Portfolio Performance Measures

Quick Answer

Current yield is annual income over current price. Total return adds capital change plus income over beginning value. Time-weighted return judges the manager and ignores cash flows; dollar-weighted return judges the investor. Sharpe uses total risk, Treynor uses systematic risk, and a benchmark must match the portfolio's style, cap size, and geography.

Review yields, returns, risk-adjusted ratios, and benchmarks.


Which One-Liners Win Points?

  • Current yield and price move inversely: the coupon is fixed, so a higher price means a lower yield.
  • Annualized return uses geometric (compound) averaging, not arithmetic; arithmetic generally overstates true compound growth whenever periodic returns vary.
  • Positive alpha means the manager beat what the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) predicted, not just that the portfolio rose.

Which Formulas Must You Reproduce?

Current yield, bonds:

Current Yield=Annual Coupon PaymentCurrent Market Price\text{Current Yield} = \frac{\text{Annual Coupon Payment}}{\text{Current Market Price}}

Current yield, stocks:

Current Yield=Annual DividendCurrent Stock Price\text{Current Yield} = \frac{\text{Annual Dividend}}{\text{Current Stock Price}}
  • Total return / holding period return (HPR): (Ending Value minus Beginning Value, plus Income) / Beginning Value
  • Expected return: Sum of (Probability x Return) for each scenario
  • Sharpe ratio: (Portfolio Return minus Risk-Free Rate) / Standard Deviation of Portfolio
  • Treynor ratio: (Portfolio Return minus Risk-Free Rate) / Beta of Portfolio
  • Jensen's alpha: Portfolio Return - [Risk-Free Rate + Beta x (Market Return - Risk-Free Rate)]
  • Real (inflation-adjusted) return, approximate: Nominal Return minus Inflation Rate
  • Real return, precise: (1 + Nominal) / (1 + Inflation) - 1
  • Tax-equivalent yield: Municipal Bond Yield / (1 - Tax Rate)

Which Worked Examples Should You Recognize?

  • Total return: buy at $50, collect $2 dividend, sell at $55. ($55 - $50 + $2) / $50 = 14%.
  • Expected return: (0.40 x 12%) + (0.50 x 6%) + (0.10 x -8%) = 4.8% + 3.0% + (-0.8%) = 7.0%.
  • Real return: 8% nominal, 3% inflation. Approximate = 5%; precise = (1.08 / 1.03) - 1 = 4.85%.
  • Tax-equivalent yield: 3.5% muni, 32% federal bracket. 3.5% / (1 - 0.32) = 3.5% / 0.68 = 5.15%.

How Do Price, Coupon, and Yield Move Together?

For fixed-rate bonds with positive coupons:

Bond Price vs. ParCurrent Yield vs. CouponCurrent Yield vs. YTM
Premium (above par)Current yield < couponCurrent yield > YTM
At parCurrent yield = couponCurrent yield = YTM
Discount (below par)Current yield > couponCurrent yield < YTM

Which Return Measure Applies When?

MeasureWhat It ShowsCash FlowsBest Used For
Time-weightedManager's skillRemovedEvaluating the manager, GIPS reporting
Dollar-weighted (commonly the IRR)Investor's experienceIncludedEvaluating the investor's actual result
Sharpe ratioExcess return per unit of total riskUses standard deviationThe investor's entire portfolio
Treynor ratioExcess return per unit of systematic riskUses betaOne of many diversified portfolios
AlphaReturn above CAPM predictionUses beta via CAPMAny actively managed portfolio

What Makes a Benchmark Relevant?

BenchmarkWhat It Tracks
S&P 500500 large-cap U.S. equities
Russell 1000 Value / GrowthLarge-cap U.S. value-style / growth-style subsets
Russell 2000Small-cap U.S. equities
MSCI EAFE (Europe, Australasia, Far East)International developed markets (excludes U.S. and Canada)
Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond IndexInvestment-grade, dollar-denominated, fixed-rate taxable U.S. bonds
MSCI Emerging MarketsEmerging market equities
  • Match style, cap size, geography, and asset class to the portfolio.
  • Multi-asset portfolios may use a custom blended benchmark (e.g., 60% S&P 500 + 40% Bloomberg Aggregate) or a published multi-asset index.

Which Gotchas Trip Students Up?

  • HPR and total return share one formula, but HPR is not annualized: a 30% HPR over 3 years is not a 10% annual return.
  • If a well-diversified portfolio has no unsystematic risk left, Sharpe and Treynor rank managers the same; if it is not diversified, the rankings can diverge.
  • A portfolio can post a positive return and still have negative alpha if it underperformed the CAPM expectation for its risk.
  • GIPS generally requires time-weighted return (exception only when the firm controls external cash flows AND the fund is closed-end, fixed-life, fixed-commitment, or significantly illiquid); picking dollar-weighted for manager evaluation is the trap.
  • MSCI EAFE excludes the U.S. and Canada; Russell 2000 (small-cap) is easily confused with the Russell 3000 (roughly 98% of the investable U.S. market by cap). S&P 500 blends value and growth.
  • Municipal bond interest is generally exempt from federal tax (and possibly state or local in-state), which is why the tax-equivalent yield grosses it up before comparing to a taxable bond.

One-Breath Recap

Current yield is annual income over current price. For fixed-rate bonds with positive coupons, it sits below the coupon at a premium and above it at a discount. Total return and holding period return add price change plus income over beginning value. Use time-weighted return for the manager (cash flows removed, generally required by GIPS) and dollar-weighted return, commonly the internal rate of return, for the investor. Judge risk with Sharpe (total risk, standard deviation) for a whole portfolio and Treynor (systematic risk, beta) for one of many. Positive alpha beats the Capital Asset Pricing Model prediction. Match the benchmark's style, cap size, and geography to the portfolio.


Need more than the recap? Read the full Portfolio Performance Measures unit.