Quick Answer
A member that issues or is affiliated with the issuer, or gets 5%+ of net proceeds, has a conflict of interest, needing prominent disclosure plus an unconflicted lead manager, a bona fide public market, investment grade securities, or a QIU. The restricted-persons rule bars new-issue equity to industry insiders. The executives rule bans spinning; the escrow rule covers contingent offerings.
These rules exist because a syndicate manager has the power to allocate scarce new-issue shares, and FINRA is concerned that the allocation will be used as an inducement, a kickback, or a self-dealing channel. The principal supervising a primary distribution must affirm that none of these patterns is in play.
Public Offerings With Conflicts of Interest
A "conflict of interest" exists under the public-offering conflict-of-interest rule if any of the following are true:
- The securities are issued by the member
- The issuer controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with the member or its associated persons
- At least 5% of the net offering proceeds will be used to repay a loan or credit facility from, or otherwise be directed to, the member, its affiliates and its associated persons, in the aggregate (net proceeds are after all issuance and distribution expenses, and underwriting compensation does not count toward the 5%; underwriting compensation includes the spread and fees for advisory work in connection with the offering)
- As a result of the offering and any transactions contemplated at the time of the offering, the member will be an affiliate of the issuer, the member will become publicly owned, or the issuer will become a member (or form a broker-dealer subsidiary)
An affiliate is an entity that controls, is controlled by or is under common control with the member. Control means any of:
- Beneficial ownership of 10% or more of an entity's outstanding common equity or preferred equity
- The right to 10% or more of a partnership's distributable profits or losses
- The power to direct the entity's management or policies
Each ownership test counts any right to receive the interest within 60 days of the member's participation in the offering.
When a conflict of interest exists, the member may participate only through one of two routes:
| Route | Requirements |
|---|---|
| (1) Prominent disclosure plus one condition | Prominent disclosure of the nature of the conflict, and one of: (A) the member(s) primarily responsible for managing the offering has no conflict, is not an affiliate of a conflicted member, and meets the Qualified Independent Underwriter (QIU) disciplinary-history standard; (B) the securities have a bona fide public market; or (C) the securities are investment grade rated (one of a nationally recognized statistical rating organization's four highest generic categories, such as BBB-/Baa3 or better), or are in the same series, with equal rights and obligations, as investment grade rated securities |
| (2) QIU participates | A QIU participates in preparing the registration statement and prospectus and exercises the usual standards of due diligence, and the offering document prominently discloses the nature of the conflict, the QIU's name and a brief statement of its role and responsibilities; the QIU has no separate duty to price the offering |
A bona fide public market exists when the issuer has reported under the Exchange Act for at least 90 days and is current, its securities trade on a national securities exchange with average daily trading volume of at least $1 million, and its common equity public float is at least $150 million. A market that is merely active or liquid does not qualify.
A member may make prominent disclosure in either of two ways:
- In a prospectus subject to Regulation S-K: a "(Conflicts of Interest)" notation after the Plan of Distribution entry in the table of contents, plus disclosure in the Plan of Distribution section and any Prospectus Summary
- In a document not subject to Regulation S-K: disclosure on the front page, with a cross-reference to the discussion inside the document and in the summary if there is one
The rule reaches only a public offering. These are outside it:
- A private placement, including a Regulation D offering under the private-placement safe harbor
- An institutional resale offering to qualified institutional buyers
- A Regulation S offering
- Exempted securities, such as U.S. government and municipal securities
The rule has no other list of exempt offering types. FINRA may separately exempt a member in exceptional and unusual circumstances.
A member with a conflict also may not sell the security to a discretionary account unless the account holder gives specific written approval of the transaction, and the member keeps documentation of that approval.
A Member's Own Public Offering: Escrow and Net Capital
When a member offers its own securities to the public, every dollar of proceeds goes into an escrow account. The member may not release or use the proceeds until it has:
- Immediately notified FINRA that the offering has terminated and settlement has been effected
- Filed with FINRA a net capital computation as of the settlement date (proceeds from the offering may count in that computation)
The member must return all money in full to the purchasers and withdraw the offering, unless the SEC has granted it a specific exemption from the net capital rule, if that computation shows any of these:
- A net capital ratio above 10 to 1
- Net capital below 120% of the minimum dollar amount the net capital rule requires
- For a member on the alternative standard, net capital below 7% of aggregate debit items
The offering document must disclose a date by which the offering is reasonably expected to be completed and the terms on which the proceeds will be released from escrow.
