M&A, Tender Offers, and Fairness Opinions

Quick Answer

A tender offer must stay open at least 20 business days; the target responds within 10 business days via Schedule 14D-9. Crossing 5% ownership triggers Schedule 13D within 5 business days, unless Schedule 13G applies. Hart-Scott-Rodino requires premerger notice to the FTC and DOJ above statutory thresholds. FINRA's fairness-opinion disclosure rule requires disclosing conflicts and maintaining written procedures.

M&A and tender-offer transactions touch federal securities law in three different places: tender-offer mechanics under the Exchange Act, beneficial-ownership reporting, and fairness-opinion disclosure under FINRA's fairness-opinion rule. The principal supervising an investment-banking advisory practice must coordinate all three plus the antitrust filing obligation under Hart-Scott-Rodino.


Tender Offer Rules

A "tender offer" is a public offer to acquire a substantial portion of a target company's outstanding shares, typically at a premium to market. A small family of Exchange Act rules polices the conduct of the bidder, the target, and any third party with information about the offer.

RuleWhat It Does
Minimum offer periodAn offer must remain open at least 20 business days from commencement; if the bidder raises or lowers the price offered, the percentage of shares sought, or the dealer's soliciting fee, the offer must remain open at least 10 business days from the date notice of the change is first published, sent, or given; payment or share return must be prompt after termination
Target-company responseThe target company must, within 10 business days of commencement, communicate to its security holders its position on the offer (recommend acceptance, recommend rejection, express no opinion and remain neutral, or state it is unable to take a position) with the reasons for that position (filed on Schedule 14D-9, which also discloses any agreements, arrangements, or conflicts of interest between the target and the bidder or the target's own insiders)
Disclose-or-abstain dutyOnce a bidder has taken substantial steps toward a tender offer, any person (other than the bidder) who has material nonpublic information about it, and knows or has reason to know it came directly or indirectly from the bidder, the target, or someone acting for them, must either disclose the information (and its source) or abstain from trading; broader than the general anti-fraud insider-trading rule because it does NOT require a fiduciary breach
Partial-tender prohibitionsProhibits short tendering (tendering more shares than the long position to inflate proration)
Outside-purchase prohibitionProhibits purchases outside the tender offer by the bidder, dealer-managers, and affiliates from announcement through expiration. Exceptions include ordinary-course purchases by or through a dealer-manager or its affiliates, either as agent for someone who is not a covered person or as principal by a non-market maker offsetting a contemporaneous sale made after an unsolicited buy order from a customer who is not a covered person, and purchases by a dealer-manager's affiliate when, among other conditions, the dealer-manager maintains and enforces written information-barrier procedures and the purchases are not made to facilitate the offer

These are the standard periods absent applicable exemptive relief. For tender-offer periods, include the business day that starts the period: commencement is day one of the standard 20-business-day period, and a price-change publication day is day one of its 10-business-day period. If the event occurs on a nonbusiness day, count the first following business day as day one. Skip weekends and federal holidays.

Tender-Offer Disclose-or-Abstain in Detail

The tender-offer disclose-or-abstain duty is what distinguishes the tender-offer context from ordinary insider trading. Under classical insider-trading doctrine, a fiduciary breach (or misappropriation) is required. In the tender-offer context, no fiduciary breach is required. The duty turns on the source of the information instead.

Once a bidder has taken substantial steps toward a tender offer, any person (other than the bidder) who has MNPI about it must disclose or abstain. The duty applies if the person knows, or has reason to know, that the information is nonpublic and came directly or indirectly from the bidder, the target, or anyone acting on behalf of either one.

How the person got it does not matter: being told, overhearing it, or getting it through a chain of tippees all count.

This means a person who learns about a tender offer at a cocktail party (no fiduciary relationship, no misappropriation) is still bound by the duty and cannot trade on the information. That holds as long as the person has reason to know it traces back to the bidder, the target, or their advisers.

A person who hears a rumor with no sign of where it came from does not meet that source test.

The timing test matters too. The duty starts only once the bidder has taken substantial steps toward the offer. A tip about an offer the bidder is only considering does not trigger this rule, although other insider-trading theories can still apply.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Tender-offer trading restrictions depend on the information’s specified source and knowledge, not a fiduciary breach.
  • The standard offer stays open 20 business days; specified changes require at least ten business days from notice.
  • The target’s position is due within ten business days; outside purchases require separate exception analysis.

