Account Transfers

Quick Answer

The FINRA account-transfer requirement governs transfers through the Automated Customer Account Transfer Service (ACATS), initiated with a signed Transfer Instruction Form (TIF). The carrying member has 1 business day to validate and 3 to complete. The transfer-interference prohibition bars interfering when reps change jobs, unless the account carries a lien for money the customer owes or another bona fide claim.

The account-transfer requirement is the operational rule (how transfers work). The transfer-interference prohibition is the customer-protection rule (you cannot block transfers to punish a departing rep). The exam pairs them because the second is the principal-supervision angle on the first.


ACATS: The Transfer Mechanism

ACATS is the Automated Customer Account Transfer Service operated by the National Securities Clearing Corporation (NSCC), a subsidiary of the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC). It is the standard mechanism for transferring most customer brokerage assets between FINRA member firms.

ACATS handles:

  • Equity securities, mutual funds, ETFs, options
  • Most fixed-income securities (Treasury, corporate, municipal bonds)
  • Cash balances
  • Most retail margin balances

ACATS does not handle:

  • Annuities (separate insurance-industry transfer process)
  • Limited partnership interests in retail accounts and other nontransferable assets (the customer is contacted in writing about how to dispose of them)
  • Some proprietary mutual funds and structured products (require non-ACATS workflows)

Nontransferable Assets and the Customer's Choices

An asset is nontransferable when it cannot move from the carrying member to the receiving member because it is:

  • A proprietary product of the carrying member, unless the receiving member agrees to accept it
  • A third-party product (for example, a mutual fund or money market fund) that the receiving member has no arrangement to carry
  • Barred by regulatory limits on the scope of the receiving member's business
  • A bankrupt issue the carrying member cannot deliver in proper denominations or quantity, when no transfer agent is available to re-register the shares
  • An issue whose proper denominations cannot be obtained under governmental regulation or the product's terms (for example, some foreign securities or baby bonds)
  • A limited partnership interest in a retail account

In a whole-account transfer, the firm that asks the customer for instructions, and the choices it offers, depend on the asset:

Nontransferable AssetWho Asks, in WritingCustomer's Alternatives
Carrying member's proprietary productCarrying member, with a list of the assets, at or before validationLiquidation (with any liquidation fees disclosed), retention by the carrying member, or transfer physically and directly to the customer in the customer's name
Third-party product the receiving member cannot carryReceiving member, with a list of the assets, before it designates themLiquidation, retention by the carrying member, shipment physically and directly to the customer in the customer's name, or transfer to the third party that is the product's original source

Once the customer authorizes liquidation or transfer, the carrying member must distribute the money balance to the customer or start the transfer within 5 business days after receiving the instructions.


The ACATS Workflow

StepActionResponsibilityTiming
1Customer signs Transfer Instruction Form (TIF) authorizing transferCustomerDay 0
2Receiving member submits TIF to ACATSReceiving memberDay 0
3Carrying member validates the TIF OR takes exception on a listed groundCarrying memberWithin 1 business day of receipt
4Following validation, carrying member completes the transfer of customer assetsCarrying memberWithin 3 business days after validation
5Receiving member confirms receipt and credits customer accountReceiving memberUpon delivery

Think of it this way: The receiving firm is the one who starts the transfer; the carrying firm is the one who executes it. The customer signs once (the TIF) and the rest happens between the two firms electronically.

Who Signs the TIF

The rule treats the customer's authorization as the customer's actual signature or a valid electronic signature. When the customer cannot sign personally, a person with legal authority to act for the customer signs instead:

  • A power-of-attorney holder
  • A trustee
  • A custodian for a minor's account

The receiving firm checks that authority before it submits the TIF. A spouse, a registered representative, or a person named only in an informal note has no signing authority. A TIF with an improper authorization is a listed exception ground (see Validation and Exceptions below).

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The receiving member initiates; the carrying member validates or takes exception within one business day and completes transfer within three business days after validation.

