Due Diligence on Issuers

Quick Answer

For non-expert management disclosures, an underwriter's defense requires reasonable investigation, reasonable grounds and an actual belief in accuracy at effectiveness. Another expert's certified work has a different reliance standard. The issuer cannot use a due-diligence defense. A completed checklist, a file or management's assurances do not automatically establish a defense.

Due diligence supports the underwriter's statutory defense and the principal's supervision. The applicable test depends on the disclosure and the defendant. Careful work can support a defense, but possessing a diligence file does not automatically defeat a claim.


The Due-Diligence Defense

The registration-statement remedy concerns a material defect when the relevant portion became effective. A purchaser must connect the acquired securities to that filing. Fraudulent intent generally need not be proved. Reliance generally need not be proved either, but a later-purchase condition applies after publication of an earnings statement covering at least twelve months beginning after effectiveness. Actual reading of the statement is not necessary to establish that reliance.

Purchaser knowledge and losses unrelated to the defect can affect recovery. The issuer's strict liability means that investigation or good faith does not supply a due-diligence defense. It does not make every alleged investor loss recoverable.

DefendantHow the Defense Applies
IssuerExcluded from the due-diligence defense; other statutory conditions still matter
Directors and signatoriesMay establish an applicable investigation or expert-reliance defense
UnderwritersMust support their own applicable defense rather than rely on another firm's approval alone
Certifying expertsMay defend their own certified work under the applicable expert standard

The principal identifies whose work is at issue:

MaterialApplicable Defense Standard
Non-expert management disclosuresReasonable investigation, reasonable grounds and actual belief in accuracy when the relevant portion became effective
Another expert's properly attributed materialNo reasonable ground for disbelief and no actual belief that the portion was materially false or misleading at effectiveness
An expert's own certified workThe applicable expert standard, including reasonable investigation and reasonable grounds for an actual belief in accuracy

Reasonable investigation uses the care of a prudent person managing their own property. It does not prescribe independent verification of every datum or one universal checklist. Management responses and supporting records can inform the work; unsupported assurances or an indemnity do not by themselves establish the defense.

Each defendant must establish its applicable elements. Coordinated work does not automatically establish every underwriter's defense, but the statute does not impose a blanket ban on coordinating investigation. Other statutory defenses, including specified withdrawal or lack-of-knowledge defenses, have separate conditions.

For another expert's certified work, the underwriter is not automatically required to repeat the expert's work. Known discrepancies still matter when assessing whether the reliance conditions can be met. An expert defending their own work cannot substitute the lower standard for relying on someone else's work.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Identify the actual material: issuer-supplied documents can include both expert and non-expert portions.
  • Good faith alone does not establish the non-expert defense; a file alone does not prove adequate investigation.
  • The issuer has no due-diligence defense, but other statutory conditions and defenses still matter.

Required Due-Diligence Activities

The following categories organize common review tasks. Their work can overlap; the applicable investigation and disclosure standards govern the offering.

1. Business and Financial Review

  • Management interviews with the CEO, chief financial officer (CFO), COO, and (when applicable) division heads
  • Site visits to material operating facilities
  • Review of audited and interim financial statements
  • Accounting policies review (revenue recognition, capitalization choices, reserves)
  • Cash-flow forecasts and the assumptions behind them
  • Major contracts: economic dependence and financial effects of customer, supplier, distribution and licensing agreements

Legal review can examine organizational authority, contractual rights and obligations, litigation, regulatory restrictions and intellectual-property rights. The work should address the issuer's relevant legal risks and support the applicable disclosures. These examples organize common tasks; they are not a closed statutory checklist or an exclusive assignment of documents to one team.

A material contract can be reviewed for both legal meaning and financial effects. Legal work may interpret consent, termination, indemnification or change-of-control provisions. Financial work may evaluate revenue dependence and the cost of losing the contract. An initial public offering (IPO) may trigger a change-of-control clause, depending on its terms.

For litigation, examine the actual claims, requested relief, materiality and applicable disclosure conditions and exceptions. The legal-proceedings disclosure requirement does not require disclosure of every lawsuit. A damages amount alone may not resolve the analysis, especially when a proceeding also seeks relief that could affect the issuer's operations.

Document labels do not establish rigid boundaries. Tax records, financial statements and management information can bear on legal issues as well as financial questions. Coordinate the relevant work; counsel's involvement does not automatically establish the underwriter's applicable defense or eliminate another team's analysis.

3. Industry / Competitive Review

  • Market position: market share, customer concentration, supplier concentration
  • Competitive risks: pricing power, technological obsolescence, new entrants
  • Regulatory environment: pending changes, recent enforcement actions in the industry

4. Management Background Review

Review relevant information about the issuer's directors, executive officers and other persons covered by the applicable disclosures. Background work can include business experience, disciplinary or regulatory history, litigation, family relationships and related-party dealings. The investigation should support the accuracy of the current registration statement; these examples are not a closed statutory checklist.

For a regulatory proceeding, obtain the relevant order and determine its nature, status and continuing effects. A settlement is not automatically material or immaterial. Apply the disclosure requirement's event, period and materiality conditions. The same assessment is needed when a director's litigation could affect the issuer's business relationships.

Family-relationship disclosure and related-person transaction disclosure are separate requirements. A relationship between specified directors and executive officers can require disclosure even without a transaction. Related-person transaction disclosure has its own conditions and exceptions. Do not substitute a general rule that family members matter only when a transaction exists.

Prior questionnaires can inform a later offering's diligence, but they do not establish that current disclosures remain accurate. Assess relevant changes and update the investigation as appropriate for the current disclosures.