Issuer Tender Offers

When the issuer itself (not a third-party bidder) is the one tendering, additional rules apply:

RuleWhat It Does
Going-private transactionsIssuers and affiliates conducting transactions that would deregister the security or terminate listing must file Schedule 13E-3 with extensive disclosure of fairness, alternatives considered, and effects on unaffiliated security holders
Issuer tender offersIssuer self-tenders are subject to the 20-business-day minimum, change-disclosure rules, and prompt-payment rules; a Schedule 13E-4 filing was historically required (now folded into the unified Schedule TO)

The going-private regime is heavily focused on disclosure of why the transaction is fair to unaffiliated public shareholders, since the controlling parties are buying out the minority.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A covered going-private transaction can require Schedule 13E-3 without a tender offer.
  • Issuer and third-party tender offers use Schedule TO.

Beneficial Ownership Reporting

A person who acquires beneficial ownership of more than 5% of a class of registered equity securities must file:

FilingWho FilesDeadlinePurpose
Schedule 13DThe default form for any holder above 5%; required for a filer with intent to influence control and for any holder that does not qualify for 13GWithin 5 business days of crossing 5%Full disclosure: who, what, why, financing, plans
Schedule 13GPassive investors and qualified institutional investorsPassive investor (no control purpose, under 20% of the class): within 5 business days after the acquisition. Qualified institution (such as a registered broker-dealer, bank, insurance company, registered fund or adviser): within 45 days after the end of the calendar quarter in which the obligation arose, or within 5 business days after the end of the month in which its holding first exceeds 10%Shorter, less detailed disclosure for passive holders

Material changes to a 13D filing require an amendment within 2 business days. An acquisition or disposition of 1% or more of the class is deemed material. A smaller change may still be material, depending on the facts and circumstances. The 1% is calculated against the outstanding class, not against the filer's prior position.

Schedule 13G amendments run on a slower clock. Every 13G filer amends within 45 days after the end of each calendar quarter if the information in its last filing has changed materially by quarter-end. A change in the percentage that comes only from a change in the number of shares outstanding needs no amendment. Faster triggers add to that duty:

  • A qualified institution amends within 5 business days after the end of the month in which its holding first exceeds 10%, and again after any month in which it moves by more than 5 points of the class.
  • A passive investor amends within 2 business days after its holding exceeds 10%, and again within 2 business days after it moves by more than 5 points of the class.

Schedules 13D and 13G must be filed in structured machine-readable format.

Institutional Investment-Manager Reporting: Form 13F

A separate filing applies to large investment managers:

  • Investment managers exercising discretion over $100 million or more in covered exchange-listed equities must file Form 13F
  • Filing is quarterly, within 45 days of quarter-end
  • Discloses positions held but not trading activity within the quarter

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Schedule 13D is the default above 5%; Schedule 13G requires a qualifying route and has its own amendment triggers.
  • A 13D change of 1% or more is measured against the outstanding class; smaller changes can still be material.
  • Form 13F’s $100 million test concerns covered securities, not total assets under management.

Insider Reporting

Officers, directors, and beneficial owners of more than 10% of a class of registered equity securities are subject to insider reporting. An owner of exactly 10% is not an insider on this test.

FormTriggerDeadline
Form 3Initial statement of beneficial ownershipWithin 10 days of becoming subject to insider reporting
Form 4Changes in ownership (most insider trades, and gifts given away)Within 2 business days of the transaction
Form 5Annual statement of holdings and transactions not already reported, such as small acquisitions and other exempt transactionsWithin 45 days after the issuer's fiscal year end; not required if everything was already reported

Short-swing profit recovery: profits from any purchase-and-sale (or sale-and-purchase) of the issuer's stock within a 6-month period are recoverable by the issuer regardless of any insider information. This is a strict-liability disgorgement rule, not an anti-fraud rule.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Most Form 4 transactions are reported within two business days.
  • Short-swing recovery does not require insider information, subject to its applicable conditions.