QIU Requirements
A Qualified Independent Underwriter must:
- NOT have its own conflict of interest under the rule
- NOT be an affiliate of any conflicted member
- Beneficially own no more than 5% of the class of securities that would give rise to the conflict, including any right to receive those securities within 60 days
- Agree to undertake the legal responsibilities and liabilities of an underwriter under the Securities Act, specifically including registration-statement civil liability
- Have served as underwriter in at least 3 prior public offerings of similar size and type during the 3 years before filing
- Have no supervisory associated person responsible for organizing, structuring or performing due diligence on public offerings who, within the prior 10 years, was convicted of, permanently enjoined for, or suspended or barred for an anti-fraud violation in connection with an offering
- Participate in the preparation of the registration statement and prospectus
- Exercise due diligence and accept registration-statement civil-liability exposure
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Prominent conflict disclosure is required on every route; a QIU is one conditional alternative.
- The 5% test uses net proceeds after issuance and distribution expenses, excluding underwriting compensation from the numerator.
- A QIU participates in preparation and due diligence and accepts underwriting liability; it has no separate pricing duty.
Restrictions on Purchases of Initial Equity Public Offerings
The new-issue allocation rule for restricted persons prohibits a member from selling shares of a "new issue" (initial equity public offering) to any account in which a "restricted person" has a beneficial interest. The rule exists because new issues are frequently underpriced; allowing industry insiders to access the spinout would convert public-offering allocation into an industry kickback. (This rule is sometimes called the free-riding and withholding rule.)
What Is Not a New Issue
A "new issue" is an initial public offering of an equity security made under a registration statement or offering circular. The definition then excludes these offerings, so the rule does not apply to them:
- Specified private placements and institutional resales to qualified institutional buyers; offerings under the small-offering exemption are excluded only if the securities are restricted
- Regulation S and other offshore offerings, unless the securities are also registered for sale in the United States in connection with a concurrent U.S. initial equity public offering
- Offerings of exempted securities, such as government securities
- Offerings of preferred securities
- Offerings of convertible securities
- Rights offerings, exchange offers and offerings made in a merger or acquisition
- Offerings of investment grade asset-backed securities
- Offerings of a commodity pool, or of a registered investment company
- Ordinary shares or American depositary receipts (ADRs) that already have a market outside the United States
- Offerings of a special purpose acquisition company (SPAC), a business development company, a direct participation program or a real estate investment trust (REIT)
Preferred stock is equity, but that alone does not make its offering a new issue. The exclusion list decides. Do not assume every exempt offering is excluded: a qualifying Regulation A common-stock initial public offering can be a new issue.
Restricted Persons
A "restricted person" is any of the following:
- Broker-dealers (members and any other broker-dealer)
- Broker-dealer personnel: any officer, director, general partner, associated person or employee of a member or other broker-dealer, and any agent of one that is engaged in the investment banking or securities business. Personnel of a limited business broker-dealer (one authorized only for investment company and variable contract securities and direct participation program securities) are not restricted
- Finders and fiduciaries: with respect to the security being offered, a finder or any person acting in a fiduciary capacity to the managing underwriter, including its attorneys, accountants and financial consultants
- A trustee, executor or other fiduciary is not restricted for that reason alone. The category reaches only a fiduciary to the managing underwriter
- Portfolio managers: any person with authority to buy or sell securities for a bank, savings and loan institution, insurance company, investment company, investment adviser or collective investment account
- Broker-dealer owners:
- Persons listed, or required to be listed, on Schedule A of a broker-dealer's Form BD, except those with an ownership code below 10%
- Persons on Schedule B, except those listed only through a Schedule A owner coded below 10%
- Persons owning 10% or more (Schedule A) or 25% or more (Schedule B) of a public reporting company on those schedules that is not listed on a national securities exchange
- Immediate family members of the persons above, under the tests in the next table
An immediate family member is a parent, mother-in-law or father-in-law, spouse, brother or sister, brother-in-law or sister-in-law, son-in-law or daughter-in-law, child, or any other person the restricted person materially supports.
