Regulation M: Stabilization and Distribution

Quick Answer

Regulation M restricts bids and purchases during distributions. For ordinary priced distributions, the period starts at the later of the 1- or 5-business-day lookback or participant entry. An actively-traded exemption covers qualifying participant activity. Issuers face fewer exceptions. Stabilization requires compliant pricing, disclosure, identification, and records. Syndicate settlement is due 90 days after issuer delivery.

Regulation M is the rule that stops distribution participants from bidding for or buying the security they are distributing, so they cannot prop up its price during the offering. The principal supervising a distribution must ensure every desk knows when the restricted period begins, what activity is permitted, and what notice must go to FINRA.


Reg M's Core Definitions

TermDefinition
DistributionAn offering of securities that is distinguished from ordinary trading transactions by the magnitude of the offering and the presence of special selling efforts and selling methods
Distribution participantAn underwriter, prospective underwriter, broker, dealer, or other person who has agreed to participate or is participating in a distribution
Affiliated purchaserAny of three groups: a person acting in concert with a distribution participant, issuer, or selling security holder in acquiring covered securities; an affiliate whose purchases control, are controlled by, or are under common control with the purchases of any such person; or an affiliate that regularly purchases securities for its own account or for the account of others, or that recommends or exercises investment discretion over securities purchases and sales
StabilizationBidding for or purchasing a security to peg, fix, or maintain its price
Reference securityA security into which the offered security converts, exchanges, or is exercisable, or whose value determines the offered security's value in whole or significant part

The third affiliated-purchaser group reaches an affiliate by what it does, so a scenario does not need to show that the affiliate controls or coordinates the covered purchases. A wholly owned investment-advisory subsidiary that exercises investment discretion for client accounts falls in this group. The group stops applying to the affiliate only if all three conditions are met:

  • The distribution participant, issuer, or selling security holder keeps and enforces written policies that prevent information flow to or from the affiliate, and obtains an annual independent assessment of them.
  • The affiliate shares no officers or employees (other than clerical or support staff) that direct, effect, or recommend securities transactions.
  • During the restricted period, the affiliate does not make a market (other than as a specialist) and does not engage, as broker or dealer, in solicited transactions or proprietary trading in the covered securities.

An information barrier alone does not meet these conditions.

An offering can be a distribution without a traditional syndicate. Participant status depends on a person's actual role; a financial interest alone does not establish participation.

For example, a firm that agrees to solicit investors for the offering participates in the distribution even if it does not buy shares for its own account.

If a scenario only calls a firm a financial adviser, examine the services it agreed to perform and its actual activities. A flat advisory fee or the absence of its name from the prospectus cover does not settle whether it is a distribution participant.


The Restricted Period

The restricted period is the window when distribution participants and issuers / selling security holders cannot trade in the offered security or its reference security. The length of the restricted period depends on the security's liquidity:

Security TypeRestricted Period
Meets ADTV ≥ $100,000 AND public float ≥ $25 million1 business day before pricing
Does not meet those thresholds5 business days before pricing
Actively-traded (ADTV ≥ $1 million AND public float ≥ $150 million)Separate exemption from the distribution-participant restriction; it does not automatically exempt issuer-side activity
Low-default nonconvertible debt and preferred (issuer's 12-month probability of default of 0.055% or less, determined and documented in writing by the lead manager from a structural credit risk model)Excepted from the distribution-participant restriction entirely

For an ordinary priced distribution, the restricted period begins at the later of the applicable one- or five-business-day point before pricing and the time the person becomes a distribution participant. It ends upon that person's completion of participation. For an underwriter, its participation must have been distributed and related stabilization arrangements and trading restrictions terminated; an overallotment exercise exceeding the net syndicate short position prevents completion.

For a merger, acquisition or exchange-offer distribution, the period instead begins when proxy or offering materials are first disseminated to security holders and ends upon completion of the distribution.