Hart-Scott-Rodino: Premerger Antitrust Notice

The Hart-Scott-Rodino Act requires premerger notification for transactions exceeding statutory thresholds:

ElementRequirement
FilingBoth parties file with the FTC and DOJ Antitrust Division
Waiting period30 days for most transactions (15 days for cash tender offers)
ThresholdsSize-of-transaction and size-of-person thresholds (adjusted each fiscal year for changes in gross national product; check current values)
Effect of failure to fileCivil penalties; closing must await expiration or formal early termination of the waiting period

HSR is an antitrust filing, distinct from SEC '33 / '34 Act filings. The principal supervising an M&A advisory must coordinate both regulatory tracks: SEC for tender offers and proxy disclosure, FTC / DOJ for antitrust premerger review.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • HSR is a separate antitrust process; check current annually adjusted thresholds and the applicable waiting period.
  • Informal favorable feedback does not replace formal early termination.

The Fairness-Opinion Disclosure Rule

The disclosure duties apply when, at the time a member issues a fairness opinion to a company's board, it knows or has reason to know the opinion will be provided or described to the company's public shareholders. Separately, every member that issues fairness opinions must have written approval procedures. The rule therefore sets two sets of obligations: disclosure and process.

Disclosure Requirements

The member must disclose in the fairness opinion:

  • Whether the member has acted as financial advisor to any party to the transaction and, if applicable, that it will receive compensation contingent on the successful completion of the transaction for the opinion or for serving as advisor
  • Whether it will receive any other significant payment or compensation contingent on successful completion
  • Any material relationships that existed during the past 2 years, or that are mutually understood to be contemplated, in which compensation was received or is intended to be received from the relationship between the member and any party to the transaction
  • Whether any information that formed a substantial basis for the opinion and was supplied by the company requesting it was independently verified by the member and, if so, a description of what was verified (when nothing was verified, a blanket statement saying so is enough)
  • Whether the opinion was approved or issued by a fairness committee
  • Whether the opinion expresses a view on the fairness of the compensation to the company's officers, directors or employees relative to the compensation to public shareholders

Process Requirements

Any member issuing a fairness opinion must have written procedures for approving it, including:

  • The types of transactions and circumstances in which the member will use a fairness committee, and, where it uses one, the process for selecting its members, their required qualifications, and a process to promote balanced review, which must include review and approval by persons who do not serve on the deal team
  • The process to determine whether the valuation analyses used in the opinion are appropriate

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Covered fairness opinions disclose applicable material relationships and compensation, including the two-year lookback.
  • When a fairness committee is used, review and approval include persons outside the deal team; a committee is not universally required.

A handful of other rules require disclosure when a member's relationship with the issuer might affect the customer's investment decision:

RuleWhat It Requires
Control-relationship disclosure ruleA member with a control relationship with an issuer (common parent, common officers, large equity stake) must disclose the relationship to the customer before completing a transaction in that issuer's securities
Distribution-participation disclosure ruleA member that is a participant in a primary or secondary distribution must disclose participation to customers buying or selling that security
Undisclosed-control manipulation ruleAn undisclosed control relationship is treated as a manipulative or deceptive device
Distribution-interest disclosure ruleA member with a financial interest in a distribution must disclose that interest to customers
"At-the-market" sales ruleSales "at the market" of securities the dealer has helped distribute are deemed manipulative unless an actual independent market exists

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Disclose a control relationship before completing the transaction.
  • At-the-market sales by a distributor require the applicable independent-market analysis.

Regulation M-A: Standardizing M&A Disclosure

Regulation M-A standardizes disclosure for business combinations subject to Exchange Act registration:

  • Schedule TO (tender offers)
  • Schedule 13E-3 (going-private transactions)
  • Schedule 14A (proxy statements for M&A votes)
  • Registration statements for securities issued in M&A (often Form S-4)

Reg M-A is a unifying framework: rather than each filing having its own disclosure requirements, Reg M-A coordinates substance across the various M&A filings. The principal supervising an M&A advisory does not have to know every Reg M-A line item, but must verify the working group is following the unified Reg M-A framework rather than treating each filing as a one-off.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you state the minimum tender offer period, and how long the offer must stay open after notice of a change in price, percentage sought, or soliciting fee?
  • Do you know why the tender-offer disclose-or-abstain duty applies even without a fiduciary breach?
  • Can you state the deadline for filing a Schedule 13D after crossing 5% ownership with control intent?
  • Do you know how far back the fairness-opinion disclosure rule requires a lookback on material relationships and compensation?