Quick Answer
A broker acts for others (commission), a dealer acts for its own account (markup or markdown), and most firms are both. Broker-dealers register both federally (Securities and Exchange Commission plus a self-regulatory organization) and in every state where they do business, keep detailed books and records, confirm trades in writing, and supervise their agents.
Review broker-dealer status, exclusions, underwriting, market makers, registration, and supervision.
What Makes a Firm a Broker-Dealer?
- Broker: effects transactions in securities for the account of others (agent capacity), earns a commission.
- Dealer: as a regular business, buys and sells securities for its own account (principal capacity), earns a markup (on sales) or markdown (on purchases); an ordinary investor trading their own account is not a dealer.
- Most firms do both and are called broker-dealers; the label describes the capacity on a given trade, not a permanent title.
Who Is Excluded From the Definition?
- Agents, issuers selling their own securities (no frequency test), and banks, savings institutions, and trust companies under the Uniform Securities Act. Federal law instead gives banks activity-specific exceptions.
What Makes a Firm an Underwriter?
- An underwriter purchases from an issuer with a view to distribution, offers or sells for an issuer in a distribution, or participates in such an undertaking; excludes a person whose only interest is a commission from an underwriter or dealer within the usual and customary seller's commission.
- Firm commitment: underwriter buys the entire issue, bearing the risk of unsold shares.
- Best efforts: underwriter acts as agent, never purchases the shares, so unsold shares remain with the issuer (issuer bears risk).
- The managing underwriter forms the underwriting syndicate; selling group members distribute shares for a concession, taking on no syndicate purchase liability, which only syndicate members bear.
Who Are Market Makers and Associated Persons?
- Market maker: a dealer willing to buy and sell for its own account on a regular or continuous basis, maintaining a two-sided market (both a bid AND an ask) at its quoted prices, earning the spread; not a guarantee a counterparty is always available.
- Associated person: any partner, officer, director, or employee of a broker-dealer, plus anyone controlling, controlled by, or under common control with it; registration provisions exclude employees whose functions are SOLELY clerical or ministerial.
How Does a Broker-Dealer Register and Stay Registered?
- Dual registration: broker-dealers register BOTH federally (SEC plus self-regulatory-organization membership) AND in every state where they do business (unlike investment advisers, who register with one or the other), subject to a no-place-of-business exclusion (institutional-only transactions, or an existing nonresident customer).
- Those two routes are independent alternatives, not a single test. A retail in-state transaction defeats the institutional route, yet a qualifying existing nonresident customer may still fit the second one. An in-state office defeats both.
- Books-and-records creation rule: make and keep current trade blotters, general ledgers, customer account records, order tickets, and specifically created communication records; originals received and copies of items sent are instead preserved under the retention rule.
- Confirmation rule: send a written confirmation at or before completion of a trade, disclosing date and time of execution (or notice it's available on request), security, quantity, price, capacity (agent, or principal and whether a market maker), and commission (agency) or markup/markdown (specified principal transactions).
- Payment-for-order-flow disclosure applies only when received; SIPC disclosure applies only when the firm is NOT a member.
What Does Supervision Require?
- Branch office inspections on a tiered cycle: offices of supervisory jurisdiction (OSJs) and branches supervising non-branch locations at least annually, other non-supervisory branch offices at least every three years, reasonably designed to detect and prevent violations, including handling of written customer complaints.
- A registered principal must supervise each OSJ; a non-OSJ branch may instead use a registered representative or a principal.
- A broker-dealer can be liable for an agent's violation without knowledge of the misconduct if it lacked reasonable supervisory procedures.
Which One-Liners Win Points?
- Banks are excluded from the broker-dealer definition under the USA; federal law gives them activity-specific exceptions instead, not a blanket exclusion.
Which Numbers Matter Most?
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Disciplinary lookback disclosed on the uniform application | past 10 years (felony charges, guilty pleas, convictions) |
| Trade blotters, ledgers, position records | 6 years (first 2 years readily accessible) |
| Originals of communications received, copies sent | 3 years (first 2 years readily accessible) |
| Employment applications, disciplinary actions | 3 years after termination |
| Written supervisory procedures | 3 years after being superseded |
| Partnership articles, uniform application, licenses | life of the enterprise |
| Branch office inspections | OSJs and supervising branches at least annually; other, non-supervisory branches at least every 3 years |
Which Gotchas Trip Students Up?
- "First 2 years readily accessible" isn't exclusive to 6-year records; it also applies to 3-year communications records (the exam may phrase this as "immediately available").
One-Breath Recap
A broker effects trades for others for a commission, a dealer trades its own account for a markup or markdown, and most firms do both, so the label describes capacity on a given trade; agents, issuers, banks, savings institutions, and trust companies are excluded. Underwriters bring securities out under firm commitment (the underwriter bears the risk), best efforts (the issuer does), or all-or-none, a type of best efforts. Market makers quote two-sided regularly or continuously, and associated persons are everyone but, for registration, the solely clerical. Broker-dealers register federally and in states where they do business, keep records, confirm trades, and supervise. Supervision includes a designated principal at each office of supervisory jurisdiction, written procedures established, maintained, and enforced, generally pre-use principal approval of retail communications subject to exceptions, and tiered branch inspections.
Need more than the recap? Read the full Broker-Dealer Regulation unit.