Distribution-Participant vs. Issuer-Side Restrictions

RestrictionWho It CoversKey Difference
Distribution-participant restrictionDistribution participants (underwriters, dealers, others agreeing to participate) and their affiliated purchasersMore exceptions available (passive market making, certain odd-lot transactions, transactions in reference securities outside specific conditions)
Issuer-and-selling-shareholder restrictionIssuers and selling security holders and their affiliated purchasersFewer exceptions - issuer-side limits are stricter

A firm can hold both roles in one offering, for example a co-manager that also sells its own shares in the deal. The participant restriction hands that firm to the issuer-side restriction.

A distribution participant, or an affiliated purchaser of one, that is the issuer or a selling security holder of the securities being distributed follows the issuer-side restriction instead of the participant restriction. It gets only the issuer-side exceptions.

The principal must run the math on ADTV and public float value before the restricted period begins, and document the determination in the distribution notice filed with FINRA.

What the Distribution-Participant Restriction Excepts

The restriction lists specific excepted activities. The ones most often tested:

Excepted ActivityWhat It Covers
ResearchPublishing research that meets the research safe-harbor conditions
Stabilization and passive market makingTransactions that comply with the stabilization rule or the passive market-making rule
Odd-lot transactionsTransactions in odd lots, or offsetting odd lots in a qualifying odd-lot tender offer
ExercisesExercising an option, warrant, right, or conversion privilege set out in the security's terms; the exception covers the exercise, not buying more of a warrant or convertible that is a reference security
Unsolicited transactionsUnsolicited brokerage transactions, and unsolicited purchases, including the firm's own principal purchases, that are not made from or through a broker-dealer, on an exchange, or through an inter-dealer quotation system or an electronic communications network
Basket transactionsOrdinary-course bids or purchases of a basket of 20 or more securities in which the covered security is no more than 5% of the basket's value
De minimis transactionsPurchases totaling less than 2% of the security's ADTV, or unaccepted bids, by a firm that maintains and enforces written procedures reasonably designed to comply (not available to a passive market maker)
Within the distributionTransactions among distribution participants, and purchases from the issuer or selling security holder, that are not made on an exchange, an inter-dealer quotation system, or an electronic communications network
Offers and solicitationsOffering or soliciting offers to buy the securities being distributed

Some securities are excepted outright: actively-traded securities (unless issued by the participant or its affiliate), low-default nonconvertible debt and preferred, qualifying shelf asset-backed securities, exempted securities such as government securities, and redeemable shares of open-end funds and unit investment trusts.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The one-day period requires both ADTV and public-float thresholds; the ordinary start is the later of the lookback or participant entry.
  • A co-manager that is also a selling shareholder follows issuer-side restrictions, with fewer exceptions.
  • The unsolicited-purchase and exercise exceptions depend on the actual transaction and venue.

Short Sales Before Pricing

A separate Regulation M restriction targets short selling ahead of a priced offering. It applies to an offering of equity securities for cash under a registration statement (or a Regulation A offering statement) conducted on a firm-commitment basis; offerings not conducted on a firm-commitment basis are excepted.

It is unlawful for any person, not only a distribution participant, to sell the security short during the short-sale restricted period and then purchase the offered securities from an underwriter, broker, or dealer participating in the offering.

  • The short-sale restricted period is the shorter of (1) the 5 business days before pricing, ending with pricing, or (2) the period from the initial filing of the registration statement to pricing.
  • The violation is the purchase in the offering. It does not matter whether the offering shares are used to cover the short position.
  • Bona fide purchase exception: before pricing, the person buys at least the full amount of its restricted-period short sales during regular trading hours, after its last restricted-period short sale and no later than the business day before pricing, and the purchase is reported. The person also must not have made a reported short sale in the last 30 minutes of regular trading on the business day before pricing.
  • Separate accounts: a purchase in one account is permitted when the short sale was in a separate account and each account's trading decisions are made separately, without coordination.
  • Investment companies: a registered fund may buy in the offering even though an affiliated fund, or a separate series of the same fund, sold short in the restricted period.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The short-sale period is the shorter of five business days before pricing or the period since initial filing.
  • Absent an exception, buying in the offering after a restricted-period short sale is prohibited even without using those shares to cover.

