Rights vs. Warrants Comparison
With both rights and warrants covered individually, this section brings them together in the side-by-side comparison the exam loves to test.
The Comparison Table
| Feature | Rights | Warrants |
|---|---|---|
| Duration | Short-term (30-90 days) | Long-term (2-5+ years, sometimes perpetual) |
| Exercise price vs. market | Below market (in the money) | Above market (out of the money) |
| Issued to | Existing shareholders | Purchasers of bonds or preferred stock (sweetener) |
| Purpose | Maintain proportionate ownership | Make another offering more attractive |
| Dilutive? | Anti-dilutive if exercised by existing holders | Dilutive (creates new shares for non-shareholders) |
| Voting rights | None (until exercised) | None (until exercised) |
| Dividends | None (until exercised) | None (until exercised) |
| Transferable | Yes | Yes (if detachable) |
| Source authority | Corporate charter | Stockholder approval |
Key Distinctions to Remember
- Price direction: Rights start in the money (subscription price below market); warrants start out of the money (exercise price above market)
- Who benefits: Rights protect existing shareholders from dilution; warrants benefit new investors who buy bonds or preferred stock
- Time horizon: Rights expire quickly (weeks); warrants persist for years
- Both become common stock upon exercise: neither provides ownership rights until exercised
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- If a question describes an instrument with an exercise price BELOW market and a short expiration, it's a right
- If a question describes an instrument attached to a bond with an exercise price ABOVE market, it's a warrant
- Rights are anti-dilutive for existing holders; warrants are dilutive
Memory Aid:
- Rights = Retain ownership (existing shareholders, below market, short-term)
- Warrants = sWeetener (bond buyers, above market, long-term)
What They Have in Common
Despite their differences, rights and warrants share several features:
- Both give the holder the right (not obligation) to purchase common stock
- Both are transferable and can trade on the secondary market
- Neither grants voting rights or dividends until exercised
- Both result in new shares being issued when exercised
- Both have a fixed exercise/subscription price
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Neither rights nor warrants holders are stockholders until exercise. The same applies to dividends and voting. Both become common stock only upon exercise.