What Counts as "Research"

Quick Answer

An equity research report contains written company or industry equity analysis and information reasonably sufficient for an investment decision, subject to express exclusions. Analyst status under the conflicts rule concerns responsibility for report substance or a related preparation reporting role. Registration uses a separate definition; examination waivers can apply. Titles and written delivery formats do not decide classification.

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) equity research-analyst conflicts rule governs research reports, covered public appearances and interactions involving research analysts. Classifying a document is one part of supervision. Its exclusion from the report definition does not remove an analyst's separate conduct restrictions, appearance obligations or applicable communications standards.


The Two-Part Research-Report Test

ElementWhat It Requires
Element 1: Subject and contentAnalysis of equity securities of individual companies or industries, other than an open-end registered investment company that is not listed or traded on an exchange
Element 2: SufficiencyThe communication provides information reasonably sufficient upon which to base an investment decision

Both elements must be present, and an express exclusion can still remove a communication that meets them. A bare "we like XYZ common stock at $40" statement with no analysis or supporting information fails the required analysis and sufficiency conditions. A note limited to macroeconomic conditions is excluded economic commentary. Industry equity analysis can qualify without naming an individual stock; the actual analysis matters.

Different written containers can carry research reports. Examples include:

  • Research notes and morning call sheets
  • Slide decks distributed to clients
  • Email blasts that summarize an analyst's view
  • Electronic publications posted to the firm's research portal
  • Website text and written webinar or podcast transcripts

A written note delivered as a portable document format (PDF) file, email, portal text or secure electronic attachment remains subject to the analysis, sufficiency and exclusion tests. This does not automatically classify every audio or video recording as written research. A speaking event or interview requires its own public-appearance assessment, and a distributed written transcript requires a separate report assessment.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Equity research reports require qualifying analysis and sufficient investment information, subject to exclusions.
  • Industry analysis can qualify without named stocks; written transcripts and original speaking events need separate assessment.
  • A convertible can be an equity security under the incorporated definition.

Debt research has a separate framework. Its debt-security definition excludes equity securities, municipal securities, security-based swaps and U.S. Treasury securities. Its report definition requires written analysis of a debt security or its issuer and sufficient investment information, with its own exclusions.

The small-audience debt exclusion concerns analysis prepared for a specific person or a limited group of fewer than 15 persons; the equity exclusion instead concerns distribution to fewer than 15 persons.


Excluded Communications: Not "Research Reports"

The equity report definition excludes communications limited to:

  • Communications limited to broad-based indices (e.g., a Russell 2000 commentary)
  • Commentaries on economic, political, or market conditions (a Fed-policy memo, a recession-risk note)
  • Technical analysis of sector, index or industry demand and supply based on trading volume and price (a momentum note on the energy sector that does not name individual stocks)
  • Statistical summaries of multiple companies' financial data, including listings of current ratings
  • Recommendations regarding increasing or decreasing holdings in particular industries or sectors
  • Notices of rating or price-target changes, if the member simultaneously directs readers to the most recent research report on the company containing all current applicable disclosures and no materially misleading disclosures, including outdated or inapplicable disclosures

The definition also excludes the following, even where company equity analysis and sufficient information are present:

  • A communication distributed to fewer than 15 persons
  • Periodic reports or other communications for investment company shareholders or discretionary investment account clients discussing individual securities in the context of past performance or previously made discretionary decisions
  • Internal communications not given to current or prospective customers

Other express exclusions cover statutory prospectuses filed as part of a registration statement, and private placement memoranda or comparable offering-related documents prepared in connection with investment banking services transactions, except those that purport to be research. There is no blanket exclusion for every solicitation or offering-related document.

A names-only watchlist with no analysis or sufficient information fails the basic report conditions; it does not need an invented listings-without-recommendations exclusion.

A client-solicitation deck that only describes the firm's research process fails the same way, because it analyzes no issuer's equity securities. It is outside the definition by Element 1, not by a solicitation exclusion.

Conversely, factual annotations or listings of current ratings do not automatically destroy the statistical-summary exclusion. Assess the actual added content.

A supported stock-specific top pick takes a note beyond the limited sector-allocation exclusion, but overall report status still requires the analysis and sufficiency conditions and assessment of other exclusions.

A communication that is not a research report can still trigger:

  • FINRA's communications standards and supervisory procedures for client communications. Retail communications, institutional communications and correspondence have different approval and review provisions and exceptions; an exclusion does not imply either no supervision or uniform compliance preapproval.
  • Regulation Analyst Certification (Regulation AC) under its separate definitions and conditions. Its report definition requires written security or issuer analysis and sufficient investment information. Absent an applicable exemption, a broker-dealer or covered person providing such a report to a U.S. person in the United States must include the required clear and prominent analyst certification. A FINRA exclusion does not automatically settle that separate test.

Regulation AC has a separate public-appearance definition covering qualifying interviews, seminars and forums involving a specific recommendation or sufficient security or issuer information.

When a broker-dealer provides reports by an analyst employed by it or a covered person to U.S. persons in the United States, it must make the required record within 30 days after a quarter with appearances, containing the analyst's personal-view and unrelated-compensation statements. Foreign-analyst conditions and other applicable exceptions require separate assessment.

This quarterly record is different from certification in a written report; neither obligation follows automatically from every public recommendation.

FINRA's equity public-appearance definition concerns an analyst's equity recommendation or opinion in specified speaking activities before 15 or more persons or a media representative, media interviews or print-media articles.