Material support means directly or indirectly providing more than 25% of a person's income in the prior calendar year, and immediate family members living in the same household are deemed to support each other.
| Family member of | Restricted when the person in the first column |
|---|---|
| Broker-dealer personnel | (1) materially supports, or receives material support from, the family member; (2) is employed by or associated with the member, or its affiliate, selling the new issue to the family member; or (3) can control the allocation of the new issue |
| Finders, fiduciaries and portfolio managers | Materially supports, or receives material support from, the family member |
| Broker-dealer owners | Restricted unless the owner does not materially support or receive support from the family member, does not own the member (or affiliate) selling the new issue, and cannot control the allocation |
Exemptions and De Minimis
The rule has several built-in exemptions:
- De minimis: an account in which the beneficial interests of restricted persons do not exceed 10% in the aggregate, so an account at exactly 10% still qualifies
- A beneficial interest is any economic interest, such as the right to share in gains or losses. Fees for operating a collective investment account, or for acting as a fiduciary, are not a beneficial interest
- Exempt accounts, including registered investment companies, qualifying insurance company accounts and common trust funds, listed public companies (other than broker-dealers and their affiliates), qualified retirement plans not sponsored solely by a broker-dealer, state and municipal government plans, tax-exempt charitable organizations and church plans
- Issuer-directed shares: securities the issuer, an affiliate of the issuer or a selling shareholder specifically directs in writing to restricted persons
- Directed shares still may not go to a broker-dealer
- Nor to an account of broker-dealer personnel or of a finder or fiduciary, unless that person or an immediate family member is an employee or director of the issuer, its parent or subsidiary (or a franchisee of any of them)
- A separate exemption covers directed shares in an offering in which no broker-dealer underwrites, solicits or sells, or influences the allocation, and another covers an issuer program offered to at least 10,000 participants on uniform terms
- Stand-by purchasers under a disclosed written stand-by agreement, and anti-dilution purchases by an account that has held the issuer's equity for at least a year, each with a 3-month hold
Documentation
Before a sale, the member must have an eligibility representation obtained within the prior 12 months. It may come from the account holder or a person authorized to represent the account's beneficial owners. A bank, foreign bank, broker-dealer, investment adviser or other conduit may instead represent that all its new-issue purchases comply with the rule. The firm follows its own procedures for obtaining and recording it.
The 12 months are counted back from the sale, not from the order. A representation obtained 11 months ago works today, but it will be more than 12 months old by a sale planned 6 weeks from now, so it will not support that sale. The firm obtains a current one before the sale.
A member may not rely on a representation that it believes, or has reason to believe, is inaccurate. The member also keeps its eligibility records for at least three years after its last new-issue sale to that account.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- A current eligibility representation must be obtained within 12 months before sale and cannot be relied on if the firm has reason to doubt it.
- Family restrictions depend on support, selling-firm affiliation and allocation control as applicable.
- Preferred and convertible offerings are excluded from the new-issue definition even though equity status alone might suggest otherwise.
New Issue Allocations and Distributions
The new-issue allocation rule for executives layers on top of the restricted-persons rule and addresses several distinct allocation problems:
| Provision | What It Prohibits / Requires |
|---|---|
| Quid pro quo allocations | A member may not offer, or threaten to withhold, new-issue shares as consideration or inducement for compensation that is excessive in relation to the services provided. Excessive compensation is the test; ordinary commissions at standard rates do not trigger this provision |
| Spinning | A member may not allocate new-issue shares to an account in which an executive officer or director of a public or covered nonpublic company (or a person that executive materially supports) has a beneficial interest, if the company is a current investment banking client (or paid the member for banking in the past 12 months), the allocator expects the member to be retained within 3 months, or the allocation is conditioned on future banking business |
| Reports to the issuer | The book-running lead manager must give the issuer's pricing committee (or board) regular reports of indications of interest and, after settlement, a report of the final allocations |
| Market orders before secondary trading | A member may not accept a market order for a new issue before secondary-market trading in that security has begun, which prevents fills at an artificial pre-market price |
| Lock-up agreements | A lock-up on the issuer's officers and directors must also cover their issuer-directed shares. At least 2 business days before any release or waiver, the book-running lead manager must notify the issuer and announce it through a major news service, except for a transfer not for consideration or to an immediate family member who agrees in writing to the same lock-up terms |
| Flipping | A member may not recoup or reduce an associated person's commission or credit because a customer resells new-issue shares within 30 days after the offering date, unless the managing underwriter assesses a penalty bid on the entire syndicate. The member must also promptly record and maintain information about any penalties or disincentives it assesses on its associated persons in connection with a penalty bid |
Spinning in Detail
The spinning prohibition targets a specific abuse pattern: a syndicate manager allocates IPO shares to the personal account of a corporate executive whose company is also a banking client (or a prospective banking client). The IPO shares pop on day one; the executive's reward is a price-driven gift. The reverse leg of the deal is the executive's company directing future banking business to the syndicate manager.
