LULD and Market-Wide Circuit Breakers

Quick Answer

LULD pauses bar trades but permit displayed bids and offers. An unresolved 15-second Limit State ordinarily triggers a pause, with a first reopening attempt after five minutes. Market-wide circuit breakers use S&P 500 declines of 7%, 13%, and 20%. Regulatory-halt publication restrictions, reopening permissions and applicable price bands require separate checks.

Modern markets use volatility controls at different scales. The Series 24 supervisor must distinguish the single-stock Limit Up-Limit Down (LULD) mechanism from Market-Wide Circuit Breakers (MWCB), and apply each halt's transaction, publication and resumption requirements.


Single-Stock LULD (Reg NMS Plan)

The Limit Up-Limit Down plan applies to covered national market system (NMS) stocks during regular trading hours. Rights and warrants are excluded. Trading centers must maintain and enforce written procedures reasonably designed to comply with its price-band and pause requirements. The regular-hours mechanism works as follows:

  • Ordinary calculation uses the arithmetic mean of eligible reported trades over the preceding five minutes. A new reference requires both at least a 1% change and at least 30 seconds on the current reference. Without eligible trades, the prior reference remains. Openings, reopenings and exit from a Limit State have separate procedures
  • Around the reference price, price bands define the acceptable trading range
  • A Limit State occurs when the national best offer equals the lower band without crossing the national best bid, or the national best bid equals the upper band without crossing the national best offer
  • To exit before a pause, the entire size of all quotations creating the state must execute or cancel within 15 seconds. Otherwise the primary listing exchange declares a pause. The processor freezes reference and band updates during the state; timely clearance causes an immediate update using the preceding five-minute eligible-trade mean, including the state period
  • A primary-market reopening attempt ordinarily follows five minutes after pause declaration, absent a regulatory halt. Actual resumption depends on the reopening, extension, price-band and special procedures below

A primary listing exchange may also declare a pause in a Straddle State: the national best bid is below the lower band or the national best offer is above the upper band, the stock is not in a Limit State, and trading deviates from normal characteristics such that a pause would support the Plan's volatility objective. A band touch alone is not the complete pause test.

LULD Bands by Tier and Time

Prior Primary-Market Close and TierOrdinary Base ParameterClosing Treatment
Above $3, Tier 1: S&P 500, Russell 1000 and specified exchange-traded products (ETPs)5%Double the applicable parameter to 10%
Above $3, nonleveraged Tier 210%No closing doubling; ordinary parameter remains 10%
$0.75 through $3.00 inclusive, either tier, before any leverage adjustment20%Double the applicable parameter
Below $0.75, either tier, before any leverage adjustmentLesser of $0.15 or 75% of the effective referenceDouble the applicable parameter

The prior primary-market close selects the parameter category. If no closing price exists, use the last primary-market sale reported by the processor. Apply the selected parameter around the effective reference, rather than around that prior close. Tier 2 includes all covered stocks outside Tier 1, including lower-priced stocks. A leveraged Tier 2 ETP multiplies its applicable parameter by its leverage ratio.

Closing doubling covers all Tier 1 stocks and Tier 2 stocks at or below $3, from 3:35 to 4:00 p.m. ET on a normal closing day or during the final 25 minutes before an early scheduled close. Double the applicable parameter; the result is not universally 10% or 20%. There is no opening-period doubling.

Single-priced opening, reopening and closing transactions on the primary listing exchange are excluded from the outside-band execution limitation. Another transaction exclusion requires both an Order Protection Rule exception or exemption and no last-sale update for a reason beyond merely late reporting or odd-lot size. These execution exclusions do not permit trading while a pause remains in effect.

LULD Mechanics in Sequence

StepAction
1Apply the effective bands and their applicable execution limitations
2A national best offer at the lower band, or bid at the upper band, enters a Limit State only if it does not cross the opposite national best quotation
3If all Limit State quotations are executed or canceled entirely within 15 seconds, the state ends
4If the state does not exit within 15 seconds, the primary listing exchange declares a pause
5The primary market ordinarily first attempts reopening after five minutes; applicable extension, fallback and late-day procedures govern resumption

The 15-second test concerns the Limit State quotations, not the speed of every price move. One trade inside the band does not end the state if quotations creating it remain.

