Other Account-Activity Controls

Quick Answer

Five FINRA rules: no paying compensation to unregistered persons who must register, except continuing commissions to a retiring rep under a contract with the member signed while registered; a 3-month convenience limit on holding customer mail; express written authorization plus 3-year retention for negotiable instruments; documented issuer review before OTC equity recommendations; and DPP suitability.

These five rules govern specific high-risk transaction types or account-management practices. Each has its own narrow scope, but the exam tests them as a group because they cover supervisory edge cases that the other recommendation rules (KYC, suitability, Reg BI, discretion) do not directly address.


Payments to Unregistered Persons

Members may not pay any commission, fee, concession, or other compensation to any person who is required to be registered but is not.

This rule prevents:

  • Paying a person to refer customers in exchange for a commission percentage when that person is not licensed
  • Paying former employees who lost their registration for misconduct
  • Paying offshore intermediaries who solicit U.S. customers without U.S. registration

The Continuing-Commission Exception

A member may pay continuing commissions to a retiring registered representative after the rep stops being associated with the member, provided that:

  • A bona fide contract between the member and the retiring rep, providing for the payments, was entered into in good faith while the person was a registered representative of the member
  • That contract, among other things, prohibits the retiring rep from soliciting new business, opening new accounts, or servicing the accounts that generate the payments
  • The arrangement complies with the applicable federal securities laws and SEC rules

The payments come from accounts held for the retiring rep's continuing customers, and the rule permits them regardless of whether customer funds or securities are added to those accounts during retirement. The exception is not limited to business booked before retirement.

A retiring registered representative is an individual who retires from the member (including because of a total disability) and leaves the securities industry. A rep who leaves to join another firm has not left the industry, so the exception does not reach that rep.

If the retiring rep dies, the beneficiary designated in the written contract, or the rep's estate if no beneficiary is designated, may receive the payments under the member's agreement.

If the former rep contacts customers to make recommendations, or otherwise solicits or services the accounts, the firm is paying an unregistered person for broker activity, and the exception no longer protects the payments.

Think of it this way: The continuing-commission exception pays a retiree a trailing share of the accounts the rep built, not a fee for new work. New money flowing into those accounts is fine; new work by the retiree is not.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The contract must be between the member and the retiring rep, entered in good faith while the rep was still registered with the member. A handshake agreement or a side letter signed after retirement does not qualify.
  • New money does not end the exception; new work by the retiree does. Payments may come from continuing customers' accounts even when funds or securities are added during retirement, but the retiree may not solicit new business, open new accounts, or service the accounts.

Holding of Customer Mail

A firm may hold mail for a customer who will not receive it at their usual address, subject to these conditions:

ConditionRequired action
Written instructionsObtain the customer's instructions specifying the hold period
Longer than three consecutive monthsThe instructions must include an acceptable reason beyond convenience; include applicable periods from prior requests
Alternate monitoring methodsInform the customer in writing about available alternatives, such as email or website access, and obtain confirmation that the customer received that information
Continuing verification and communicationVerify at reasonable intervals that the instructions still apply; remain able to communicate important account information in a timely manner
Protection of held mailTake reasonable steps against tampering, holding without consent and improper use by associated persons

Safety or security concerns are examples of acceptable reasons for a longer hold. For example, a deployed customer may document a credible security concern about sensitive mail accumulating in an unsecured shared mailbox. The reason and specified period belong in the customer's written instructions; the other conditions still apply.

Travel, medical treatment, deployment or lack of a forwarding address does not automatically establish the required reason. Assess the actual circumstances beyond mere convenience. The rule does not create a closed list of acceptable reasons. An indefinite request lacks the required period, and dividing a continuous hold into successive requests does not restart the three-month threshold.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Convenience does not support a hold longer than three consecutive months. A shorter hold still requires written instructions specifying its period and satisfaction of the other conditions. An indefinite electronic-access preference cannot simply be treated as a valid three-month authorization.
  • The periodic check concerns whether the instructions still apply. Current address and contact details alone do not answer that question. The rule does not prescribe a fixed monthly reauthorization schedule. When the authorized period ends, follow applicable customer instructions and firm procedures; the rule does not prescribe a universal packet format or delivery-documentation checklist.

