IA Compensation Restrictions

Broker-dealer compensation is priced per trade or per service. Investment adviser compensation raises a different concern: a fee tied to the client's investment gains can push the adviser toward outsized risk to inflate its own pay. The Uniform Securities Act addresses that specific incentive directly.

What Does the Performance-Fee Prohibition Require?

• Except as the Administrator permits by rule or order, it is unlawful for an investment adviser to enter into, extend, or renew an advisory contract unless the contract provides in writing that the adviser shall not be compensated on the basis of a share of capital gains upon, or capital appreciation of, the client's funds
• The word is "shall," not "may": the contract must contain this provision, it is not optional language
• The purpose is to prevent an adviser from sharing in client profits in a way that could reward excessive risk-taking

Exam Tip: Gotchas

The prohibition targets performance-based compensation tied to capital gains or appreciation, not fee amount generally. A larger fee is not automatically a violation; the trigger is whether the fee formula is pegged to the client's investment gains.

What Fee Structures Can an IA Charge Instead?

An AUM fee is not a performance fee even though it rises when the account grows. The prohibited structure is compensation tied to gains or appreciation, not compensation tied to total value.

What Is the Fulcrum Fee Exception?

• The performance-fee prohibition does not apply to an advisory contract that provides for compensation based on the total value of a fund averaged over a definite period, or as of definite dates
• This permits so-called "fulcrum fee" arrangements: the adviser's fee moves up or down with the fund's total value over that period, instead of being pegged one-way to gains
• The exception itself does not require measuring the fee against an external benchmark, only that it be based on total value averaged over time or as of definite dates
• Either way, a fee that can move in both directions with total value is not the same as a one-way performance fee that only ever rewards gains

Exam Tip: Gotchas

If a fee structure only ever pays the adviser more when the account goes up and never adjusts down when it declines, that one-way behavior is the signature of a prohibited performance fee, not the total-value exception.

When Can an IA Charge a True Performance Fee?

• The Administrator may, by rule or order, adopt exemptions from the performance-fee prohibition
• NASAA's model exemption rule permits a performance-fee contract in either of two situations:
  • The adviser is not registered and not required to register under the Act's registration provisions, or
  • The client is a qualified client and the adviser gives the required written disclosure
• Under federal law and SEC rules, a "qualified client" is generally:
  • A client with at least $1,400,000 in assets under management with the adviser, or
  • A client with a net worth of at least $2,700,000 (excluding the primary residence)
  • Qualified purchasers under the Investment Company Act, or knowledgeable employees of the adviser
• These dollar thresholds are periodically adjusted for inflation by SEC order
• Meeting the qualified-client threshold is not the only condition for a registered adviser. Unless Form ADV Part 2 already discloses it, the adviser must also give the client written disclosure of material performance-fee information: the risk incentive to take on more speculative investments, how unrealized appreciation is treated alongside realized gains, the measurement period, the comparative index used (if any), and how hard-to-value securities will be valued

Exam Tip: Gotchas

Qualified-client status alone does not clear a registered adviser to charge a performance fee. The adviser still owes the client written disclosure of the performance-fee mechanics unless Form ADV Part 2 already covers it. A question that stops at "the client is a qualified client" without addressing disclosure has not shown a completed exemption. Separately, an adviser that is not registered and not required to register can use this exemption without meeting the qualified-client test at all.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

• An advisory contract must state in writing that the adviser will not be compensated on a share of capital gains or appreciation, unless the Administrator has granted an exemption.
• AUM, hourly, and flat fees are all permitted; none of them is a performance fee, even though an AUM fee rises as the account grows.
• A fulcrum fee is based on the fund's total value averaged over a definite period or as of definite dates, and it can move up and down with that value. It is not the same as a one-way performance fee.
• Qualified clients ($1,400,000 AUM with the adviser, or $2,700,000 net worth excluding primary residence, plus qualified purchasers and knowledgeable employees) may be charged true performance fees, with proper written disclosure.
• An adviser that is not registered and not required to register can also use the performance-fee exemption, without needing a qualified client.