Quick Answer
FINRA's best-execution rule requires reasonable diligence; absent order-by-order review, firms need a quarterly review by security and order type. Regulation NMS requires monthly execution-quality reports (market centers and larger broker-dealers) and quarterly order-routing reports, requires policies to prevent trade-throughs of protected national best bid and offer (NBBO) quotations, and sets a $0.01 increment at or above
Quick Answer: FINRA's best-execution rule requires reasonable diligence; absent order-by-order review, firms need a quarterly review by security and order type. Regulation NMS requires monthly execution-quality reports (market centers and larger broker-dealers) and quarterly order-routing reports, requires policies to prevent trade-throughs of protected national best bid and offer (NBBO) quotations, and sets a $0.01 increment at or above $1.00.
.00.A broker-dealer routing customer orders has two parallel duties: a fiduciary-style best-execution duty under FINRA's best-execution rule, and a regulatory duty under Regulation NMS (national market system) to respect protected quotations and disclose routing practices. The Series 24 supervisor sits between a firm's order-routing logic and the regulatory framework that constrains it.
Execution Venues
A broker-dealer may route a customer order to one of several venue types:
| Venue | Description |
|---|---|
| National Securities Exchange | A registered exchange (NYSE, Nasdaq, Cboe BZX, etc.): operates under SEC oversight as a self-regulatory organization (SRO) |
| Alternative Trading System (ATS) | An electronic system that matches orders but is not a registered exchange (governed by SEC Regulation ATS); includes dark pools and electronic communications networks (ECNs) |
| Alternative Display Facility (ADF) | A FINRA quotation and trade-reporting facility for NMS stocks: it displays quotes and reports trades, but has no matching engine of its own |
| OTC Market | OTC Markets Group tiers (OTCQX, OTCQB, Pink, Expert) for non-exchange OTC equities: a quotation marketplace where broker-dealers quote, then execute trades with each other and report them to FINRA |
| Internal Crossing | The member's own ATS or principal book |
The principal supervising routing decisions must be able to justify why orders are routed to one venue over another, both for individual orders and on a systematic basis.
On the Nasdaq Book, resting orders meet incoming orders under a price/display/time sequence: the better price executes first; at the same price, displayed orders rank ahead of non-displayed orders (including the hidden reserve portion of an order), and each group fills in time order.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The Alternative Display Facility displays quotes and reports trades; it does not match or execute them.
The FINRA Best-Execution Rule
A member must use reasonable diligence to ascertain the best market for a security and execute the customer order at a price as favorable as possible under prevailing market conditions.
The factors in best-execution analysis:
- Character of the market: price, volatility, liquidity, communications/data quality
- Size and type of transaction: market order vs. limit, large block vs. retail size
- Number of markets checked
- Accessibility of quotations at competing venues
- Terms and conditions of the customer order itself
Regular and Rigorous Review
If a firm does not review every order individually for best execution, it must conduct a regular and rigorous review of execution quality:
| Element | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Frequency | At least quarterly |
| Granularity | Security-by-security AND type-of-order (market, limit, market-on-open, etc.) |
| Comparison | Compare the firm's executions against competing markets |
| Action | Modify routing if material differences are found, OR document the rationale for not modifying |
A firm that finds a venue is providing materially worse executions than a competing venue and continues routing without explanation has failed the rule.
Think of it this way: The regular-and-rigorous review is best-execution-by-statistics. Instead of evaluating every customer order one by one, the firm samples enough executions to identify patterns. If Venue A is consistently worse than Venue B for limit orders in mid-cap stocks, the firm must either reroute or document why the choice is justified on customer execution factors. If no legitimate customer-centered justification supports retaining A, the firm must change routing. Rebates that fund zero commissions do not justify inferior execution.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Absent order-by-order review, regular and rigorous review is at least quarterly by security and order type.
- Change routing or document the customer-centered rationale for retaining it after finding material differences.
Interpositioning
A firm may NOT interpose a third party between itself and the best market unless doing so demonstrably benefits the customer (lower price, better fill, or some other quantifiable advantage).
The classic interpositioning violation: a firm routes a customer order through an affiliate broker that adds a markup, with no improvement in execution quality. The customer pays more without receiving anything in return.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Interpositioning must demonstrably benefit the customer; an affiliate markup without execution benefit is insufficient.