Opening References and Reopening Conditions

  • Ordinary opening: Unless a regulatory halt is in effect at the start of regular hours, an opening price on the primary listing exchange occurring less than five minutes after the start supplies the first reference
  • Opening-reference updates: During the first five minutes after that ordinary opening, use the eligible-trade mean since the opening, including the opening price, with the 1% and 30-second update conditions
  • Delayed opening: Without a regulatory halt at the start, if the primary opening does not occur within five minutes after regular hours begin, use the preceding five-minute eligible-trade mean
  • Normal pause reopening: The primary market attempts reopening after five minutes if it has not declared a regulatory halt, using its established procedures. An unsuccessful attempt can extend the pause
  • Normal reopening reference: The reported reopening price ends the pause and supplies the next reference when the primary market reopens with a transaction or a quote without a zero side. Subsequent references follow the normal opening procedure
  • Systems or zero-sided-quote reference: If the primary market notifies the processor that a systems issue prevents reopening, or reopens with a zero bid or offer, the next reference is the last effective band that was in a Limit State before the pause
  • Systems-failure bands: Without a regulatory halt, processor bands appear no earlier than ten minutes after pause declaration and use triple parameters for their first 30 seconds. Off-exchange fallback also requires processor bands and trading on at least one other national securities exchange
  • Off-exchange normal route: Trading must have commenced on the primary listing exchange. The member must either receive processor bands or, if the processor has not disseminated them but the reference is available, calculate bands using the processor's reference until receiving them. Primary-market resumption alone is insufficient
  • Final ten minutes: If the stock is paused during the final ten minutes of regular hours, the primary market does not reopen ordinary trading; it attempts a closing transaction under its closing procedures. Other centers may begin trading when that closing transaction executes, or if none executes within five minutes after regular hours end, after that five-minute interval
  • After a regulatory halt: An opening or reopening price within five minutes after the halt ends supplies the next reference, followed by the normal opening procedure. Otherwise use the preceding five-minute eligible-trade mean. A prior close or last sale used to select the parameter category is a different reference function

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Closing doubling includes all Tier 1 and Tier 2 at or below $3; there is no opening doubling.
  • An unresolved 15-second Limit State leads to a pause; five minutes is ordinarily the first reopening attempt, not guaranteed resumption.
  • The primary listing market conducts its ordinary reopening auction; systems-failure and late-day branches differ.

Trading Halts

Halt authority depends on the security and the reason:

  • Listed NMS stocks: FINRA halts off-exchange trading when the primary listing market declares a Regulatory Halt. That halt starts at the primary market's declaration despite a notice-dissemination problem. Unless the market-wide rule specifies otherwise, resumption follows the primary market's termination notice or the specified securities-information-processor resume time, with applicable band conditions
  • Systems-related extraordinary activity: FINRA also halts off-exchange trading when severe, continuing market-wide disruption to activity or necessary information is caused by a qualifying system disruption or malfunction. The rule distinguishes FINRA/member systems from exchange/member systems, for which consultation with an exchange trading the security is required. This is not a general discretionary news-pending power
  • OTC foreign regulatory ground: The OTC security, or the security underlying an OTC depositary receipt, must be listed on or registered with the foreign market and halted for public-interest concerns or news pending. A foreign halt solely for a filing deficiency or operational reasons does not qualify. There is no separate general FINRA OTC news-pending category
  • OTC derivative/component ground: The OTC security or depositary-receipt underlying is a derivative or component of a nationally or foreign-listed security, and the relevant exchange or market halts that listed security
  • OTC extraordinary-event ground: FINRA can halt for an extraordinary event materially affecting the relevant OTC market, causing or potentially causing major marketplace disruption, or creating significant settlement and clearance uncertainty
  • OTC foreign/derivative notice: The halt begins with FINRA's appropriate public notice after validated notice of the underlying halt. It may continue until FINRA receives notice that the relevant authority has resumed or intends to resume trading
  • OTC extraordinary-event duration: The halt may end when its basis ends or after ten business days. FINRA may extend it in further periods of up to ten business days while the ongoing-event and public-interest conditions hold. FINRA disseminates termination notice
  • Market-wide events: FINRA requires off-exchange NMS quoting and trading to stop when a market-wide halt is publicly disseminated. It also halts OTC equity quoting and trading during the corresponding market-wide halt