Validation and Exceptions

The carrying member must validate the TIF within 1 business day. The carrying member may instead take exception (refuse to validate), but only on a ground the account-transfer requirement lists. The list is closed: a reason it does not name cannot block validation. Common exception categories:

  • Social Security number (SSN) or tax ID mismatch: the SSN or tax ID on the TIF does not match the carrying-firm record
  • Account title or account type mismatch: the title or type on the TIF does not match the carrying-firm record
  • Account flat: no transferable assets (the account is empty); the receiving member may resubmit only with the most recent customer statement attached
  • Duplicate request: a previous TIF is already in process for the same account
  • Invalid account number, or a missing or improper authorization on the TIF
  • Additional documentation required: for example, a death or marriage certificate
  • Credit-policy violation, a customer rescission of the instruction, or the customer has taken possession of the assets

A dispute over positions or the money balance cannot block validation; the carrying member transfers what its books show. A lien is not one of the listed grounds either; it matters under the transfer-interference prohibition, covered below.

Exceptions must be promptly resolved by both firms. An exception is not a denial; it is a flag that the parties must clear before the transfer can proceed.

The Account Freeze on Validation

When the carrying member validates an instruction to transfer an account in whole, it must freeze the account:

  • All open orders are canceled, except option positions that expire within 7 business days
  • No new orders may be taken

Residual Credits After the Transfer

Dividends, interest and other credits can reach the old account after the transfer is done. For at least 6 months after a whole-account transfer is completed, each member must transfer any credit balances (cash and securities) that accrue to the transferred account within 10 business days after they accrue. Where the clearing agency offers residual credit processing and both firms participate in it, that facility must be used.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A lien is not an ACATS validation exception; the separate interference carve-out concerns money owed by the customer or another bona fide claim.
  • Both firms must promptly resolve valid exceptions.

Interference With Customer Transfers

When a registered representative changes employment, the customer often follows the rep to the new firm. The FINRA transfer-interference prohibition prohibits the prior (carrying) firm from interfering with that customer's transfer request.

The rule states that it is inconsistent with just and equitable principles of trade for a member or associated person to interfere with a customer's request to transfer the account in connection with a change in employment of the customer's registered representative.

What Is Prohibited

  • Seeking judicial orders or decrees to bar or restrict a customer transfer request
  • Imposing conditions on the transfer that are not imposed on transfers in the ordinary course (delay tactics, additional documentation requirements, etc.)
  • Contacting the customer to dissuade the transfer in a manner that misrepresents the rep, the new firm, or the customer's rights

What Is Permitted

  • An account subject to a lien or other bona fide claim: the prohibition reaches only an account that is not subject to a lien for money the customer owes (for example, a margin debit or unpaid fees) or another bona fide claim. Such an account falls outside the ban on interference; the account-transfer requirement still governs how the transfer itself is processed
  • Pursuing claims against the departing rep: the rule protects the customer's right to transfer, not the rep's right to leave without consequence. Non-compete clauses, garden-leave provisions, and other employment claims against the departing rep are not restricted by the transfer-interference prohibition

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A customer credit balance is not a lien for money the customer owes.
  • The transfer-interference rule protects the customer’s request while employment claims against the representative remain separate.

How the ACATS Mechanics and the Transfer-Interference Prohibition Interact

The ACATS rule sets the mechanics (1 day to validate, 3 days to deliver). The transfer-interference prohibition sets the integrity (no improper interference). A firm that complies with the ACATS timing but takes exception on a pretextual ground (for example, demanding additional documentation that is not required for ordinary transfers) violates the transfer-interference prohibition even though the timeline looks correct.

A firm that taps the brakes on every transfer request from departing reps' customers will eventually face a transfer-interference charge regardless of how clean the ACATS paperwork is.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Timely ACATS processing does not excuse pretextual transfer interference.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you state the ACATS timeline: 1 business day to validate the Transfer Instruction Form, then 3 business days to complete the transfer?
  • Do you know which assets ACATS does not handle, such as annuities and nontransferable limited partnership units?
  • Can you state the freeze on validation (open orders canceled except options expiring within 7 business days, no new orders) and the 6-month, 10-business-day residual credit rule?
  • Can you place the lien carve-out in the transfer-interference prohibition, not the account-transfer exception list, and tell a lien for money the customer owes from a credit balance the firm owes?
  • Do you know that meeting the ACATS timing does not excuse a transfer-interference violation if the carrying firm invents a pretextual exception?