Loan Documents, Bankruptcy, and Investor Claims

Quick Answer

Debt securities follow loan documents and the bankruptcy regime: senior vs. subordinated (priority), secured vs. unsecured (collateral), and affirmative, negative, and financial covenants. Chapter 7 is liquidation; Chapter 11 is reorganization. Liquidation priority runs secured creditors, administrative expenses, unsecured creditors, subordinated debt, then equity. The principal must disclose covenants, defaults, and bankruptcy risks.

The Series 24 tests bankruptcy and loan-document mechanics because the principal supervising a debt offering or distressed M&A must understand what risks need to be disclosed and how creditor claims rank when the issuer fails.


Fundamental Terms of Loan Documents

Loan documents fall into a small set of structural choices the principal must recognize when reviewing a debt offering:

Senior vs. Subordinated Debt

CategoryWhat It Means
Senior debtPaid first among debt obligations; lower coupon (lower risk to the lender)
Subordinated debtPaid only after senior debt is satisfied; higher coupon (higher risk)
Mezzanine debtSubordinated debt that may also include warrants or equity participation; sits between senior debt and equity

Priority and cost run in opposite directions. In a liquidation, senior debt is paid first, then mezzanine, then equity. For the issuer, senior debt is the cheapest, mezzanine costs more, and equity costs the most. A lender that waits further back in the repayment line demands a higher return, such as a higher coupon or warrants.

Two notes from the same issuer face the same chance that the issuer fails to pay. Rank changes the loss: a junior holder recovers less when that failure happens, so junior debt carries more credit risk.

Secured vs. Unsecured

CategoryWhat It Means
Secured debtCollateralized through liens, security interests, or specified assets; in default, the secured lender has a direct claim on the collateral
Unsecured debtNo specific collateral; the lender has a general claim on the issuer's assets shared with other unsecured creditors

Covenants

Covenants are promises by the borrower that constrain its behavior during the life of the loan:

TypeWhat It Requires
Affirmative covenants ("must do")Provide financial statements, maintain insurance, comply with laws, pay taxes
Negative covenants ("must not do")Incur additional debt above limits, sell major assets, change capital structure, pay dividends without lender consent
Financial covenantsMaintain leverage ratios (Debt / EBITDA), interest coverage (EBITDA / Interest), minimum net worth, working-capital ratios

Events of Default

An event of default lets the lender accelerate the loan (demand immediate full repayment):

  • Payment default: missed interest or principal
  • Covenant breach: violation of an affirmative, negative, or financial covenant
  • Cross-default: default on another debt instrument triggers default here (a "cross-default" clause)
  • Bankruptcy: any bankruptcy filing by the borrower
  • Material adverse change (MAC): catch-all for major negative developments

Acceleration

Upon a default (and after any cure period), the lender can accelerate the loan, demanding immediate full repayment of principal and accrued interest. Acceleration is the lender's primary enforcement mechanism short of foreclosure.

Indentures (Public Bonds)

Public corporate bond offerings use an indenture governed by the Trust Indenture Act of 1939. The Act does not reach securities it exempts outright, including municipal securities and securities issued or guaranteed by the U.S. government.

An indenture has these parts:

  • A trustee acts on behalf of bondholders
  • Modification provisions specify what changes require bondholder consent
  • Redemption / call provisions specify when the issuer can repay early
  • Sinking fund provisions specify mandatory periodic principal repayment
  • Conversion provisions (if a convertible bond) specify when bondholders can convert to equity

Enforcing an Indenture

A single bondholder usually cannot declare default or sue over a covenant breach alone. Enforcement runs through the trustee:

  • The bondholder notifies the trustee of the breach and asks it to act.
  • A covenant breach usually becomes an event of default only after notice and any cure period (time the issuer has to fix the breach).
  • After an event of default, the trustee can accelerate or use the other remedies the indenture gives it, for all holders together.
  • Holders of a majority in principal amount can direct the time, method, and place of the trustee's remedies, under the Trust Indenture Act.
  • A no-action clause typically bars an individual holder from suing until the trustee has been asked to act and has not.
  • One right stays with each holder: the right to receive principal and interest when due, and to sue to collect it, cannot be impaired without that holder's consent.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Indenture terms govern notice, cure and remedies; a holder ordinarily asks the trustee to act.
  • Cross-default provisions can transmit a default to other obligations; acceleration generally follows an actual default and any cure period.

Bankruptcy: Chapter 7 vs. Chapter 11

Two bankruptcy chapters are tested:

ChapterWhat Happens
Chapter 7 (Liquidation)Assets are sold; proceeds distributed to creditors per priority; the entity ceases to exist
Chapter 11 (Reorganization)Debtor remains in possession; proposes a plan of reorganization approved by creditor classes and confirmed by the court; equity may be diluted or eliminated, but the entity may continue operating

In Chapter 7, the trustee liquidates assets and distributes proceeds. In Chapter 11, the existing management team (called the "debtor-in-possession" or DIP) typically continues to operate the company while it negotiates a plan with creditors.

