Broker-Dealer Registration

Quick Answer

A broker is an agent effecting trades for others (commission); a dealer is a principal trading its own account (markup). Registration runs three tiers (Securities and Exchange Commission, self-regulatory organization, states), all through one Form BD on the Central Registration Depository. FINRA membership adds a New Member Application, and jurisdiction survives withdrawal for two years.

Review definitions, registration, forms, FINRA membership, sanctions and customer protection.


Broker vs. Dealer and the Registration Trigger

  • Broker = agent effecting securities transactions for the account of others; earns a commission.
  • Dealer = principal buying and selling for its own account; earns a markup or markdown.
  • One firm usually acts as both, registering as a broker-dealer (B/D).
  • Trader exception: trading one's own account not as a regular business (a private investor) is excluded from the dealer definition.
  • Bank exception: banks doing specified activities (trust, custody, networking) are excluded from the broker definition.
  • Trigger: using the mails or interstate commerce to effect securities transactions is unlawful unless registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

Three-Tier Registration and Exemptions

TierAuthorityMechanism
FederalSEC (Securities Exchange Act of 1934)Form BD
Self-regulatory (SRO)FINRA By-LawsForm BD + Form NMA (New Member Application)
StateBlue-sky laws (Uniform Securities Act)Form BD via CRD, state-by-state
  • One form, three filings: the same Form BD on the Central Registration Depository (CRD) routes to the SEC, the SRO, and the states.
  • Foreign broker-dealer exemption: specified routes include unsolicited transactions, qualifying research distribution to major U.S. institutional investors, and chaperoned institutional solicitation. Each has separate conditions.
  • Successor registration: successor files Form BD within 30 days; the predecessor's registration carries it for up to 45 days.

The One-Liners That Win Points

  • A firm that buys into inventory and resells is a dealer; one that matches buyer and seller is a broker.
  • A B/D registered with the SEC but not an SRO member cannot conduct over-the-counter (OTC) business.
  • Form BD = entry; Form BDW = withdrawal; Form BR = per-branch registration.
  • Office classification follows the activities and applicable exclusions. Final acceptance of new accounts generally triggers OSJ status; a qualifying residential supervisory location can receive non-branch treatment.
  • The New Member Application (NMA) applicant bears the burden of proof on every standard; a tie goes to denial.
  • Continuing Membership Application (CMA) ownership test: a change first brings one person or entity to 25%+ direct or indirect equity or partnership-capital ownership/control. Covered material business changes generally await FINRA review.
  • The investment adviser (IA) exclusion needs BOTH prongs: advice solely incidental AND no special compensation.
  • Representing SEC registration as Commission approval or endorsement is a fraudulent practice.
  • Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) restores missing customer assets at failed members; it does not insure investment value. Fraud does not automatically exclude a custody claim.

Numbers to Lock In

ItemValue
SEC suspension of a B/Dup to 12 months
Firm-sanction conviction timing10 years before a registration application, or any time afterward
Associated-person sanction conviction timing10 years before commencement of proceedings
Form BDW effective (SEC registration)60 days after filing
Form BDW effective (SIPC member status)6 months after SEC effective date
FINRA retention of jurisdiction after withdrawal2 years
CMA advance filing (ownership/control change)at least 30 days before; a material business change files anytime and generally waits for review unless FINRA and the member agree otherwise
CMA equity-ownership trigger25% or more (single person/entity)
NMA Standards of Admission14
Successor files Form BDwithin 30 days
Predecessor registration carries successorup to 45 days
Form BD amendmentpromptly; FINRA limit 30 days after learning
Form BD / organizational records retentionlife of the enterprise
Most other books and records6 years
SIPC advances per separate capacity$500,000 (including up to $250,000 cash)
Major U.S. institutional investorqualifying U.S. institution with more than $100 million in assets owned or under management, or qualifying SEC-registered adviser with more than $100 million under management
U.S. institutional investorspecified institutional categories; no general $50 million threshold

Top Gotchas

  • A qualifying conviction 11 years ago can support firm sanctions if it followed the registration application. The SEC's associated-person conviction ground measures ten years before proceedings commence. Statutory disqualification has a separate test.
  • The 60-day Form BDW effective period (SEC registration) is separate from the 6-month SIPC member-status delay.
  • Filing Form BDW does not escape FINRA discipline: jurisdiction survives 2 years for conduct during membership, and a parallel rule reaches associated persons who leave via Form U5.
  • "Life of the enterprise" is permanent, not 6 years. Form BD and organizational records outlive every other retention period.
  • Failure to supervise is a stand-alone basis for sanctions, even if the principal never knew of the underlying violation.
  • SIPC advances cap at $500,000, including $250,000 cash. Returned customer property may add to recovery; these are not total-recovery ceilings.
  • The 25% threshold is a single-person or single-entity ownership/control test, including indirect interests. Separate unrelated holders are not simply pooled.

One-Breath Recap

Broker means agent; dealer means principal. Registration spans federal, self-regulatory and state authorities. Form BD handles registration, BDW withdrawal and BR branches. Remember FINRA's 14 admission standards, the 25% ownership-change trigger, material business changes and two-year retained jurisdiction. Apply the correct conviction clock. SIPC advances may supplement returned customer property; investment value is not insured.


Need more than the recap? Read the full Broker-Dealer Registration unit.