Regulation SHO: Short-Sale Compliance

Quick Answer

Regulation SHO governs sell-order marking, locates, short-sale price tests, and fail close-outs. Ordinary short fails close out by the next settlement day's trading open after settlement; documented long and bona fide market-making fails get the third settlement day. A 10% decline activates the short-sale price test. Exceptions and missed-close-out pre-borrow requirements must be assessed separately.

A short sale is a sale of stock the seller does not own; the seller may borrow the stock for delivery and hopes to buy it back later at a lower price.

Delivery is due at settlement, but a stock loan is not inevitable if purchases to cover or other available shares provide delivery. Reg SHO is the SEC's framework for preventing fails to deliver and abusive short selling that can manipulate price or undermine settlement.

The supervisor's duty under Reg SHO is to ensure:

  • Every order is correctly marked
  • Every short has a documented locate
  • Every fail is closed out on time
  • The alternative uptick rule is enforced when triggered

Definition and Order Marking

A "short sale" under Reg SHO is any sale of a security that the seller:

  • Does not own, OR
  • Owns but consummates by delivering a borrowed security

Every sell order must be marked at the time of entry:

MarkingWhen to Use
LongSeller owns the security and will deliver from owned shares
ShortSeller does not own or will deliver borrowed shares
Short exemptSale is short but qualifies for an exception to the alternative uptick rule

Net positions are determined firm-wide by default, or by unit when the firm elects and meets the independent-aggregation conditions. That election does not remove the other ownership and delivery conditions for long marking.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Independent-unit netting requires all four conditions; simply naming desks is insufficient.
  • Short exempt concerns the price test, not an exemption from Regulation SHO generally.

The Locate Requirement

Before a broker-dealer accepts a short-sale order in any equity security, the firm must locate the security to be borrowed. The firm must have one of:

  • Borrowed the security
  • Entered into a bona fide arrangement to borrow the security
  • Reasonable grounds to believe the security can be borrowed and delivered by the settlement date

The locate must be documented before order acceptance. A firm cannot accept the short, then look for a locate, then back-fill paperwork.

Bona Fide Market-Maker Exception

A registered market maker engaged in bona fide market-making activities is exempt from the locate requirement. The exception exists because a market maker often shorts as part of providing liquidity; requiring a locate before every market-maker short would impede the function.

Think of it this way: The locate requirement is the broker-dealer's documented basis for timely borrowing and delivery, rather than a requirement that a stock loan inevitably occur. The promise must be in place at order entry; it cannot be retroactive. The market-maker exception trades a locate-by-locate check for an overall presumption that bona fide market making does not contribute to fails.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Document the locate before acceptance; a later successful locate cannot cure an untimely one.
  • The market-maker exception requires bona fide market making, not directional proprietary trading.

The Close-Out Requirement

If a short sale results in a fail to deliver (the seller's broker cannot deliver the shares to the buyer's broker by settlement), the clearing-agency participant must close out the fail by purchasing or borrowing securities of like kind and quantity.

The close-out timing depends on the type of fail:

Type of FailClose-Out Deadline
Ordinary short-sale failBy regular-trading open on the next settlement day after settlement date
Documented ordinary long-sale failBy regular-trading open on the third consecutive settlement day after settlement date
Bona fide market-making failBy regular-trading open on the third consecutive settlement day after settlement date
Deemed-to-own sale fail (the seller is deemed to own the shares, such as restricted stock, and intends to deliver once delivery restrictions are removed)By regular-trading open on the 35th consecutive calendar day after trade date, and only by purchasing; borrowing does not satisfy this deadline

The first three clocks begin at settlement, not trade date. Under ordinary T+1 settlement, the first deadline generally corresponds to T+2 and the third-day deadline to T+4. The deemed-to-own clock is the exception: it counts calendar days from trade date.

The locate rule carries a matching exception for the same sale. No locate is needed if the broker-dealer has been reasonably informed that the seller intends to deliver as soon as all restrictions on delivery are removed. If the seller still has not delivered 35 days after the trade date, the broker-dealer that effected the sale must borrow the shares or close out the position by purchasing.

After a missed close-out, the restriction reaches the participant and brokers submitting shorts to it for clearing, subject to allocation and exceptions. Covered short orders require a borrow or bona fide arrangement to borrow until the close-out purchase clears and settles. There is no additional undefined clean period, and the restriction is not automatically market-wide.