Authorization for Negotiable Instruments

A firm or associated person must obtain the customer's express written authorization before obtaining or submitting for payment any negotiable instrument (a check or draft) drawn on the customer's:

  • Checking account
  • Savings account
  • Share account
  • Other similar account

This rule covers situations where the firm obtains or submits a paper instrument drawn on the customer's bank account, such as:

  • Recurring drafts drawn on a linked bank account to fund a brokerage account
  • Check-writing privileges where the firm clears checks against a customer's account
  • Drafts drawn on the account to pay advisory fees

The rule text names a "check, draft or other form of negotiable paper." It does not mention electronic transfers such as automated clearing house (ACH) debits. Do not apply this rule to an ACH debit. The negotiable-instrument rule covers paper instruments only.

Records Retention

When written authorization is separate from the negotiable instrument, preserve that authorization for 3 years after it expires. This provision does not require preserving copies of customer-signed instruments and does not itself create a customer-production right.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The negotiable-instrument rule requires express written authorization, not implied or oral. A firm that submits drafts on a customer's account based on a verbal "yes" violates the rule even if the customer wanted the draft.
  • Negotiable-instrument authorization records must be preserved 3 years after the authorization expires, not 3 years from creation. A multi-year draft authorization that expires in June 2030 must have records preserved until June 2033.

OTC Equity Recommendation Review

Before a covered recommendation to purchase or sell short an OTC equity security (a stock that does not trade on a registered exchange and is quoted only over-the-counter), a member must:

  • Review the issuer's current financial statements
  • Review current material business information about the issuer
  • Conclude that the available information provides a reasonable basis for the recommendation

A firm cannot make an OTC equity recommendation based on rep enthusiasm alone or on information from an issuer-paid promoter. The firm must do its own due diligence on the issuer's actual financials and current business situation.

Designated Registered Person Requirement

The firm must:

  • Designate a registered person to conduct the OTC review. That person must have the skills, background, and knowledge to do the review, and must either be registered as a General Securities Principal or General Securities Sales Supervisor or be supervised in the review by someone who is
  • Document the information reviewed, the date of review, and the reviewer's name. If the reviewer is not a General Securities Principal or General Securities Sales Supervisor, also document the name of the principal or sales supervisor who supervised the review

This documentation creates an audit trail. If a recommendation later proves problematic, the firm can demonstrate that a registered person actually reviewed the issuer's filings and reached a documented conclusion.

Delinquent-Filer Inquiry

For issuers that are delinquent in their SEC filings (current annual or quarterly reports overdue), the review must include an inquiry into the circumstances of the failure to file.

A delinquent filer is presumptively higher-risk because the firm cannot rely on current public disclosure. The inquiry might reveal that the issuer is undergoing restatement, has had auditor turnover, or has suspended operations. Without the inquiry, the firm cannot have a "reasonable basis" for the recommendation.

Think of it this way: The OTC equity review duty elevates OTC equity recommendations above ordinary suitability. For OTC stocks, the firm must do issuer-level due diligence, not just customer-level suitability. A rep who pitches an OTC stock without the firm having reviewed the issuer's financials is acting beyond what know your customer (KYC), suitability, or Reg BI alone would require; the OTC equity rule imposes a separate, product-specific gating duty.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The OTC review duty applies before a covered purchase or sell-short recommendation. The firm cannot defer the review until after the recommendation. A qualified recommending representative may be the designated reviewer when appropriately designated and supervised; enthusiasm alone does not replace the documented review.
  • Before a covered new recommendation, the reviewed information must remain current and adequate. Still-current prior work may be reused. Newly available financial or material business information must be addressed; a prior review does not authorize reliance on stale information. Whoever starts the conversation does not change this: a customer who asks the representative what to buy gets a recommendation only after the review.
  • The product recommended triggers the review, not the account it is bought in. A customer who opens a margin account to buy an OTC equity security still needs the issuer review before the recommendation. Margin approval and credit limits answer a different question and do not satisfy the review.
  • For delinquent SEC filers, the review must include an inquiry into the circumstances of the failure to file. Without that inquiry, the firm has no reasonable basis for any recommendation regardless of the rep's enthusiasm.

Direct Participation Programs Suitability

A direct participation program (DPP) is a program that provides flow-through tax consequences, whatever the legal structure of the entity. Examples include oil and gas, real estate, and agricultural programs, condominium securities, and Subchapter S corporate offerings; many are limited partnerships. The definition excludes real estate investment trusts (REITs), tax-qualified retirement plans, individual retirement plans, tax-sheltered annuities, and any company registered under the Investment Company Act.

