Quick Answer
Trade prices and disclosures involve fair pricing, reasonable service charges, consent to net transactions, and trade confirmations. The 5% policy is a guideline, not a safe harbor. Service fees must be reasonable and not unfairly discriminatory; check the account agreement and applicable disclosure requirements before changing them. Retail principal debt trades can require additional markup disclosures.
These rules together govern the firm's pricing and disclosure obligations on every customer transaction. The exam tests them as a stack: the firm must price fairly, charge reasonable service fees, obtain proper consent for principal-trade structures, and confirm every trade in writing with the right disclosures.
The Fair Pricing Standard ("5% Policy")
Members must buy and sell securities for customers at prices that are fair, taking into account all relevant circumstances. The "5% Policy" is a guideline, not a safe harbor: a markup, markdown, or commission of 5% or even less may be unfair under all the circumstances.
The base is the prevailing market price. The markup that matters for fairness is the spread over the prevailing market price. Absent other bona fide evidence of the prevailing market, the member's own contemporaneous cost is the best indication of that price.
The mark-up policy lists some of the factors a firm should weigh in judging fairness; the list is not exhaustive:
- Type of security (listed equity vs. low-priced or thinly-traded vs. bond)
- Availability of the security (illiquid securities may justify higher cost)
- Price of the security (lower-priced securities may justify higher percentages)
- Transaction size (smaller dollar size may justify higher percentages)
- Disclosure of the markup or commission to the customer (a factor, but does NOT cure an unfair price)
- Pattern of the firm's markups
- Nature of the firm's business
Which Transactions the Policy Covers
The policy applies to all securities in five kinds of transactions:
- A riskless (simultaneous) principal trade that fills an order already received from the customer
- A sale from inventory, with the markup measured over the bona fide representative current market
- A purchase from a customer, where the price or markdown must be reasonably related to the prevailing market price
- An agency trade, where the commission must be fair in light of all relevant circumstances
- A proceeds transaction, where the customer sells securities to pay for others bought at about the same time; the markup counts any profit or commission on the securities sold
It does not apply to a sale at the specific public offering price when a prospectus or offering circular must be delivered.
Think of it this way: The 5% Policy is a guide, not a rule, and it is neither a ceiling nor a floor. A firm can charge less than 5% and still violate fair pricing if the security is liquid and widely traded; a firm can charge slightly more than 5% on a thinly traded low-priced security and still satisfy fair pricing when the circumstances justify it. Each transaction is evaluated on its own facts.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The 5% policy is a guideline, not a safe harbor; disclosure does not cure an unfair price.
- The policy excludes a sale at the specific public offering price when a prospectus or offering circular must be delivered.
Charges for Services Performed
Miscellaneous charges (collection of dividends/interest, transfer or exchange of securities, appraisals, safekeeping or custody, etc.) must be:
- Reasonable
- Not unfairly discriminatory among customers
The service-charge rule does not establish a universal 30-day notice period. Check the account agreement and any other applicable disclosure obligations. If an agreement promises 30 days' advance written notice of a fee change, the firm must honor that promise.
Read the promise precisely: which changes trigger it, whether notice must be written, what delivery method is permitted, and whether the period starts at dispatch or delivery. Apply the stated terms. A customer's silence or general acceptance of future fee changes does not itself fulfill an unchanged advance-notice promise.
An agreement may permit valid written email notice. Do not treat consent to email alone as proof that a particular notice was provided: check the required delivery and timing. A same-day passive webpage update does not satisfy an agreement promising delivered advance notice.
If an increase is premature, correct affected charges and align effectiveness with compliant notice under the agreement. Check whether the earlier notice was adequate or whether further notice is needed; do not automatically restart an otherwise valid notice period.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Fee reasonableness and any promised advance notice are separate; apply the agreement’s actual starting event and delivery terms.
Net Transactions With Customers
A "net" transaction is a principal trade with all of these features:
- A market maker takes the trade
- The market maker receives the customer's order first, to buy or sell an equity security
- It then trades the security at one price with another broker-dealer or customer
- It trades with the customer at a different price
The difference between the two prices is imputed compensation to the firm; it is not separately disclosed as a commission or markup on the confirmation.
The consent rule reaches only that structure. A firm that sells a corporate bond to a retail customer at a higher price than it paid is taking a markup, and the net-transaction consent rule does not apply to it.
The net-transaction rule sets the consent requirements based on customer type:
| Customer Type | Consent Requirement |
|---|---|
| Non-institutional customer | Written, order-by-order consent required before each net transaction |
| Institutional customer | May use a negative-consent letter with clear terms and a meaningful opportunity to object before execution, documented oral order-by-order consent, or written order-by-order consent |
A negative-consent letter is a one-time written disclosure that net trades will occur unless the institutional customer objects. The firm may rely on lack of objection only after clearly disclosing handling terms and providing a meaningful opportunity to object before execution. Acknowledgment of receipt alone is not affirmative consent to the terms.
This option is not available for non-institutional customers, who must affirmatively consent in writing on every order.
Oral order-by-order disclosure and consent must explain the terms, provide a meaningful opportunity to object before execution, and document the customer's understanding and consent.
"Institutional" here uses the institutional-account definition. An account is institutional if it belongs to one of these:
- A bank, savings and loan association, insurance company, or registered investment company
- An investment adviser registered with the SEC or a state securities commission
- Any other person, natural or legal, with total assets of at least $50 million
A natural person can therefore be institutional, but only at $50 million or more in total assets. A wealthy individual with $20 million is still non-institutional and needs written, order-by-order consent.