Stabilization

Stabilization is legal manipulation, the only kind permitted in a registered offering. Outside the stabilization rule's conditions, any bid intended to peg the price is illegal manipulation under the anti-manipulation provisions of the Exchange Act.

The conditions for permitted stabilization:

ConditionWhat It Requires
Price ceilingApply the stabilization rule's initial, maintained, or increased-bid conditions, including its offering-price and principal-market stabilizing-bid ceilings
One bid per priceNo more than one stabilizing bid in any one market at the same price at the same time
Notice and purpose disclosureAnyone displaying or transmitting a bid it knows is for stabilizing must give prior notice to the market on which it will stabilize and disclose the stabilizing purpose to the person with whom the bid is entered
Prospectus disclosureThe prospectus must state the intention to stabilize and briefly describe it (the standard disclosure language: "stabilizing bids may be entered which raise or maintain the market price"). The same duty covers syndicate covering transactions and penalty bids (see below)
RecordkeepingThe manager must record each stabilizing purchase (price, date, and time) and the syndicate roster, and keep the records at least 3 years (see Stabilization Recordkeeping below)
Identifying markOn Nasdaq, stabilizing bids are identified through Nasdaq's stabilizing-bid mechanism

Initiating, Maintaining, Increasing, and Reducing a Stabilizing Bid

  • Ceiling: no stabilizing bid may be higher than the lower of the offering price or the stabilizing bid in the principal market
  • Initiating (principal market open): start no higher than the last independent transaction price in the principal market, if the security traded there that day or the prior trading day and the current ask is at or above that price. Otherwise, start no higher than the highest current independent bid in the principal market
  • Maintaining: a bid that has not been discontinued may stay at its price, or be carried over into another market, even if independent bids or trade prices move below it
  • Increasing: raise it no higher than the highest current independent bid in the principal market (or, if that market is closed, the highest independent bid at its previous close)
  • Reducing: lower it at any time. Once stabilizing stops, it may resume only at a price at which a new bid could be initiated

Syndicate-Covering and Penalty Bids

The stabilization rule also permits two related activities:

  • Syndicate-covering transactions: closing a syndicate short by buying back in the open market. They are separate from stabilizing bids, so the stabilizing-bid price ceiling does not automatically govern them. The manager must still follow the covering rules, including prior notice to the self-regulatory organization with authority over the principal market and the ban on manipulative conduct.
  • Penalty bids: the managing underwriter reclaims a selling concession from a syndicate member when securities originally sold by that member are purchased in a syndicate covering transaction. A customer flip alone does not establish a penalty bid

These are not stabilization in the strict sense but are governed by the same anti-manipulation framework.

The prospectus must also cover them. The plan-of-distribution item of Regulation S-K applies to an underwriter or selling group member that intends any of these:

  • Stabilizing
  • Syndicate short covering transactions
  • Penalty bids
  • Any other transaction that may stabilize, maintain, or otherwise affect the security's price

That firm must indicate the intention and briefly describe each transaction. This is a requirement, not a market custom. A prospectus that describes only the stabilizing bids is incomplete when the syndicate also plans covering or penalty bids.

A syndicate short often comes from overallotment. The issuer may grant the underwriters an overallotment option (the "green shoe") to buy additional shares for offering to the public. In a firm-commitment offering, FINRA's corporate-financing rule prohibits, as an unreasonable term, an overallotment option of more than 15% of the securities being offered, computed without counting the option shares themselves.

The syndicate can close an overallotment short in two ways. It can exercise the overallotment option, which buys shares from the issuer. Or it can buy shares in the open market in a syndicate covering transaction. Without an option, the syndicate has no right to demand shares from the issuer, so it must cover in the market.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Stabilization must satisfy its applicable pricing, notice and disclosure conditions.
  • Initial, maintained and increased bids have different tests; one market cannot have two stabilizing bids at the same price simultaneously.