5. Bring-Down Diligence

A bring-down is a refresh of due-diligence findings just before pricing and again at closing. It includes:

  • Final officers' certificates confirming no material adverse change since the last review
  • Comfort letters from auditors covering financial information published in the prospectus
  • Negative-assurance legal opinions from issuer counsel
  • Re-confirmation that representations and warranties in the underwriting agreement remain true

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Bring-down diligence is practice, not a named statutory step; it supplements investigation at effectiveness.
  • Comfort letters have limited scope; material adverse changes can require updated disclosure.

Documentation: The Diligence File

The firm must maintain written supervisory procedures and provide for registered-principal review evidenced in writing of its investment banking transactions. A reasonably designed risk-based system may focus detailed reviews on the areas posing the greatest risks of violation.

A diligence file can preserve evidence of the investigation and review. Depending on the offering, it may include the following materials; a completed file or signature does not establish the underwriter's defense automatically.

Documentation ItemWhat It Contains
Meeting minutesDate, attendees, topics covered, key statements made by management
Due-diligence questionnairesStandardized issuer-response document covering business, legal, financial topics
Expert reportsAuditor reports, engineering reports, FDA approvals, environmental assessments
Comfort lettersAuditor letters covering financial information in the prospectus
Background-check resultsBrokerCheck pulls, regulatory history searches, litigation searches for officers and directors
Site-visit memosNotes from physical inspections of material facilities
Principal reviewWritten evidence of the registered principal's review, following the firm's applicable approval procedures

Diligence records can be reached by FINRA examinations, SEC requests and litigation discovery. Regulatory access follows the applicable request and authority. In federal litigation, discovery generally reaches nonprivileged material relevant to a claim or defense and proportional to the case's needs, subject to court limits. A diligence file is not automatically producible in every lawsuit.

A party claiming privilege or trial-preparation protection for otherwise discoverable material must expressly assert the claim and describe the withheld material so others can assess it without revealing protected information. Counsel's involvement does not by itself protect the whole diligence file.

The broker-dealer must promptly furnish the SEC with requested records within the applicable recordkeeping requirement, in legible, true, complete and current copies. A member must also make requested records available to FINRA when a service provider holds them but the member controls or has a right to demand them.

When supplying requested electronic information to FINRA on portable media, use strong encryption and send the decryption key or confidential process in a separate communication. Encryption protects the transfer; withholding the key would prevent the requested access.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Follow the firm’s principal-review procedure, and distinguish its deadlines from statutory defense conditions.
  • Civil claim deadlines do not set record-retention periods; classify records and applicable holds separately.

Retaining Diligence Records

Identify each record's category, required period and starting event. A diligence file may contain records governed by different rules. FINRA's default requires at least six years for required FINRA books and records when neither FINRA rules nor applicable Exchange Act rules specify a period. That default does not make every diligence document a six-year record.

Civil limitation and repose periods govern deadlines for bringing claims. They do not independently set record-retention periods, and they are not added to recordkeeping periods to create a retention formula. A seven-year file policy still needs to account for the applicable record categories and starting events.

Check litigation and regulatory preservation holds before destruction. An active hold can require retaining covered records after their ordinary periods expire. Confirm that the applicable periods have elapsed and any hold has been properly released; offering closing alone does not authorize discarding the file.


Issuer Personnel Not Deemed Brokers

The issuer-associated-person safe harbor addresses when a qualifying person's participation in selling an issuer's securities does not make them a broker solely because of that participation. It does not exempt the securities offering from registration.

Covered people include qualifying partners, officers, directors and employees of:

  • The issuer
  • A corporate general partner of an issuer limited partnership
  • A company or partnership controlling, controlled by or under common control with the issuer
  • A registered investment adviser to a registered investment company that is the issuer

Every route requires, at the time of participation:

  • No statutory disqualification
  • No commissions or other remuneration based directly or indirectly on securities transactions in connection with participation
  • No broker-dealer association as defined for this safe harbor

That association definition excludes people whose functions are solely clerical or ministerial. It also excludes people required by state law to register solely because they are issuers or issuer-associated persons. These exclusions do not create a general exemption from state law.

The person must satisfy one complete activity route:

Specified Transactions

Permitted categories include sales to listed institutional purchasers, certain exempt transactions, specified reorganization or exchange transactions under plans submitted for vote or consent of the receiving security holders, and employee benefit or stock plans. Accreditation alone does not establish this route.

Substantial Non-Sales Duties

The person primarily performs, or intends primarily to perform at the offering's end, substantial non-sales duties for or on behalf of the issuer. They must not have been a broker-dealer or associated person of one within the preceding 12 months.

They may participate in selling an offering for any issuer no more than once every 12 months, excluding participation under the other two routes. For shelf offerings, that clock begins with the last sale under one registration.

Limited Activities

The person restricts participation to one or more of these activities:

  • Preparing or delivering written communications without oral solicitation, with content approved by a partner, officer or director of the issuer
  • Responding to purchaser-initiated inquiries with information limited to the registration statement or other offering document
  • Performing ministerial and clerical work

Substantial non-sales duties and the twelve-month limits are not universal conditions of all routes. The principal should check the actual role, compensation and every condition of the route being used. Failing to fit the safe harbor does not alone establish a broker-registration violation; the underlying broker analysis still matters.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Issuer title does not excuse transaction-based compensation under the safe harbor.
  • An offering exemption and the seller’s broker-registration analysis are separate.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you distinguish the due-diligence standard for non-expertised portions from the lower standard for expertised portions like audited financials?
  • Do you know why firms refresh diligence at pricing and closing, and why that bring-down adds to the effective-date investigation instead of replacing it?
  • Can you apply a firm's stated approval deadline and distinguish written principal review from the statutory defense conditions?
  • Do you know why comfort letters do not cover the business narrative or projections in the diligence file?