Regulation NMS: The Core Components
| Component | Substance |
|---|---|
| NMS security definitions | Defines an NMS security (exchange-listed equity or option), protected quotation, trading center, and other key terms |
| Dissemination of quotations | Exchanges and OTC market makers must furnish quotations to a securities information processor (SIP) so the public market data feed reflects all displayed quotes |
| Display of customer limit orders | A market maker must immediately display a customer limit order priced better than its own quote. An order priced equal to its quote and to the national best bid or offer must be displayed when it adds more than a de minimis amount to the quoted size |
| Execution-quality reports | Every market center, and since August 1, 2026 any broker-dealer that introduces or carries 100,000 or more customer accounts, must publish monthly execution-quality reports on covered orders during the applicable Reporting Period, within one month after month-end |
| Order-routing reports | Broker-dealers must publish quarterly routing reports on non-directed orders. The report names the ten most-used venues and any venue taking 5% or more of those orders. For each, it states the net payment for order flow received (total dollars and per share) and describes the terms of the arrangement |
| Order Protection Rule (Trade-Through Rule) | Trading centers must establish written policies to prevent trade-throughs of protected quotations displayed by automated trading centers at the NBBO |
| Sub-Penny Rule | Under the currently operative standard, quotations in NMS stocks priced at $1.00 or more use $0.01 increments; below $1.00, $0.0001 increments. Apply a separate exemption only when its conditions are stated |
Displaying Customer Limit Orders
A market maker holding a customer limit order must publish immediately a bid or offer that reflects:
- The price and full size of an order that would improve its own bid or offer
- The full size of an order priced equal to its own bid or offer and to the national best bid or offer, when the order is more than a de minimis change in its quoted size
The SEC reads "immediately" as soon as practicable after receipt, which under normal market conditions means no later than 30 seconds. NASD guidance issued after consulting SEC staff calls the 30 seconds an outer limit, not a safe harbor: a firm may not build a routine delay into its order handling, and a display inside 30 seconds can still be too slow.
The display duty does not apply to a customer limit order that is:
| Exception | Detail |
|---|---|
| Executed on receipt | Filled as soon as it arrives |
| Customer opts out | The customer expressly asks, when placing the order or under an individually negotiated agreement, that it not be displayed |
| Odd lot | Smaller than a round lot |
| Block size | At least 10,000 shares or $200,000 in market value, unless the customer asks for display |
| Delivered immediately | Sent on receipt to an exchange, an association-sponsored system, a qualifying electronic communications network, or another exchange member or market maker that complies with the rule |
| All or none | Marked "all or none" |
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Thirty seconds is an outer limit under normal conditions, not a routine waiting period.
- A block-size order must be displayed if the customer requests it.
Execution-Quality vs. Order-Routing Reports: Who Owes What
This is one of the most-tested distinctions on the Series 24:
| Report | Filer | Frequency | Content |
|---|---|---|---|
| Execution-quality report | Market center (the venue), plus a broker-dealer with 100,000 or more customer accounts, during its applicable Reporting Period | Monthly | Detailed and summary execution-quality statistics on covered orders |
| Order-routing report | Broker-dealer (the order router) | Quarterly | Routing destinations + venue-level payment-for-order-flow amounts and arrangement terms |
The SEC's 2024 amendments to the execution-quality rule took effect for compliance on August 1, 2026. Before then only market centers reported. Now a broker-dealer that is not a market center must publish monthly reports when it introduces or carries 100,000 or more qualifying customer accounts and enters its applicable Reporting Period.
For the first threshold crossing, that period begins on the first calendar day four calendar months later; a later crossing starts it on the first day of the next month. Reporting continues for at least three calendar months. Qualifying accounts are those through which NMS-stock trades are effected.
A small introducing firm that only routes orders still owes the quarterly routing report but not the execution-quality report. The quarterly report has no size, revenue, or order-count exemption. Only the SEC can excuse a firm, by an exemptive order on that firm's application.
The volume tests for relief from a customer-requested not-held order report are 5% of customer shares in not-held orders and $1,000,000 of monthly notional value per customer. They do not excuse the public quarterly report.
A principal supervising routing decisions uses the firm's own routing report. A principal evaluating execution venue performance uses the venues' execution-quality reports.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Execution-quality reports are monthly; market centers and qualifying large broker-dealers owe them in the applicable reporting period.
