Quick Answer
Under the Securities Exchange Act (SEA), a broker is in the business of effecting securities transactions for others; a dealer buys and sells for its own account as a business. Capacity follows whose account is used. Federal registration with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) generally applies when brokerage or dealing uses interstate commerce, subject to statutory exceptions.
The Series 24 starts every registration question with one fact pattern: did the firm act as a broker (agent) or a dealer (principal), and did that activity rise to the level that requires SEC registration? Get the agent-versus-principal distinction wrong and every downstream answer collapses.
Statutory Definitions
The two foundational definitions sit in the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (SEA):
| Term | Definition | Capacity |
|---|---|---|
| Broker | Any person engaged in the business of effecting transactions in securities for the account of others | Agent (earns commission) |
| Dealer | Any person engaged in the business of buying and selling securities for his own account, through a broker or otherwise | Principal (earns markup or markdown) |
- A single firm typically acts as both broker and dealer depending on the transaction; the firm registers as a "broker-dealer" (B/D)
- Capacity follows whose account is used, not the fee label or confirmation format. Transaction-based agency commissions are disclosed on confirmations; certain nontransaction-based remuneration under a written agreement is excepted. Principal markups are embedded in prices, and additional principal price-difference disclosures may apply
- A markup or markdown is measured against the prevailing market price, not automatically the dealer's acquisition cost. A purchase/resale spread may be trading profit without proving a markup or markdown on either leg
- Firms set their commission schedules subject to fair-commission requirements; neither the SEC nor FINRA sets a uniform commission rate
- A firm matching a customer order with a counterparty is acting as a broker; a firm that buys securities into inventory and resells them is acting as a dealer
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Broker capacity acts for another account; dealer capacity trades for the firm’s account.
- First-time dealer activity is a material FINRA business change even though Form BD covers both capacities.
- Confirmation formatting alone does not establish capacity.
Trader and Bank Exceptions
Not every person who buys and sells securities meets the dealer or broker definition:
- Trader exception: Buying and selling for one's own account that is not part of a regular business (e.g., a private investor managing a personal portfolio) is excluded from the dealer definition. The test is the activity, not the type of person: an investor is buying for personal investment, while a firm that trades its own account as a regular business is a dealer and registers on Form BD.
- Bank exclusions: Specified trust, custody, and networking activities are excluded only when their applicable conditions are met. The trust exclusion requires qualifying fiduciary examination, chiefly qualifying fee compensation, and limits on public brokerage solicitation.
- Bank execution restriction: For trust, certain plan, and custody activities involving U.S. trades in U.S. publicly traded securities, the bank generally directs execution to a registered broker-dealer unless a qualifying fiduciary cross or another permitted execution exception applies.
- Networking and custody have their own conditions; these are not blanket exclusions for banks.
Think of it this way: The statute targets people who are "engaged in the business" of effecting transactions. A retiree buying stocks in their own brokerage account is not running a broker-dealer business. A bank can rely on the trust exclusion only if it meets the fiduciary, compensation, solicitation, and applicable execution conditions. The key phrase the exam tests is "engaged in the business".
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The trader exception concerns own-account dealing; brokerage for others has its own engaged-in-business test.
The Exchange Act Registration Requirement
The trigger that converts the definitions into a duty is the Exchange Act's broker-dealer registration regime:
- Registration mandate: It is unlawful for any broker or dealer to use the mails or any instrumentality of interstate commerce to effect transactions in securities (other than an exempted security, or commercial paper, bankers' acceptances, or commercial bills) unless registered with the SEC. A broker or dealer whose business is exclusively intrastate and that uses no facility of a national securities exchange is outside this trigger
- Application path: Filed with the SEC
- Form BD requirement: The application must be made on Form BD in accordance with its instructions
- Membership and state registration: Federal registration generally becomes effective only upon required registered securities association membership, or national securities exchange membership for a firm trading solely on that exchange, unless the SEC grants a membership exemption. An ordinary nonexempt over-the-counter (OTC) firm needs the required association membership. Applicable state registrations are separate
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Federal filing, required membership and applicable state registration are separate requirements.
- The intrastate exception requires exclusively intrastate business and no use of a national exchange facility.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you distinguish a broker, who acts as agent for commissions, from a dealer, who acts as principal for markups or markdowns?
- Do you know the trader exception applies only to buying and selling for one's own account, not for someone else's account?
- Can you state that a broker-dealer whose business is exclusively intrastate and uses no national exchange facility is outside the federal registration trigger?
- Do you know Form BD is the common application across regulators, with initial paper filing through CRD and separate approval requirements?