Think of it this way: The disparity in consent rules tracks customer sophistication. An institutional customer with a portfolio manager and a compliance department can absorb a one-time disclosure and decide whether to opt out. A retail customer cannot reasonably be expected to manage that ongoing exposure, so each net trade requires a fresh, written approval.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Non-institutional net trades require written order-by-order consent; institutional alternatives have distinct conditions.
- The net-transaction rule concerns the specified market-maker principal equity structure, not an ordinary bond markup.
Customer Confirmations
The firm must give or send the customer a written confirmation at or before completion of each transaction. The duty is to give or send it by then, not to make sure the customer has received it by settlement. The confirmation requirement comes from the SEC's customer-confirmation rule, with the FINRA trade confirmation rule layering on additional retail-debt disclosures.
Required Confirmation Content
| Element | Required For |
|---|---|
| Trade date and time | All trades (time may be "available upon request" depending on rule) |
| Price and quantity | All trades |
| Security identity (a Committee on Uniform Securities Identification Procedures (CUSIP) number is customary) | All trades |
| Capacity (agent or principal) | All trades |
| Commission (if firm acted as agent) | Agency trades |
| Markup or markdown (or price difference) | Certain debt principal trades, and certain equity principal trades under the SEC rule |
| Remuneration from third parties | Agency trades (whether received from someone other than the customer, or amount thereof) |
| Yield information (yield to maturity from the dollar price, or the traded yield and its type) | Debt securities |
| Early-redemption statement | Debt securities that can be redeemed before maturity |
Think of it this way: The confirmation tells the customer what was traded, at what price, what role the firm played, and what the firm earned. The confirmation is the customer's primary record of every transaction; the firm must give or send it at or before completion of the transaction so the customer can verify the trade.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Confirmations disclose capacity; callable debt requires the specified redemption statement.
- Yield disclosure depends on how the debt trade was priced and applicable exceptions.
Retail Debt Markup Disclosure
The customer-confirmation rule adds two separate debt disclosures. They have different triggers, so check each one on its own.
1. Markup or markdown disclosure (the conditional one). The confirmation must show the firm's markup or markdown as a total dollar amount AND as a percentage of prevailing market price (PMP) when all four conditions are met and no applicable exception applies:
- The customer is a retail (non-institutional) customer
- The security is corporate or agency debt (not municipal debt, which has parallel MSRB customer-confirmation rules)
- The firm acts as principal (not agent)
- The firm trades the security the other way on the same trading day, in offsetting transactions whose aggregate size meets or exceeds the size of the customer trade (dealer purchases offsetting its customer sale, or dealer sales offsetting its customer purchase, regardless of which leg occurs first)
Exceptions to markup disclosure. No markup disclosure is required when a functionally separate principal desk executed the offset and the firm maintained policies and procedures reasonably designed to ensure that desk had no knowledge of the customer trade. A second exception covers securities acquired in a fixed-price offering and sold to retail customers at that offering price on the acquisition day. Non-arm's-length affiliate offsets require looking through to the affiliate's third-party transaction.
2. Execution time and trade-data reference (the unconditional one). For every transaction in corporate or agency debt with a retail customer, the confirmation must show:
- The time of execution, to the second
- A reference and brief description of the FINRA page with public Trade Reporting and Compliance Engine (TRACE) data for the security, plus a hyperlink if the confirmation is electronic
These two items do not depend on a same-day offset, and they apply to agency trades as well as principal trades.
Think of it this way: A retail principal bond trade with qualifying same-day opposite-direction offsets and no applicable exception requires dollar-and-percentage markup disclosure. Every retail corporate or agency bond confirmation also shows when the trade happened and a reference to public trade data, with a hyperlink if electronic. These rules were designed to bring transparency to retail bond trading, where markups had historically been opaque.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Retail principal corporate or agency debt markup disclosure requires a qualifying same-day opposite-side offset and no applicable exception.
- Execution time and the TRACE reference apply separately to retail corporate or agency debt confirmations; electronic confirmations also need the hyperlink.
- Municipal debt has parallel MSRB requirements.
How These Rules Stack on a Single Trade
Imagine a firm sells a corporate bond to a retail customer as principal at 102, after buying at least the same quantity at 100 earlier that day. Assume no markup-disclosure exception applies. Five rules touch this single trade:
- Fair-pricing standard: the 2-point markup must be fair under all circumstances (security type, liquidity, price, transaction size). Disclosure does not cure unfairness.
- Net-transaction rule: not a "net transaction" because the net-transaction rule covers only a market maker's trade in an equity security after it receives the order, and this is a corporate bond sale with a markup. Consent rules do not apply.
- Miscellaneous-charges rule: any service fees layered on (handling, settlement) must be reasonable and disclosed.
- Customer-confirmation rule: the confirmation must show capacity (principal), price, quantity, time, and yield information.
- Retail debt confirmation amendments: because this is a retail principal trade in corporate debt with a same-day offsetting purchase, the confirmation must additionally show the markup in dollars and as a percentage of PMP. Because it is a retail corporate debt trade, it must also show the execution time to the second and a TRACE reference and brief description, plus a hyperlink if electronic.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Fair pricing, service fees, confirmation and debt disclosure can apply to the same trade.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you explain why the 5% policy is a guideline, not a safe harbor, and why disclosure never cures an unfair price?
- Do you know the markup base, the prevailing market price best shown by the firm's contemporaneous cost, and that the policy does not reach a sale at the public offering price?
- Can you distinguish the fee's reasonableness standard from the agreement's promised notice period, delivery method, and starting event?
- Can you distinguish the net-transaction consent rule for a non-institutional customer (written, order-by-order) from an institutional customer (negative-consent letter allowed)?
- Can you distinguish conditional markup disclosure from execution time and the trade-data reference required on all retail corporate or agency debt confirmations, with a hyperlink if electronic?