When recommending the purchase, sale, or exchange of a DPP interest, a member must:

  1. Have reasonable grounds to believe, on the basis of information obtained from the participant about the participant's investment objectives, other investments, financial situation and needs, and any other information known by the member, that:
    • The participant is or will be in a financial position appropriate to realize, to a significant extent, the benefits described in the prospectus, including the tax benefits where they are a significant aspect of the program
    • The participant has a fair market net worth sufficient to sustain the risks inherent in the program, including loss of investment and lack of liquidity
    • The program is otherwise suitable for the participant
  2. Keep documents in the member's files disclosing the basis on which the suitability determination was reached for each participant

Fair market net worth is total assets at fair market value less total liabilities.

Separately, a member may not underwrite or participate in a public offering of a DPP unless the program has established suitability standards for participants, fully disclosed in the prospectus and consistent with the requirements above.

This is product-specific suitability layered on top of the general recommendation standard (Regulation Best Interest for a retail customer, the suitability rule otherwise). A rep cannot rely on a general profile alone; the participant-specific information must support all three beliefs for this particular program.

Discretionary Accounts and Listed Programs

No member may execute a DPP transaction in a discretionary account without the customer's prior written approval of the transaction. General discretionary authority over the account is not enough.

The suitability-standard and recommendation requirements above do not apply to a secondary offering of, or a secondary market transaction in, a DPP interest listed on a national securities exchange, or to an initial public offering of an interest whose exchange listing has been approved and is expected within a reasonable time.

In those same listed situations, the discretionary-approval requirement also drops away, but only when the member is not affiliated with the program.

Rollup Solicitation Compensation

A limited partnership rollup transaction combines or reorganizes one or more limited partnerships into a new entity. A member may solicit limited partners' votes or tenders on a rollup only if any compensation it receives is:

  • Payable and equal in amount whether the limited partner votes for or against the rollup
  • No more than 2%, in the aggregate, of the exchange value of the newly created securities
  • Paid whether or not the limited partners reject the rollup

The member also may not solicit unless the general partner or sponsor agrees to pay all solicitation expenses if the rollup is rejected, and it may not participate in any capacity in a rollup that is unfair or unreasonable.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The first belief is about realizing the prospectus benefits, including the tax benefits, not about absorbing risk. Risk capacity is the second belief: fair market net worth sufficient to sustain the risks, including loss of investment and lack of liquidity. A wealthy customer who cannot use a program's significant tax benefits can still fail the first belief.
  • A tax professional's letter is information the member can use, not a replacement for the member's own belief. If it says other losses leave the customer little taxable income, that weighs against the first belief when tax benefits are significant. The member still weighs it and records its own basis.
  • Discretion over a DPP trade needs the customer's prior written approval of that transaction. The exception for exchange-listed programs reaches the discretionary-approval requirement only when the member is not affiliated with the program.
  • The member must document the basis for each participant's DPP suitability determination in its files. A conclusion with no recorded basis falls short of the rule.

How These Rules Cover Edge Cases

The five rules in this section cover transaction types and practices not directly addressed by the broader recommendation rules:

  • The payments-to-unregistered-persons prohibition covers the compensation edge case
  • The holding-of-customer-mail rule covers the mail-handling edge case (holding customer mail beyond convenience)
  • The negotiable-instrument authorization rule covers the bank-account-debit edge case (negotiable instruments drawn on customer bank accounts)
  • The OTC equity recommendation rule covers the OTC equity recommendation edge case (issuer-level due diligence beyond customer suitability)
  • The DPP rule covers the DPP suitability edge case (product-specific beliefs, a documented basis, and written approval of discretionary DPP trades)

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The exam often tests these rules as fact-pattern violations that look like ordinary transactions but trigger product-specific or practice-specific rules. A firm processing an OTC equity recommendation is in the OTC equity recommendation lane regardless of what KYC, suitability, or Reg BI would require.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you state who the continuing-commission contract must be between, when it must have been signed, and which reps count as retiring?
  • Do you know why a mail hold beyond 3 months needs an acceptable reason, not just convenience, and how long convenience alone is allowed?
  • Can you state how long negotiable-instrument authorization records must be preserved after the authorization expires?
  • Do you know what a firm must review and document before recommending an OTC equity security, including the extra step for a delinquent filer?
  • Can you state the three beliefs a member must reasonably hold before recommending a DPP, what it must keep in its files, and what a discretionary DPP trade requires?