Threshold Securities

A threshold security is an equity security of a qualifying registered or reporting issuer with aggregate clearing-agency fails of at least 10,000 shares and 0.5% of shares outstanding for five consecutive settlement days, included on the applicable self-regulatory organization's list. Threshold status and the duration of a participant's fail have separate roles; listing alone is not a universal immediate pre-borrow trigger.

What the threshold rule adds is a backstop keyed to the participant's own fail:

  • Trigger: the participant has a fail to deliver in a threshold security for 13 consecutive settlement days. The count is how long the fail has lasted, not how long the security has been on the list
  • Close-out: the participant must immediately close the fail out by purchasing securities of like kind and quantity
  • Pre-borrow: until it does, the participant and the brokers it clears for may not accept or effect a short sale in that security without first borrowing it or arranging to borrow it

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Most deadlines run from settlement; the deemed-to-own deadline runs 35 calendar days from trade and requires a purchase.
  • The 13-settlement-day threshold count measures the participant’s fail, not time on the list.
  • A missed close-out triggers scoped pre-borrow requirements until the covering purchase clears and settles.

The Alternative Uptick Rule (Circuit Breaker)

The "alternative uptick rule" is a short-sale price test that triggers only when a covered security has experienced a sharp intraday decline:

  • Trigger: the security drops 10% or more from the prior day's closing price (intraday decline)
  • Effect: new nonexempt short orders may not execute or initially display at a price at or below the current National Best Bid (NBB). A displayed short order initially priced above the then-current bid may later execute even if the bid moves to or above its price.
  • Remains in effect for the rest of the trigger day plus the following trading day

While the test is active, a new nonexempt short order must be priced above the current national best bid. The previously displayed-order exception permits later execution of an order initially displayed above the then-current bid; it does not permit initial display at or below that bid.

An execution can occur between the bid and offer; taking the offer or waiting for a last-sale uptick is not required. Bona fide market making alone does not supply a price-test exception.

The exam tests "short exempt" markings here: a sale that is short under Reg SHO but qualifies for an exception to the alternative uptick rule is marked short exempt so the price test does not apply. The listed grounds are narrow:

  • The broker-dealer identifies the order as priced above the current NBB when it submits it
  • The seller is deemed to own the shares and will deliver once delivery restrictions are removed
  • A market maker offsets customer odd-lot orders or liquidates an odd-lot position, changing its position by no more than one unit of trading
  • Qualifying convertible-security or international arbitrage
  • An underwriter's or syndicate member's over-allotment or lay-off sale
  • A riskless principal sale that executes a customer purchase or a customer long sale
  • A qualifying sale at the volume-weighted average price (VWAP)

A market maker shorting at the NBB to provide liquidity fits none of them.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The 10% decline is measured from the prior close; the test lasts through the next trading day.
  • The current best bid governs initial display and execution, subject to the previously displayed-order exception.
  • A locate exception is not automatically a price-test exception.

Putting Locate and Close-Out Together

Reg SHO operates in a sequence:

StageRequirementAction
Before order entryLocateDocument a locate (or qualify for the market-maker exception)
At order entryMarkingApply ownership, delivery, and the appropriate firm or qualifying-unit net position
At order entry (if 10% trigger active)Alternative uptick rulePrice short above the NBB or mark short exempt if eligible
After settlement-date failClose-outApply the deadline measured from settlement date for the documented fail category
After missed close-outPre-borrowApply to covered short orders until the close-out purchase clears and settles

Think of it this way: The exam loves to walk through a fact pattern and ask which requirement was violated at each step. Locate fails happen at order entry; price-test fails happen during the day on a trigger; close-out fails happen at clearing. The supervisor must catch breakdowns at each stage.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Locate precedes acceptance; close-out follows a settlement-date fail.
  • A missed close-out requires borrowing or a bona fide arrangement, not merely reasonable grounds to believe shares are available.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Do you know a locate must be documented before order entry, not before settlement, and who is exempt under the market-maker exception?
  • Can you calculate the next- and third-settlement-day close-out deadlines from settlement date?
  • Do you know the threshold security definition: fails of 5 or more consecutive days totaling 10,000 shares and 0.5% of shares outstanding?
  • Can you state when the alternative uptick rule triggers, a 10% intraday decline, and how long it remains in effect?