Quick Answer
Three exemptions, three different constraints. Regulation A is a public offering the regulator must still qualify, capped by tier. The intrastate exemption trades registration for a strict one-state boundary on every offer and every sale. Regulation S treats a genuinely offshore offer or sale as no offer at all for registration purposes.
The whole unit on one sheet: tier caps, residency tests, offshore clocks.
Which One-Liners Win Points?
- Regulation A still needs qualification. The Securities and Exchange Commission must qualify the offering statement, filed on Form 1-A, before any sale. Oral offers, a preliminary offering circular and testing-the-waters solicitations are allowed while it is on file.
- Tier 1 keeps state registration; Tier 2 preempts it. A Tier 2 security is a covered security: no state registration or merit review, though a notice filing still applies.
- Tier 2 reports; Tier 1 does not. Annual on Form 1-K, semiannual on Form 1-SA, current events on Form 1-U, plus a special financial report. Tier 1 files only an exit report on Form 1-Z within 30 calendar days.
- Eligibility: organized and headquartered in the United States or Canada, and not a blank-check shell, registered fund, mineral-rights issuer, delinquent filer or bad actor.
- Intrastate residency is two tests. An entity issuer must be organized in and headquartered in the state, and meet one of four doing-business tests: 80% of revenue, assets, or net proceeds used in-state, or a majority of employees.
- An entity buyer is resident on its principal place of business alone; a purpose-formed buyer only if every beneficial owner is in-state.
- Regulation S needs three things at once. An offshore transaction, no directed selling efforts in the United States, and any conditions the category adds. Aiming activity at the U.S. market is enough; it need not work.
Which Numbers Matter Most?
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Tier 1 per 12 months | $20 million, $6 million affiliate resales |
| Tier 2 per 12 months | $75 million, $22.5 million affiliate resales |
| Non-accredited Tier 2 purchaser | 10% of the greater of income or net worth |
| Selling securityholders | 30% of the first offering |
| Intrastate resale | Six months per security |
| Offshore category 2 | 40 days |
| Offshore category 3 | 40 days debt, one year equity, six months if reporting |
Which Gotchas Trip Students Up?
- The 12-month figure limits size; the two-year and three-year figures limit how long a continuous offering stays open, and only annual and semiannual filings keep it selling.
- The 30% cap covers only the first Regulation A offering and one qualified within a year of it.
- The 10% cap applies only to a Tier 2 offering not exchange-listed, and the issuer may rely on the purchaser's representation unless it knows at the sale it is false.
- The intrastate six-month clock runs per security, and a second offering in a different state waits six months from the prior offering's last sale.
- A purchaser's signed residency statement alone does not support reasonable belief.
- Offshore equity of a domestic issuer bought from the issuer, a distributor or an affiliate is restricted on acquisition, and the compliance period starts at the later of the first non-distributor offer and the closing.
One-Breath Recap
Three exemptions, three constraints. Regulation A is a qualified public offering: Tier 1 raises $20 million per rolling 12 months and keeps state registration, Tier 2 raises $75 million, preempts it but not the notice filing, caps a non-accredited purchaser at 10% of the greater of income or net worth, and files ongoing reports where Tier 1 files only an exit report. The intrastate exemption demands issuer residency, one of four 80% doing-business tests, in-state offers and sales, and a six-month resale limit. Regulation S needs an offshore transaction, no directed selling efforts, and its category conditions, with compliance periods from none to a year.
Need more than the recap? Read the full Regulation A, Regulation S and Intrastate Offerings unit.