Stabilization Recordkeeping

The Exchange Act stabilization-recordkeeping rule covers a manager that stabilizes, effects syndicate covering transactions, or imposes a penalty bid in a registered offering. It also covers a Regulation A offering and an offering over $5,000,000. The manager must promptly record these items:

  • Name and class of the security stabilized (or covered, or subject to a penalty bid)
  • Price, date, and time of each stabilizing purchase or syndicate covering transaction, by the manager or by any syndicate participant, and whether any penalties were assessed
  • Names and addresses of the syndicate or group members
  • Each member's commitment, or its percentage participation in a standby or contingent underwriting
  • The dates any penalty bid was in effect

The manager keeps these records for at least 3 years, the first 2 years in an easily accessible place. A record already kept under the general broker-dealer books-and-records rules need not sit in a separate file if the firm can sort and retrieve it promptly.

The rule also sets two communication duties:

  • The manager promptly tells each syndicate member the security's name and class and the date and time of the first stabilizing purchase. It also tells each member when stabilizing ended.
  • A syndicate participant that is not the manager and stabilizes or covers must tell the manager the price, date, and time within 3 business days, and when it ended.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Record the price, date and time of covered stabilizing purchases and covering transactions, along with required syndicate information.

Nasdaq Stabilization Mechanics

Two Nasdaq rules implement Reg M mechanics on the Nasdaq market:

RuleWhat It Does
Nasdaq stabilizing-bid mechanismStabilizing bids in Nasdaq-listed securities (procedural mechanics for entering and identifying a stabilizing bid in the system)
Nasdaq penalty-bid identification mechanismPenalty bids and syndicate covering transactions in Nasdaq securities (notice and identification rules)

These rules ensure stabilization activity is identifiable and surveilable by the exchange. A Nasdaq stabilizing bid is flagged in the system so that regulators can distinguish it from ordinary market making.


The Distribution-Notice Requirement

A member acting as manager (or similar capacity) of a Reg M-covered distribution must give written notice to FINRA before the restricted period begins. The notice includes:

ItemWhat It Documents
Restricted period determinationWhether a 1-day or 5-day restricted period applies and the basis for the determination (ADTV and public float value math)
Restricted period commencementContemplated date and time of restricted-period commencement
Security identificationSecurity name and symbol
Distribution participantsIdentification of distribution participants and affiliated purchasers

Timing: Notice must be submitted no later than the business day prior to the first complete trading session of the restricted period.

If no member is acting as manager, each distribution participant is responsible for filing unless another member assumes the duty in writing.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The manager files the distribution notice before the restricted period and documents the basis for its determination.

Settlement of Syndicate Accounts

FINRA's syndicate-account rule measures deadlines from delivery of the securities by the issuer to or for the account of the syndicate:

  • Final settlement of accounts is due within 90 calendar days after that delivery date.
  • For corporate-debt offerings, the manager must remit to each syndicate member at least 70% of the gross amount due to that member within 30 calendar days, with any final balance due within 90 days.
  • No later than final settlement, the manager must give each syndicate member an itemized statement of syndicate expenses. Where they apply, the rule's categories are legal fees, advertising, travel and entertainment, closing expenses, loss on oversales, telephone, postage, communications, co-manager's expenses, computer and data processing charges, interest expense, and miscellaneous.
  • Miscellaneous should hold only minor items that cannot be easily categorized and should not be disproportionately large. Any other major item is itemized separately.

Late or incomplete settlements are FINRA-rule violations distinct from any underlying compensation issue.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Issuer delivery starts the 90-day final settlement clock.
  • For corporate debt, remit at least 70% of each member’s gross amount due within 30 days; provide the itemized statement by final settlement.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you state the trading-volume and public-float thresholds that set the 1-day restricted period rather than the 5-day period?
  • Can you distinguish the stabilization rule's initial-bid conditions from its maintaining and increasing conditions?
  • Can you state the deadline for filing the distribution notice relative to when the restricted period begins?
  • Do you know why issuer delivery starts the syndicate-account deadlines, and what a corporate-debt syndicate manager owes each member by day 30?
  • Can you state the short-sale window before pricing, and why buying in the offering after a short sale in that window is prohibited even if the shares never cover the short?