The exam usually focuses on Chapter 7 priority because the priority rules are explicit. Chapter 11 outcomes vary by plan. Creditors may receive cash, new debt, or shares while the company continues operating.

The plan identifies claim classes and states how each is treated. The related disclosure gives holders enough information to evaluate that treatment. Creditors still need to understand what they would receive even though the company is reorganizing rather than selling all its assets.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Chapter 11 reorganizes and can preserve operations; Chapter 7 liquidates and common equity generally recovers last.

Priority of Claims in Liquidation

The priority of claims is the single most-tested fact in bankruptcy. The order from first paid to last paid:

PriorityClassWhy
1 (paid first)Secured creditorsUp to the value of their collateral; if the collateral covers the debt, they recover in full
2Administrative expensesAllowed post-petition operating costs and court-approved fees of the estate's professionals, including unsecured post-petition credit granted ordinary administrative-expense status
3Priority unsecured claimsCertain wages (within statutory dollar caps), certain taxes (within statutory caps), certain consumer deposits
4General unsecured creditorsTrade creditors, deficiency claims of secured creditors (the unsecured portion), unsecured bondholders
5Subordinated debtSubordinated bondholders (paid after general unsecured but before equity)
6Preferred shareholdersEquity claim, junior to all debt
7 (paid last)Common shareholdersResidual equity claim

Key Distinctions

  • Secured creditors get paid first up to the value of their collateral. The payment comes out of the collateral itself, not out of the pool shared with the other creditors. If the collateral is worth less than the secured debt, the unsecured "deficiency" rolls down to general unsecured (priority 4)
  • Administrative expenses include allowed case costs and qualifying unsecured post-petition credit. DIP financing is not one universal priority class: the statute and court order may authorize ordinary administrative treatment, superpriority, or liens. This simplified hierarchy does not replace reviewing collateral and financing terms.
  • Priority unsecured (priority 3) is a small bucket of statutorily preferred claims (capped wages, taxes within limits, consumer deposits). It is much smaller than general unsecured. Administrative expenses are also unsecured claims with priority over general unsecured claims, but this course lists them as their own class at priority 2. When a question asks for the claim's category, name the specific class and not the broad word "priority"
  • General unsecured (priority 4) includes the unsecured bondholders, trade creditors, and the unsecured-portion deficiency of any secured creditors whose collateral was insufficient
  • Subordinated debt (priority 5) is still a debt claim, paid after general unsecured but before any equity holders
  • Preferred shareholders (priority 6) are equity, paid after all debt classes
  • Common shareholders (priority 7) are the residual equity claim, paid last (and usually nothing)

Think of it this way: The waterfall has three big buckets: secured creditors and administrative expenses at the top, all unsecured creditors (priority, general, and subordinated) in the middle, and equity (preferred and common) at the bottom. The middle bucket is where the action is in most bankruptcies because secured creditors usually get paid in full and equity usually gets nothing.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Secured claims reach collateral value; an unsecured deficiency can join general unsecured claims.
  • Administrative and priority unsecured claims precede general unsecured claims; subordinated debt remains ahead of preferred and common equity.
  • Treatment of estate and debtor counsel fees depends on the applicable facts and approvals.

Implications for the Underwriting Principal

The principal supervising a registration statement has three deliverables tied to this material:

DeliverableWhat It Requires
Risk factor disclosureMaterial loan covenants, events of default, cross-default risks, and bankruptcy outcomes must be disclosed in the registration statement's risk-factor section under Regulation S-K
Going-concern explanatory paragraphsIf the auditor's report contains an explanatory paragraph raising substantial doubt about the issuer's ability to continue as a going concern (often called a going-concern qualification), the registration statement must disclose the uncertainty prominently: as a material risk under the Risk Factors caption and as a known uncertainty in the MD&A liquidity discussion, not only through the incorporated audit report and consent; if a going-concern issue emerges between filings, check whether the underlying events trigger a specific Form 8-K item, and reflect the doubt in the next 10-Q
Distressed M&A and debt restructuringIn a distressed transaction (Chapter 11 plan, exchange offer for unsecured bonds), the principal must oversee the firm's analysis of claims priorities, valuation of claims classes, and disclosure of restructuring outcomes to investors

A debt-for-equity exchange in a Chapter 11 plan, for example, calls for a clear account of which claim classes receive new shares and how existing equity is affected. The principal reviewing restructuring materials should check that the proposed treatment of bondholders is explained in the context of other classes and the company's value.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Assess material covenant risks and the actual events behind going-concern doubt for disclosure.
  • Chapter 11 creditors receive plan treatment; recovery depends on the plan and value rather than a universal fixed percentage.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you list the liquidation priority order from secured creditors down to common shareholders, including where subordinated debt ranks?
  • Do you know why a secured creditor with insufficient collateral recovers in two different priority buckets?
  • Can you distinguish Chapter 7 liquidation from Chapter 11 reorganization, and confirm a company can keep operating in Chapter 11?
  • Do you know why going-concern doubt that emerges between filings does not by itself require an 8-K, and what you check instead?