A password-protected webcast, call or similar event for at least 15 existing customers is excluded only if all participants previously received the most current report or other documentation with required applicable disclosures, and the analyst corrects and updates inaccurate, misleading or no-longer-applicable disclosures during the event. The FINRA audience threshold and customer exception do not replace Regulation AC's separate conditions.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Limited sector allocation, internal-only material and qualifying target-change notices have distinct exclusions.
  • A customer distribution or substantive update requires checking all applicable conditions.

Who Is a "Research Analyst"?

ElementWhat It Requires
Conflicts-rule definitionAn associated person primarily responsible for preparing the substance of a research report, and any associated person reporting directly or indirectly to a research analyst in connection with preparing that substance, regardless of title
Registration definitionAn associated person whose primary job function is investment research and who is primarily responsible for equity-report substance or whose name appears on an equity research report
QualificationsRegistration normally requires the Securities Industry Essentials examination, Series 86 for analysis and Series 87 for regulation, subject to applicable prior qualification, exemptions and waivers

The conflicts definition concerns responsibility for a report's substance, not a percentage of work hours. An occasional writer can meet it when primarily responsible for an actual research report. A strategy associate primarily responsible for report substance can be an analyst regardless of title. Someone who writes only excluded macro notes and has no qualifying report-preparation role does not become an analyst merely by publishing those notes.

Assess conflicts status, registration and supervisory qualifications separately. An organization-chart label or byline alone is not the conflicts definition. A supervisor can be primarily responsible for preparing report substance without writing personally; pure conduct supervision without a qualifying preparation role does not itself establish analyst status. Research Principal and Supervisory Analyst registration routes depend on actual duties, so not every supervisor must pass the same analyst examination pair.

On written request, the analytical-examination waiver requires passing Levels I and II of the Chartered Financial Analyst examination, or Levels I and II of the Chartered Market Technician examination for an analyst preparing only technical research reports. That technical research must be based solely on stock-price movement and trading volume, rather than company financial information, business prospects, management contact or securities valuation.

The applicant must also have worked continuously as a research analyst since passing Level II, or apply for registration within two years of passing Level II. This analytical waiver does not waive the regulatory analyst examination. General examination waivers and prior qualification or foreign-analyst relief have their own requirements; another qualification alone does not automatically supply relief.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Primary responsibility for report substance can establish conflicts-rule analyst status even for an occasional writer or a non-writing supervisor.
  • Series 86 concerns analysis and Series 87 regulation; an analytical waiver does not waive the regulatory examination.

Investment Discretion Under the Exchange Act

A separate but related concept the exam tests is investment discretion under the Securities Exchange Act:

  • A person exercises investment discretion with respect to an account if the person:
    • Is directly or indirectly authorized to determine what securities or other property are bought or sold by or for the account, or
    • Makes those decisions in fact, even though someone else may have responsibility for them, or
    • Otherwise exercises influence over those purchases and sales that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), by rule, determines should be subject to the Act

The influence route has a limit. Having influence over an account's trades does not, by itself, make someone a person with investment discretion. Influence counts only when an SEC rule covers that type of influence. The other two routes (authority to determine, and deciding in fact) do not need an SEC rule.

Investment discretion and research-content influence are separate definitions. Research-content influence concerns an associated person required to review report content or who has exercised authority to review or change a report before publication or distribution.

Legal or compliance personnel reviewing for compliance purposes are excluded from this category only when they are not authorized to dictate a recommendation, rating or price target. A title or early draft access alone does not establish required content review or exercised review/change authority. Absence of an actual change does not establish the qualified compliance exception.

The research early-trading safeguard covers research analyst accounts, research-analyst supervisors and associated content influencers. They must not benefit in trading from knowledge of report content or timing before intended recipients have a reasonable opportunity to act.

Absence of content-influencer status does not authorize misuse of advance research knowledge. The separate trading-ahead rule prohibits member inventory transactions based on nonpublic advance knowledge of a report's content or timing and requires information barriers to prevent trading personnel from using that knowledge for the member or any other person.

Associated persons have the same rule obligations as members. This separate rule concerns research emanating from the research department; reports produced elsewhere require assessment under other applicable duties.

For this separate trading-ahead rule, research includes written information from the research department that a reasonable person would expect to result in a transaction. This scope is broader than the equity and debt research-report definitions and includes communications distributed to fewer than 15 persons.

The separate bans on trading inconsistently with the most recent recommendation and on specified pre-offering purchases apply to research analyst accounts, not automatically every influencer's account. Account financial interest, discretion and control, and the defined account exceptions, matter.

Investment discretion also gates the soft-dollar safe harbor later in this unit. The statutory protection concerns paying a higher commission for brokerage and research services when the discretionary decision-maker determines in good faith that it is reasonable in relation to their value, viewed by the particular transaction or overall responsibilities for discretionary accounts.

It does not establish that a person without discretion has no fiduciary duty under other law, and it does not replace the separate research-content influence test.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Required review or exercised prepublication review authority can establish content influence; titles or no actual edit do not settle the test.
  • Investment discretion gates the soft-dollar safe harbor; actual investment decisions differ from mere execution.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you identify written company or industry equity analysis and sufficient investment information, then check every applicable exclusion?
  • Can you distinguish limited sector allocation, statistical summaries including current ratings, qualified target-change notices and the fewer-than-15-person exclusion?
  • Can you separate conflicts-rule preparation responsibility from registration job-function criteria and applicable examination relief?
  • Can you distinguish account investment discretion from required or exercised report-review authority, and identify which trading safeguard applies to each covered actor or account?
  • Can you assess communications supervision, report certification and quarterly appearance records under their separate conditions?