A facility-only closure is different from a security-wide halt. FINRA may close its Alternative Display Facility or a Trade Reporting Facility when qualifying systems problems prevent proper operation. Quoting or trading through another market is not prohibited by that closure if that other market is not halted. FINRA's own halts and closures commence and end with the applicable FINRA notices.

Members must promptly notify FINRA of inadequately disclosed information about an NMS stock or issuer, or a known regulatory problem relating to the security. News disclosure alone does not authorize resumption.

During a Limit State, permitted within-band executions can still occur. During a LULD pause, no trades may occur, but bids and offers may be displayed. A separate regulatory halt requires its own publication and resumption analysis.


Market-Wide Circuit Breakers (MWCB)

Market-wide circuit breakers use the S&P 500's decline from its prior trading-day closing value, with the percentage, time and frequency conditions below. Intraday gains do not reset that base. Applicable levels are publicly disseminated before 9:30 a.m. ET; the rule does not require calculation the night before.

LevelS&P 500 DropActionTime Restriction
Level 17%Initial 15-minute market-wide halt, once per dayAfter 9:30 a.m. through 3:25 p.m. ET inclusive, or 12:25 p.m. on an early scheduled close
Level 213%Initial 15-minute market-wide halt, once per dayAfter 9:30 a.m. through 3:25 p.m. ET inclusive, or 12:25 p.m. on an early scheduled close
Level 320%Halt for the remainder of the trading dayTriggers any time

Levels 1 and 2 each trigger only once per trading day. Returning to the same 7% decline after a Level 1 halt does not repeat Level 1. The next higher unused percentage threshold is Level 2 at 13%, subject to its time cutoff.

That threshold order does not predict which actual halt occurs next. Level 3 at 20% halts trading for the remainder of the day regardless of earlier halts.

The initial 15-minute period does not guarantee immediate resumption in every stock. Off-exchange trading ordinarily waits for the primary listing market to resume. Nasdaq's reopening display and auction procedures can also extend the wait.

If the primary market has not reopened a security within 15 minutes after the initial 15-minute halt period ends, FINRA may permit off-exchange resumption if at least one other national securities exchange has begun trading it.

The 3:25 p.m. ET cutoff is critical:

  • On a normal closing day, a qualifying unused Level 1 or Level 2 threshold reached at 3:25 p.m. ET can still trigger that level's halt
  • A later decline cannot trigger a new Level 1 or Level 2 halt; separate halt authority remains available
  • On an early scheduled close day, the same cutoff is 12:25 p.m.

Level 3 and other regulatory halt authority remain available after the Level 1/2 cutoff. The cutoff does not guarantee an uninterrupted closing process.

Applying the Late-Day Cutoff

On a normal closing day, the first qualifying 7% decline at 3:25 p.m. ET can still trigger Level 1; the same first decline at 3:30 p.m. cannot. That later 7% decline does not establish a Level 3 threshold or prevent another applicable regulatory halt.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Use the prior trading-day S&P 500 close; Levels 1 and 2 each trigger once daily, subject to their cutoff.
  • Level 3 ends trading for the day; it is not a 15-minute halt.

The Halt-Trading Prohibition

During a current security-wide regulatory halt, with no applicable permitted display procedure, a member or associated person may not directly or indirectly:

  • Effect transactions in the halted security
  • Publish quotations or priced bids and offers
  • Publish unpriced indications of interest, including bid-wanted, offer-wanted and name-only indications, or bids and offers marked as unsolicited customer interest

The restriction reaches the stated transaction and publication conduct. It is not a ban on every customer-service communication, cancellation or internal order instruction. Applicable FINRA and exchange halts are covered. For a market-wide halt, members must stop off-exchange NMS quoting and trading when the halt is publicly disseminated.

