Quick Answer
Penny-stock status depends on the definition's exclusions, not price alone. Covered transactions require risk, quotation, and compensation disclosures, account statements, and sales-practice steps. Required documents and two-business-day waiting periods precede execution. Established-customer status exempts the sales-practice steps only; it does not independently waive Schedule 15G or the separate disclosure rules.
Use the reporting facility appropriate to the security and transaction. Penny-stock status alone does not select a single facility. Penny stocks also raise books-and-records and customer-disclosure obligations. The firm must maintain a supervisory system and enforce written procedures reasonably designed to achieve compliance with each applicable requirement.
Penny Stock Definition
A "penny stock" is generally an equity security that is NOT:
- Within a qualifying exchange/national market system (NMS) exclusion under the penny-stock definition, OR
- Priced $5 or more under the rule's price calculation, excluding commissions and other remuneration, OR
- Issued by a registered investment company, OR
- A put or call option issued by the Options Clearing Corporation, OR
- A security futures product listed on a national securities exchange or an association-sponsored automated quotation system, OR
- Issued by an issuer with net tangible assets > $2 million (in continuous operation 3+ years) or > $5 million (in operation less than 3 years), OR
- Issued by an issuer with average revenue ≥ $6 million for the last 3 years
Most low-priced (under $5) over-the-counter (OTC) equities meet the definition.
For issuer-size exclusions, use the financial statements prescribed for the issuer's status, meeting the required currency and audit/reporting conditions. The broker-dealer must review them, have a reasonable basis for believing they are accurate in relation to the transaction date, and preserve copies. Continuous operating history, rather than incorporation age alone, determines which net-tangible-asset threshold applies.
| Test | Threshold for NOT Being a Penny Stock |
|---|---|
| Price | $5 or more under the rule's applicable calculation; the exclusion is not limited to NMS stocks |
| Listing | Meets the rule's qualifying exchange/NMS criteria |
| Instrument | A registered investment company's security, an Options Clearing Corporation put or call, or a listed security futures product |
| Issuer net tangible assets | > $2 million (3+ years in continuous operation) or > $5 million (less than 3 years) |
| Issuer average revenue | ≥ $6 million over the last 3 years |
A security that fails all of these tests is a penny stock and is subject to the penny-stock disclosure regime.
Penny stock is a regulatory category. A $7 OTC equity can satisfy the price exclusion even if its issuer is small. A sub-$5 security can qualify for another exclusion. Apply the actual listing, price, issuer, and instrument criteria rather than a single label.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The exclusions are independent alternatives; check the conditions for the relevant listing, price, instrument or issuer test.
Exempt Transactions
Distinguish a security excluded from the penny-stock definition from a transaction exempt under a particular rule. The disclosure exemptions cover specified transactions, including qualifying institutional-accredited and unrecommended transactions. Established-customer status is a separate sales-practice exemption, not a general disclosure exemption.
An "established customer" has an account carried by the broker-dealer or a clearing broker on its behalf and, in that account, satisfies either:
- An account through which the customer effected a securities transaction or deposited funds or securities more than one year earlier, OR
- Three different prior penny-stock buys on three different days from at least three different issuers
The first established-customer route does not require penny-stock activity. A qualifying mutual-fund purchase or account deposit more than one year earlier can suffice. Institutional-sale exemptions concern the transaction or purchaser; they do not redefine the security itself.
Supervisory procedures should verify the actual conditions and scope of relief. If firm policy requires contemporaneous supporting evidence, enforce that policy. The established-customer definition does not itself prescribe a universal exemption-record form or creation time. Apply separate express record duties where relevant, including preservation of the financial statements supporting issuer-size exclusions.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Account age alone is insufficient; the qualifying transaction or deposit need not involve penny stock.
- Established-customer status covers sales-practice steps, not the separate risk, quotation, compensation or statement duties.
Disclosure Document: Schedule 15G
Before a non-exempt penny stock transaction, the broker-dealer must deliver Schedule 15G: the standardized risk disclosure document describing penny-stock market risks. The firm must:
- Obtain the customer's signed and dated acknowledgment of receipt before the transaction
- Retain the signed and dated acknowledgment at least three years, first two easily accessible.
- Not effect the covered transaction less than two business days after sending the disclosure document, however the customer acknowledges it
| Requirement | What It Requires |
|---|---|
| Pre-transaction delivery | Delivery of Schedule 15G before the first non-exempt penny stock transaction |
| Signed acknowledgment | In the firm's hands before the transaction, not collected afterward |
| Waiting period | At least two business days between the firm sending Schedule 15G and the transaction |
| Schedule 15G content | The standardized risk disclosure form |
Preserve Schedule 15G's prescribed presentation. Its delivery communication must include broker contact information and may include acknowledgment instructions and routine email privacy or confidentiality text. No other information may be added to that communication, including transaction quotations or compensation. A paper copy must be reproduced exactly as presented, so a stamp or note such as "Read carefully" is added information, and a customer's signature does not cure it.
Other compatible disclosures may share a document when each requirement is met; this does not make every disclosure a separate physical form.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Send Schedule 15G at least two business days before the covered transaction and obtain the signed, dated acknowledgment before execution.
- Delivery, acknowledgment, waiting and retention are separate requirements.
