Quick Answer
FINRA's variable-contracts rule governs variable-contract sales (annuities and life), both securities and insurance products; compensation normally flows through the member firm, not the insurer. The deferred variable annuity rule requires a registered principal to approve or reject a recommendation in writing within 7 business days after the office of supervisory jurisdiction (OSJ) receives a complete application, before insurer transmittal.
The two requirements work in parallel: the variable-contracts framework sets the compensation and distribution rules for all variable contracts; the deferred variable annuity rule layers a deferred-VA-specific supervisory regime on top.
What a Variable Contract Is
A variable contract is an insurance product (variable annuity or variable life insurance) whose values vary with the performance of a separate account invested in securities (typically mutual fund subaccounts).
- Variable contracts are securities under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (SEA) and insurance products under state insurance law (dual SEC and state-insurance regulation)
- The separate account itself registers as an investment company under the Investment Company Act of 1940 (ICA) and the underlying subaccounts mirror mutual fund structures
- Distinguish from a fixed annuity (insurance contract with guaranteed return; not a security; not subject to FINRA rules)
Variable Contracts: Sale and Compensation
The FINRA variable-contracts requirement sets the compensation and distribution framework for all variable contracts.
Compensation Channeling
An AP generally may only receive compensation in connection with variable-contract sales from the member with which the person is associated.
- The insurance carrier normally may not pay the AP directly
- Compensation normally flows: carrier → member firm → AP through the firm's payroll
- This rule prevents the insurance carrier from creating off-the-books incentives outside the firm's supervision
- Narrow exception: a non-member company may pay an AP directly if the member agrees to the arrangement, relies on an appropriate SEC rule, regulation, interpretive release, interpretive letter, or no-action letter that fits the arrangement, treats the payment as compensation received by the member, and keeps the required records
Cash and Non-Cash Compensation
Cash and non-cash compensation restrictions parallel the requirements covering direct participation programs (DPPs), investment company securities, and corporate financing covered in the Compensation Practices unit. The four permitted non-cash compensation categories (gifts, occasional meals / entertainment, offeror-funded training, internal non-cash arrangements) all apply to variable-contract sales.
Recordkeeping
The member must maintain records of all compensation received from offerors in connection with variable-contract sales: offeror name, AP name, cash amount, and nature and value of any non-cash compensation. These records feed the broader per-rep transaction record kept under the books-and-records framework.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Variable contracts involve both securities and insurance requirements; assess each registration or licensing failure separately.
- Continuing-education inactive status does not authorize registration-required activity despite an existing CRD number.
- Compensation generally flows through the member; direct nonmember payments require all four stated conditions, and noncash prizes have separate rules.
The Deferred Variable Annuity Rule
The deferred variable annuity rule applies to recommended purchases and exchanges of deferred variable annuities. It sets a heightened supervisory regime distinct from standard suitability.
Required Customer Disclosure Before Recommendation
Before recommending a deferred-VA purchase or exchange, the rep must have a reasonable basis to believe the customer has been informed, in general terms, of the product's various features, such as:
- Surrender period and surrender charges (including the schedule of declining charges over the surrender period)
- Potential tax penalty (10% federal penalty on pre-59½ withdrawals, in addition to ordinary income tax on the gain portion)
- Mortality and expense (M&E) fees and investment advisory fees
- Potential charges for and features of riders (e.g., guaranteed minimum income benefit (GMIB) rider, guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit (GMWB) rider)
- The insurance and investment components of the contract
- Market risk
The list is illustrative ("such as"), not closed. Death benefits sit in a different part of the test: the rep must also have a reasonable basis to believe the customer would benefit from features such as tax-deferred growth, annuitization, or a death or living benefit. The rule does not name a market-value adjustment (MVA), a feature some contracts use to adjust surrender value when interest rates move.