A prohibited public quote violates the restriction even without an execution or customer harm. Continued active publication of a pre-halt quote is not excused merely because it was entered earlier.

Reporting an earlier execution is separate from effecting a new transaction. Applicable reporting duties, timeliness, required late designations and facility procedures still govern. The halt rule does not state an express pre-halt-reporting exception or generally prohibit publication of transaction reports. A delayed report is not made timely by a halt.

The Plan's permissions matter. During a LULD pause, bids and offers may be displayed but no trades may occur. FINRA preserves that permission. Other permitted reopening displays have their own market procedures; do not assume that every display is forbidden or that a display authorizes execution. A facility-only closure does not prohibit trading through another market that is not halted.

Security futures have a separate restriction. The transaction and quotation/indication-publication prohibition also applies to a single-security future while its underlying security has a current regulatory halt. For a narrow-based securities-index future, the trigger is current regulatory halts in one or more underlying securities constituting 50% or more of the index's market capitalization, not half the constituent count. Do not import the stock paragraph's Plan permission into this separate futures provision.

A stub quote without genuine trading interest is improper even when no halt is in effect: published bids and offers must be bona fide. Calling a remote bid "non-actionable" does not excuse it. A halt adds a separate restriction on quoting; it is not what makes a non-bona-fide stub improper. Permitted reopening procedures do not authorize fictitious quotes.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Regulatory-halt restrictions cover transactions and publication, subject to permitted procedures; an earlier execution report is governed separately.
  • A LULD pause permits displayed bids and offers but bars executions. Notice rules depend on the halt type.

How LULD, MWCB, and Halts Connect

The three mechanisms work in layers:

ScopeMechanismSource
Single security (intraday volatility)LULD pause after an unresolved 15-second Limit State, or qualifying discretionary Straddle StateRegular-hours LULD Plan
Single security (news, regulatory)Applicable regulatory halt, notice and resumption conditionsListing-market and FINRA halt rules
Whole market (qualifying S&P 500 decline)MWCB Level 1, 2, or 3, with time and frequency conditionsExchange market-wide rules and FINRA's off-exchange requirements
Regulatory and market-wide haltsTransaction and publication restrictions, subject to applicable permitted proceduresFINRA and exchange halt requirements
LULD trading pauseNo trades; bids and offers may still be displayedReg NMS Plan, carved out of the halt rule

A principal's supervisory controls should:

  • Monitor LULD pauses on the firm's positions (especially market-making books)
  • Prevent prohibited executions and publications by the firm's desks when applicable halts take effect
  • Distinguish security-wide halts, permitted reopening displays and facility-only closures
  • Support review and documentation of the response under the firm's supervisory procedures; the halt rule does not prescribe a special record of every individual step

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • LULD addresses individual stocks; market-wide circuit breakers operate across the market.
  • Distinguish security-wide halts, facility closures and permitted displays before applying restrictions.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you apply both noncrossing Limit State conditions and the complete 15-second quotation-clearance test, and distinguish a five-minute first reopening attempt from actual resumption?
  • Can you select a parameter using the prior primary-market close or its last-sale fallback, apply leverage where required, and double the applicable parameter for all Tier 1 and Tier 2 at or below $3 during the final 25 minutes?
  • Can you state the three MWCB thresholds, 7%, 13%, 20%, and apply the inclusive 3:25 p.m. ET cutoff or 12:25 p.m. early-close cutoff for Levels 1 and 2 without assuming uninterrupted trading afterward?
  • Do you know that Levels 1 and 2 trigger only once per day, while Level 3 halts trading for the rest of the day?
  • Can you distinguish transaction and publication restrictions from earlier-execution reporting, permitted LULD display, facility-only closures and valid resumption conditions?