The spinning prohibition covers new-issue allocations to accounts in which executive officers or directors of public companies, or of covered nonpublic companies (large private companies that meet the rule's income, equity, or asset tests), or persons they materially support have a beneficial interest. Subject to exemptions, any one of three conditions is enough; an express deal is not required:
| Trigger | What must be true |
|---|---|
| Current client | The company is a current investment banking client of the member, or the member received compensation from it for banking services in the past 12 months |
| Expected retention | The person making the allocation decision knows or has reason to know the member intends to provide, or expects to be retained for, banking services within the next 3 months |
| Quid pro quo | The allocation is made on the express or implied condition that the executive, for the company, will retain the member for future banking services |
Only the third trigger is a quid pro quo. The first two apply even when nobody says a word about a trade.
| Type of Account | Restricted Under the Spinning Rule? |
|---|---|
| Public-company executive officer / director | Yes, if any of the three triggers is met |
| Covered nonpublic-company executive / director | Yes, if any of the three triggers is met |
| Hedge fund where covered executives or directors and persons they materially support hold more than 25% in aggregate | Yes, if any trigger is met and no other exemption applies |
| Hedge fund where those executives, directors and supported persons hold 25% or less in aggregate | No. The rule exempts the account |
| Hedge fund where neither a covered executive or director nor a person they materially support has an interest | No |
The 25% aggregate exemption is not limited to hedge funds. It applies to any account in which covered executives and directors of the company and the persons they materially support hold 25% or less in total. Specified restricted-person account exemptions, including qualifying registered investment companies and retirement plans, also apply to spinning. The restricted-persons 10% de minimis exemption does not carry over; apply spinning's separate 25% test.
Allocations that the issuer, an affiliate, or a selling shareholder directs in writing are also outside the rule, if the member has no involvement or influence in those allocation decisions.
Think of it this way: The restricted-persons rule is about industry insiders. The spinning prohibition is about corporate clients. The two rules cover different conflict patterns and operate independently. A hedge-fund account may be a "covered" account under the spinning rule (because a portfolio company executive of a banking client holds more than 25% of it) but not a "restricted person" (no broker-dealer affiliation). Both rules can apply simultaneously.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Restricted-person and spinning tests have separate thresholds and exemptions.
- Spinning can arise from a current or recent banking relationship or expected retention without an express quid pro quo.
- The flipping provision limits recoupment of associated-person compensation; it does not prohibit customer resale.
Related Rules: Prohibited Representations and Escrow
Two rules complete the IPO-distribution regime:
| Rule | What It Does |
|---|---|
| Prohibited-representations rule | It is fraudulent to represent an offering is being made on an all-or-none or at least minimum contingent basis if the offering is NOT in fact being held on those terms |
| Escrow rule for contingent offerings | In best-efforts contingent offerings, customer payments must be promptly deposited in a separate bank account held by the broker-dealer as agent or trustee for the investors, or promptly transmitted to a bank that has agreed in writing to hold them in escrow. Funds go to the issuer only when the contingency occurs; otherwise, they are promptly returned to the persons entitled. Who releases them depends on the route: under the separate-account route, the broker-dealer transmits or returns the funds from that account once the event or contingency has occurred; under the escrow route, the escrow bank transmits or returns them directly to the persons entitled. In a non-contingent best-efforts deal, payments must simply be promptly transmitted to the persons entitled |
In a best-efforts contingent offering (e.g., minimum-maximum or all-or-none), the issuer does not get any proceeds until the contingency is met. Direct receipt and use of customer funds before satisfying the contingency is a fraud violation under both the prohibited-representations rule and the escrow rule.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Contingent best-efforts proceeds go to the separate investor-benefit account or written bank escrow route.
- Misrepresenting an offering’s contingency is a separate violation.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you state the 5% test for the conflict-of-interest rule, and confirm it applies to net proceeds, not gross?
- Do you know how often a firm must renew a customer's written representation of eligibility to buy new-issue equity?
- Can you name the three ways a broker-dealer employee's family member becomes restricted: support in either direction, the employee works for the selling member, or the employee can control the allocation?
- Can you distinguish the restricted-persons rule from the spinning prohibition, and name the three triggers of the spinning prohibition (only one is a quid pro quo)?
- Do you know the two places the escrow rule lets contingent-offering funds sit: a separate bank account the broker-dealer holds as agent or trustee, or a bank escrow agent under a written agreement?