Principal Review and Approval: 7 Business Days
A registered principal (Series 24, Series 26, or Series 9 / 10) must review and approve or reject the recommendation in writing.
| Requirement | Detail |
|---|---|
| Trigger | OSJ receives a complete and correct application package |
| Deadline | No later than 7 business days after that receipt |
| Action | Principal must review and approve or reject in writing; the determination must be documented and signed by the principal who reviewed it (an electronic signature counts) |
| Standard | Approve only with a reasonable basis to believe the transaction is suitable for this customer, judged on the deferred-VA factors |
| Outcome | Approval before transmission to the insurance company |
The principal's review must occur before the application is transmitted to the issuing insurance company.
An actually unsolicited purchase falls outside this recommendation-specific review rule and its seven-business-day clock. Other applicable variable-contract duties remain, including prompt transmittal of applications and at least the purchase-payment portion required to be credited to the contract. Labeling a recommendation customer-initiated does not remove the review requirement.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The seven-business-day review runs from OSJ receipt of a complete and correct application.
- The reviewing principal must document and sign a customer-specific approval or rejection before transmission to the insurer.
- An actually unsolicited purchase is outside the deferred-annuity recommendation rule; other applicable duties remain.
Exchange Supervision
Replacing one variable annuity with another (a "1035 exchange") triggers heightened scrutiny. The principal must evaluate whether the customer would benefit from the new product's enhancements considering:
- New surrender charges (the new VA typically resets the surrender schedule, locking the customer in for another 5-10 years)
- Loss of existing benefits (death-benefit step-ups, locked-in withdrawal rates, vintage GMIB / GMWB rider terms that may not be available on the new product)
- Surrender charges on the existing product (selling out of an existing product before the schedule expires consumes principal)
- Customer's frequency of recent exchanges (the rule asks whether the customer had another deferred variable annuity exchange within the preceding 36 months)
The frequency of recent exchanges is a key factor, and a red flag that calls for closer review. It is not a presumption of churning and it is not an automatic bar. A customer who exchanged once five years ago is in a different posture than a customer who has exchanged twice in the past three years. The principal weighs the pattern with the other factors and documents the analysis.
The 36-month look-back follows the customer, not the firm. The firm checks whether the customer had an exchange at the firm. It also makes reasonable efforts to find out whether the customer had one at any other broker-dealer in that window.
Asking the customer is a reasonable effort. The firm documents in writing both the question and the customer's answer. An exchange older than 36 months does not count toward this factor.
The frequency factor feeds the principal's review of the exchange in front of them. It does not replace that review. A customer with several recent exchanges still gets a written approve-or-reject decision on the new exchange, and the rule lists no heightened account supervision step ahead of that decision.
The firm has a separate duty to run surveillance on each associated person's rate of deferred variable annuity exchanges and to correct any pattern of inappropriate exchanges. That duty watches the rep's pattern across customers, not one customer's account.
Required Training
The member must develop and document training for the associated persons who effect deferred variable annuity transactions and the registered principals who review them, covering:
- The deferred variable annuity supervisory framework
- The material features of deferred variable annuities, including those listed above
- The suitability factors that apply to deferred-VA recommendations
Training must occur before any rep recommends a deferred VA. A firm that distributes deferred VAs without documented rep training has a supervisory failure regardless of whether the individual sales appear suitable.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The seven-business-day review applies to recommended deferred variable annuities, not every variable contract.
- An exchange can introduce new surrender charges; evaluate customer benefits against lost benefits and other exchange factors.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you state the 7-business-day deadline for a principal to approve or reject a deferred variable annuity recommendation after the OSJ receives a complete application?
- Do you know that principal review must finish before the application transmits to the insurance carrier, not after, even if approval was likely?
- Can you state the 10% tax penalty on a pre-59½ deferred variable annuity withdrawal, and that it applies on top of ordinary income tax?
- Do you know why compensation for variable-contract sales generally flows through the member firm, and the four conditions under which a non-member company may pay the representative directly?