Quick Answer
Know your customer (KYC) gathers the essential facts; then Regulation Best Interest (Reg BI) governs retail recommendations while suitability governs institutional ones. Firms must price fairly under the 5% policy, deliver Form CRS and the annual disclosure stack, document discretion with three writings, approve day trading, avoid breakpoint sales, and recognize red flags.
Review the framework.
The One-Liners That Win Points
- KYC is fact-gathering; suitability is using the facts. An order from an unauthorized person violates KYC even if the trade is suitable.
- Suitability has three layers: reasonable-basis (suited to some investors), customer-specific (suited to this profile), and quantitative (a recommended series not excessive, with no control requirement).
- Reg BI governs recommendations to a retail customer (natural person, personal/family/household use) through four required obligations: Disclosure, Care, Conflict of Interest, and Compliance.
- The Care Obligation requires cost consideration with risks, rewards and the customer's profile. A suitable recommendation can still fail the best-interest standard. A lower-cost alternative matters, but its existence does not automatically make a higher-cost recommendation improper or require an investment beyond the customer's resources and needs.
- Reg BI must ELIMINATE sales contests, quotas, bonuses, and non-cash comp based on sales of specific securities or types of securities within a limited period; firm-wide production-based comp is permitted.
- Customer Relationship Summary (Form CRS) covers natural persons, including their nonprofessional legal representatives, seeking or receiving services primarily for personal, family, or household purposes. It can apply before a recommendation; regulated professional representatives are excluded.
- Net (principal) transactions: non-institutional customers give written order-by-order consent; institutional customers can use a negative-consent letter.
- Discretionary accounts need three writings: customer authorization, firm acceptance, and prompt written approval of each order by the firm or designee; oral authorization never suffices.
- Time and price discretion is NOT discretionary trading. It ordinarily lasts through that business day; specific signed and dated contrary instructions or qualifying institutional not-held good-till-canceled instructions can extend it.
- A day-trading firm that PROMOTES the strategy must deliver the risk-disclosure statement and make a good-faith appropriateness determination or get a written non-day-trading agreement.
- Breakpoint sale = selling fund shares below the discount threshold to keep the higher sales charge; check rights of accumulation (ROA), letter of intent (LOI), and combined purchases.
Numbers to Lock In
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Fair-pricing "5% policy" | Guideline, not a safe harbor (below 5% can be unfair) |
| Service-charge change notice | none set by rule; honor the account agreement |
| Form CRS length | 2 pages standalone broker-dealer / 4 pages dual registrant |
| Form CRS retention | 6 years (easily accessible the whole period) |
| Form CRS amendment delivery (existing customers) | Within 60 days |
| Institutional-customer asset test (anyone other than a bank, savings and loan, insurance company, registered investment company or registered investment adviser, which qualify by type) | At least $50 million in total assets |
| Typical Class A breakpoints | $50,000 / $100,000 / $250,000 / $500,000 / $1,000,000 |
| Letter of intent (LOI) window | usually 13 months, per prospectus |
| Predispute arbitration copy | Within 30 days of signing |
| Trusted Contact Person (TCP) | Reasonable efforts to obtain a contact age 18 or older |
| Mail hold beyond convenience | Over 3 months needs an acceptable reason |
| Negotiable-instrument authorization records | 3 years after authorization expires |
Memory Aid: The Customer's Mailbox in Three Timing Buckets
Picture the customer's mailbox in three timing buckets:
- Annual stack: three flyers yearly (margin risk, SIPC information, BrokerCheck notice) in one envelope.
- Trigger-and-done: one delivery with a deadline tied to an event, like extended-hours risk before the first after-hours trade (opening delivery also works) or the arbitration copy within 30 days of signing.
- Pass-through: issuer mailings, like proxy materials, forwarded to the beneficial owner.
Top Gotchas
- Reg BI vs. suitability turns on the customer: retail natural person means Reg BI, institutional or non-retail means suitability, even for the same product and firm.
- The 5% policy is a guideline, not a hard cap: a 4.5% markup can be unfair on a blue-chip stock, a higher markup can be fair on a thinly-traded bond, and disclosure never cures an unfair price.
- Disclosure does not cure a Care Obligation failure; a firm cannot disclose its way out of a poor recommendation.
- A breakpoint sale needs no intent to cheat, but it needs a purpose: the sale is kept just below the threshold in order to share in the higher sales charge; a near-breakpoint amount or a missed discount check is a red flag to investigate, not proof by itself.
- A no-day-trading agreement stops working once the firm knows otherwise: a promoting firm that knows a non-institutional customer intends to day trade must approve the strategy on reasonable grounds and record the basis.
- The Trusted Contact Person is informational only and cannot authorize trades, change beneficiaries, or direct disbursements.
- Failure to document the supervisory response is a discrete violation, independent of the underlying conduct: recognize, investigate, escalate.
One-Breath Recap
Know your customer gathers the essential facts, then Reg BI governs retail recommendations through its four obligations (Disclosure, Care, Conflict, Compliance) while suitability's three layers govern institutional ones; Reg BI ranks above suitability and requires explicit cost consideration. Price fairly under the 5% guideline, get written order-by-order consent for retail net transactions, deliver Form CRS and the annual disclosure stack, document discretion with three writings, approve day trading through an appropriateness determination or a written no-day-trading agreement, never keep a sale below a breakpoint to earn the higher charge, and recognize, investigate, escalate, and document red flags. Nail the customer split and the numbers, and this unit answers itself.
Need more than the recap? Read the full Recommendations and Disclosures unit.