanced supervision of recommendations, including holding-period monitoring for daily-reset products

The Daily-Reset Problem

Leveraged and inverse ETFs reset their leverage daily. Over multiple days, the compounding effect causes the product's return to diverge from the simple multiple of the index return.

  • Ignoring fees and tracking differences, an index rising 5% and then falling 5% takes $100 to $105 to $99.75, a 0.25% loss. A daily 2x ETF takes $100 to $110 to $99, a 1% loss. Twice the index's two-day return is -0.5%
  • The divergence does not always hurt the holder. A -2x inverse ETF on an index that rises 5% two days in a row loses 10% each day, about 19% in total ($100 becomes $90, then $81). The index gained 10.25%, so -2x would be -20.5%; the ETF loses slightly less. A steady one-direction market can shrink the loss, and a choppy market is where the reset hurts
  • Over volatile multi-week periods, the divergence can be substantial: an investor in a 3x leveraged ETF for a month may underperform 3x the monthly index return materially

Firms should tailor their supervisory procedures to the products and customers involved. Alerts on extended holding are one possible control; the firm must ensure appropriate recommendations, accurate promotion and compliance with applicable rules, and document adherence to its procedures.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Daily-reset leveraged and inverse products can diverge from their stated multiple over multiple days through compounding.
  • A category label does not establish due diligence on each structured note’s material features and risks.

How Complex Products Behave

The committee cannot document "payoff mechanics" or "appropriate accounts" for the products listed above unless a principal knows how each one behaves. This section covers three of them: reverse convertibles, structured notes, and leveraged and inverse exchange-traded funds (ETFs).

Reverse Convertibles

A reverse convertible is a short-term note, usually from a large bank, linked to a reference asset such as one stock or an index. In its basic form it has two parts:

  • A note that pays a fixed, above-market coupon, often monthly or quarterly
  • A put option the investor gives the issuer. If the reference asset falls below a set knock-in level, the issuer may repay principal in depreciated shares (or their cash value) instead of cash. Knock-in levels are often 20 to 30 percent below the starting price

Assume a basic coupon-only note and that the issuer pays. The note's maturity terms govern the payoff.

Reference assetWhat the holder receives
Stays above the knock-in levelAll coupons and full principal in cash
Rises well above the starting priceThe same: coupons and principal only, with no share of the gain
Falls below the knock-in levelDepending on the terms, the holder may receive shares worth less than principal and lose some or all principal, or may receive full principal after a recovery. Coupons can offset the loss
  • Higher coupon, higher volatility. A more volatile reference asset generally supports a higher coupon, because the put the investor writes is worth more to the issuer
  • Terms differ. Some notes pay full principal if the asset ends above the knock-in level even after dipping below it. In others, any breach during the term can mean less than principal
  • Other risks: the note is an unsecured obligation of the issuer, so issuer credit risk applies, and there is little or no secondary market
  • Who it may suit: a customer who wants higher current income than other bonds offer, accepts giving up all appreciation, and understands that the debt can end as an equity position
  • Who it does not suit: a customer who needs principal certain, cannot hold the stock, or wants the gain if the stock rises

Structured Notes and Principal-Protected Notes

A structured note is an unsecured debt obligation of a financial institution with two components, a bond and an embedded derivative that links the return to a reference asset. Reverse convertibles, principal-protected notes, enhanced-participation (leveraged) notes, and hybrids are common types.

FeatureHow it worksRisk or trade-off
Principal protectionPrincipal is repaid at maturityOnly as good as the issuer's credit. Many notes have none. Protection that is conditional, partial, or withdrawable on a stated event is a complexity risk
Participation rateInvestor receives a set percentage of the reference asset's riseA 50 percent rate on a 20 percent rise pays 10 percent
CapGains stop at a maximumA 20 percent cap on a 25 percent rise pays 20 percent
Knock-inFalling below a barrier changes the payoffThe holder may lose principal and coupons, or receive the declined asset
Call featureIssuer may redeem early at its discretion, at a price above, below, or equal to face valueThe holder may not reinvest at the same rate
Issue pricePrice paid is likely above the issuer's estimated valueCosts of selling, structuring, and hedging sit in the price
LiquidityMost notes are not exchange listedThe only buyer may be the issuer's affiliate, at a discount
  • Hold to maturity. A customer who may need the money early can lose a significant part of the investment, even in a note with principal protection at maturity
  • Worst-of and volatility-linked products add more layers: a worst-of payoff follows the weakest index in a group, and a volatility-linked product may track the market's expectation of future volatility rather than volatility actually experienced
  • Rep knowledge. A rep should be able to explain the payoff, any cap, the chance of a call, and the extent and limits of any protection. A note paying principal plus 150 percent of an index rise is a bond plus an embedded call

Leveraged and Inverse ETFs

  • Leveraged ETFs seek a multiple of an index's performance. Inverse ETFs seek the opposite. A 2x leveraged inverse ETF seeks twice the opposite of the index
  • Most reset daily and are designed to meet their objective on a daily basis. Compounding makes results over longer periods differ significantly from the stated multiple, and volatility magnifies the gap
  • Worked example, ignoring fees and tracking differences. An index goes 100 to 101 and back to 100. A 1x inverse ETF loses 0.02 percent. If the index goes 100 to 110 and back to 100, the same ETF loses 1.82 percent
  • Who it may suit: a sophisticated customer using it for a short-term trading view or a hedge within one trading session
  • Typical suitability concern: daily-reset leveraged and inverse ETFs are typically unsuitable for retail customers planning to hold them beyond one trading session, particularly in volatile markets. Assess the particular recommendation and customer circumstances

What a Principal Should Flag

  • The customer's stated objective or holding period does not match the product's design: income and preservation customers in reverse convertibles that may repay in shares, or a multi-year hold in a daily-reset fund
  • A recommendation made without asking to whom the product should not be offered and under what scenarios the promised protection or yield would not occur
  • Financial ability and understanding. Review the customer's ability to understand risks and bear potential losses. FINRA encourages firms to borrow the approach used for options trading accounts when recommending complex products; the applicable recommendation standard governs the actual transaction
  • A signed qualification agreement offered in place of customer-specific analysis. It cannot replace that analysis
  • Training gaps: a rep who cannot explain the payoff, the cap, the call, or the limits of protection should not recommend the product

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A reverse convertible’s knock-in can cause principal loss depending on its terms; an above-market coupon does not add upside to a basic coupon-only note.
  • Principal protection depends on issuer credit and applicable terms, generally at maturity; early sales may lose principal.
  • A signed risk acknowledgement does not replace reasonable-basis and customer-specific analysis.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you explain why a daily-reset leveraged or inverse ETF's multi-day return can diverge from its stated daily multiple, and why the customer's intended holding period matters?
  • Can you explain why different structured-note terms require attention in product review?
  • Can you distinguish a material modification from a cosmetic prospectus update when applying the firm's review procedures?
  • Can you explain why firms tailor their review process and may use a committee without a universally mandated roster?