- Order-routing reports are quarterly and include venue-level payment amounts and arrangement terms.
- The not-held request thresholds do not excuse a small firm from public quarterly reporting.
The Order Protection Rule
During regular trading hours, a trading center may not execute a trade at a price worse than a protected quotation at another center. A "protected quotation" is the top-of-book best bid or offer at an automated trading center.
Two key qualifiers:
- Top-of-book only: depth-of-book quotations are not protected
- Automated only: manual quotations (legacy specialist quotes that require human action to access) are NOT protected
The rule also has a time limit. Reg NMS defines a trade-through as a purchase or sale of an NMS stock during regular trading hours (9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Eastern Time) at a price lower than a protected bid or higher than a protected offer.
A pre-market or after-hours execution at a worse price is therefore not a trade-through. FINRA's best-execution duty to the customer still applies.
A trade-through of a manual quote is permitted under the Order Protection Rule. A trade-through of an automated top-of-book quote is prohibited unless an exception applies (Intermarket Sweep Order, ISO, being the most common).
The rule also sets a separate supervisory duty. A trading center must keep written policies reasonably designed to prevent trade-throughs, and it must regularly surveil whether those policies work and fix any gap promptly.
Whether a trade was a trade-through is one question. Whether the policies were reasonably designed and operating is another. A trade-through remains a trade-through, but its occurrence alone does not establish a violation of the policy-based rule. Assess exceptions and the design, maintenance, enforcement and surveillance of the policies.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Protected quotations are automated and top-of-book; the benchmark is the national best bid or offer.
- A trade-through occurs during regular trading hours; best-execution duties still apply outside them.
The Sub-Penny Rule
| Stock Price | Minimum Pricing Increment |
|---|---|
| $1.00 or more, under the currently operative standard | $0.01 (one penny) |
| Below $1.00 | $0.0001 (one hundredth of a cent) |
The adopted half-penny amendment has a deferred general compliance date; do not treat it as the currently operative standard. Separately granted exemptions require their own facts. The standard rule prohibits sub-penny quotations and orders at or above $1.00, such as bidding $10.0001 ahead of $10.00. This quotation restriction does not prohibit an execution that provides sub-penny price improvement.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The $1 threshold concerns stock price, not order size.
- A prohibited sub-penny quote is separate from trading ahead under Manning.
Locked and Crossed Quotations
A "locked" quotation occurs when the bid equals the offer (e.g., bid $10.00 / offer $10.00). A "crossed" quotation occurs when the bid is higher than the offer (bid $10.05 / offer $10.00). Both indicate market dysfunction: a locked or crossed quote is theoretically executable on its face but no execution is occurring.
Trading centers must have written policies to avoid displaying locking or crossing quotes, and market makers must promptly remove their quotes if they lock or cross another market.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Locked means bid equals offer; crossed means bid exceeds offer. The market maker creating the condition must promptly remove its quote.
How the Pieces Fit Together
A best-execution and routing analysis under Series 24 has two layers:
- The FINRA best-execution rule (the firm's duty to its customer): use reasonable diligence, conduct regular and rigorous review, do not interpose third parties without benefit
- SEC Reg NMS (the regulatory floor for the national market system): respect protected quotations under the Order Protection Rule, file order-routing reports, comply with sub-penny minimum increments, support display of customer limit orders
A firm that satisfies Reg NMS but fails the best-execution rule has still violated FINRA's best-execution standard. Best execution does not resolve the separate order-protection duty. Before concluding a violation, assess applicable exceptions and policy design, enforcement and surveillance. The supervisor must enforce both duties.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Regulation NMS and FINRA best execution are separate duties; compliance with one does not satisfy the other.
- Document the supervisory review of routing data.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you state how often a regular and rigorous best-execution review must occur, and at what granularity: security and order type?
- Do you know which report is monthly, execution-quality, owed by market centers and broker-dealers with 100,000 or more customer accounts, versus quarterly, order-routing, owed by the broker-dealer?
- Can you state that the Order Protection Rule protects only automated, top-of-book quotations, not manual or depth-of-book quotes, and applies only during regular trading hours?
- Do you know the sub-penny rule's minimum increments: $0.01 for stocks at or above $1.00, $0.0001 below $1.00?