Quotation, Compensation, and Statement Disclosures
A second set of disclosures applies to specific dimensions of the transaction:
| Disclosure | What Is Disclosed |
|---|---|
| Inside-quote disclosure | Qualifying inside bid and offer and applicable quantities; for agency transactions without qualifying inside quotations, the best independent interdealer bid and offer obtained through reasonable diligence, with quantities. Disclose orally or in writing before the transaction, and in writing at or before confirmation. When the firm makes the pre-trade disclosure, it must also make and preserve a record of that disclosure |
| Firm-compensation disclosure | Required aggregate broker-dealer compensation orally or in writing before the transaction, and in writing at or before confirmation |
| Associated-person compensation disclosure | Aggregate transaction cash compensation determined by execution, received or to be received from any source by a natural-person associated person communicating about the transaction by order receipt, excluding solely clerical or ministerial functions; separately identify outside-payer sources and amounts |
| Account statement | Required estimated market value or the statement "no estimated market value" under the prescribed methods; ordinarily monthly, subject to specific exceptions |
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Pre-trade quotation disclosure may be oral, but the firm must make and preserve a record when it discloses it.
- Firm and covered associated-person compensation are independent disclosures.
- Statement deadlines and exceptions depend on the applicable conditions, not established status alone.
Give or send statements within ten days after covered month-ends, subject to the applicable exceptions. After six consecutive calendar months without penny-stock transactions, send required statements within ten days after each immediately subsequent quarterly period while inactivity continues.
A separate price-history exception can suspend monthly statements when the security was at least $5 on all but five or fewer trading days of a quarterly period; it lasts for subsequent quarters until one ends with the security below $5.
If associated-person compensation will be determined later by sales volume or another contingency, the written disclosure must state that fact and describe the basis.
For the agency quotation fallback, obtaining quotations from three market makers, or all known market makers if fewer than three, satisfies the specified reasonable-diligence route. Absence of qualifying inside quotations alone does not permit replacing that inquiry with a 'no quotations available' notice.
Sales Practice Requirement
For non-exempt purchases, the broker-dealer must:
- Approve the account after collecting finances, investment experience, and objectives and making the required suitability and capability determinations.
- Deliver the firm's written suitability-basis statement with prescribed highlighted notices and obtain the customer's signed and dated copy.
- Receive the customer's written agreement specifying the identity and quantity of the penny stock to be purchased before executing the trade
| Step | What It Requires |
|---|---|
| Account approval | Required broker-dealer determination and approval; follow the firm's designated supervisory approval procedures |
| Suitability statement | Firm's written basis and prescribed notices, signed and dated by the customer |
| Written agreement | Transaction-specific customer agreement coverage specifying identity and quantity of the penny stock |
The written agreement identifies the security and quantity for the covered transaction; a generic account authorization is insufficient. The sales-practice rule also requires two business days after sending the transaction agreement and suitability statement before the transaction. Apply each relevant waiting period along with the separate Schedule 15G requirement.
The suitability-basis statement expressly requires the customer's signed and dated copy; do not transfer that wording to every transaction agreement.
Think of it this way: The penny-stock sales-practice regime is a deliberate friction layer. Each step adds documentation and the chance for the customer (or the principal) to think twice. Penny stocks are dangerous enough that the SEC built the friction in by design.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Each covered purchase needs agreement identifying the security and quantity; one instrument can cover multiple properly identified transactions.
- Firm approval and supervisory review follow applicable requirements and firm procedures; individual principal verification of every step is not universally required.
How the Penny-Stock Regime Stacks for a Single Trade
A new customer's first non-exempt penny-stock buy requires several controls. The firm must complete the suitability-document steps as part of account approval and satisfy every applicable pre-trade requirement before execution. The following checklist groups the controls; it does not prescribe an order among independent pre-trade duties.
| Control | Action |
|---|---|
| Account approval | Obtain required customer information and make the required determinations; deliver the suitability-basis statement and receive its signed and dated copy as part of approval |
| Risk disclosure | Send Schedule 15G to start its two-business-day wait; deliver it and obtain the signed and dated acknowledgment before execution, then retain the acknowledgment |
| Quotation disclosure | Disclose qualifying inside bid/offer and quantities, or the applicable agency or principal fallback |
| Transaction agreement | Receive customer agreement specifying identity and quantity for the covered purchase; observe the sending-based wait |
| Compensation disclosure | Disclose firm and covered associated-person compensation |
| Trade execution | Verify all required documents, disclosures, and two-business-day waiting periods; execute and report through the proper facility |
| Account statements | Ongoing and after the trade, not a pre-trade item: apply required statement timing and the prescribed estimated-value methods |
A breakdown can leave an independently required control unsatisfied. A checklist's missing-step count does not automatically establish a formal regulatory charge count or one charge per step. The principal must ensure the written supervisory procedures address the applicable controls and that supervisors can produce evidence of compliance on regulatory request.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Count missing controls separately from formal charges.
- Established-customer relief covers sales practices, not the separate disclosures and statements.
For every covered holding, report identity and quantity. Estimate value by multiplying the highest qualifying inside bid on the last trading day of the statement period by the quantity held. Without an inside bid, use the weighted average price of all qualifying purchases in the last five trading days, multiplied by the quantity held, if the firm made at least ten separate qualifying purchases during that period.
Qualifying purchases are bona fide own-account purchases of at least 100 shares, excluding blocks exceeding one percent of outstanding shares or units. If neither method applies, state no estimated market value rather than leaving a blank or using acquisition cost. Include the prescribed conspicuous pricing-reliability legend; lack of an estimate does not mean worthlessness.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you state the price threshold and issuer-size tests that determine whether a security is a penny stock?
- Do you know the two alternative established-customer tests in an account carried by or on behalf of the broker-dealer, and that the exemption covers special sales practices only?
- Can you state when Schedule 15G must be delivered, and confirm it is before, not at, the transaction, with a signed acknowledgment and two business days since sending?
- Can you verify written identity-and-quantity agreement coverage for each covered purchase, timely receipt, and the sending-based wait without assuming one physical form per trade?