Quick Answer
The SEC's records-retention rule covers manuals kept at least 3 years after use ends; compliant electronic storage using WORM or an audit-trail alternative; an access undertaking by a third party or executive officer; continuing retention after business ceases; applicable outside-provider undertakings, with independent access supporting an alternative; and prompt furnishing to the SEC on request.
The records-retention rule is the "preserving" half of the SEC recordkeeping pair. Together with the recordmaking rule, it forms the federal floor for broker-dealer recordkeeping.
Compliance, Supervisory, and Procedures Manuals
Firms must preserve compliance, supervisory, and procedures manuals, including any updates, modifications, and revisions.
| Requirement | Detail |
|---|---|
| What | Manuals describing the firm's policies and practices for compliance with applicable laws and rules, and for supervision of activities of each natural person associated with the firm |
| Retention | While in use and at least 3 years after use of the manual ends |
| Accessibility | Kept in an easily accessible place for the entire retention period, including all 3 years after use ends, not just the first 2 years |
| Updates | Updates, modifications, and revisions are themselves preserved (not just the latest version) |
Why the End of Use Matters
The three-year post-use period does not start when the manual is created or adopted. It starts when use of that version ends. Superseding it with a new version is one way its use ends, but a replacement is not required. A manual in active use, no matter how old, remains subject to ongoing preservation.
- A 12-year-old written supervisory procedure (WSP) manual that has never been updated is still in active use; no 3-year clock has started
- A manual replaced in 2024 must be preserved through at least 2027 (3 years after supersession)
- Each version's clock is independent; updating a manual triggers a new 3-year clock for the version being replaced
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Preserve each manual version while used and at least three years after its use ends, even without a replacement.
Electronic Storage Media
A broker-dealer may preserve required records on electronic storage media if each electronic recordkeeping system meets one of two standards. The firm chooses the standard for each system.
Two Permitted Standards (Pick One per System)
| Standard | What It Requires |
|---|---|
| WORM (Write Once, Read Many) | Preserve records exclusively in a non-rewriteable, non-erasable format |
| Audit-Trail Alternative | A system that permits recreation of an original record if it is modified or deleted, with a complete time-stamped audit trail of every change |
Under either standard, the storage system must also:
- Automatically verify the completeness and accuracy of the recording process
- Serialize and time-date the storage media where applicable
- Be able to readily download and transfer copies of a record (with its audit trail, if applicable) and the information needed to locate that record, in a human-readable and a reasonably usable electronic format, when regulators require it
These requirements apply to the whole system, not only to the WORM option.
The firm chooses which standard to apply. Both are acceptable. The audit-trail alternative is friendlier to modern cloud and database storage that natively supports versioning and audit logs.
The rule sets each standard as a duty of "an electronic recordkeeping system." So the choice is made per system, not once for the whole firm. A firm may keep historical records in a WORM archive and newer records in a separate audit-trail system. Each system must fully meet the standard it uses, plus the other electronic-storage requirements below. No SEC pre-approval is needed to run both.
Other Electronic-Storage Requirements
In addition to choosing a storage standard, the firm must:
- Backup or redundancy: The system must include a backup electronic recordkeeping system that keeps a redundant set of records, or have other redundancy capabilities designed to ensure access to the records
- Locating records: The firm must organize, maintain, keep current, and promptly provide on request all information necessary to access and locate the stored records
- The electronic system itself must also be able to readily download and transfer that locating information, so a paper-only index does not meet this duty for an electronic recordkeeping system
- For micrographic media such as microfilm, the rule requires accurate indexes, a duplicate copy of the records and a duplicate of each index, each stored separately from the original
- Access undertaking: Either:
- A third-party access undertaking (a third party files a written undertaking with the firm's Designated Examining Authority (DEA), agreeing to download a requested record if the firm fails to), OR
- An executive officer designation: the firm may designate an executive officer of the firm in lieu of a third party for the same purpose
- DEA filing: The undertaking is filed with the firm's DEA. For most broker-dealers, FINRA is the DEA
- Always on file: The firm must have the undertaking filed with the DEA at all times. The duty attaches to the electronic recordkeeping system, not to the WORM or audit-trail choice, so moving from one standard to the other does not by itself require a new filing. A new filing is needed when the signer changes, such as when the firm replaces its third party or executive officer
No Advance DEA Notice Required
A firm may adopt an electronic recordkeeping system without notifying the DEA in advance, provided the system itself meets the electronic-storage standards above.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- WORM and the audit-trail alternative are choices per system; each system must meet its standard and other storage requirements.
- The access undertaking remains on file with the DEA under either standard; changing standards alone does not require refiling.
- A third party or designated executive officer must give the undertaking.
Records After Ceasing Business
If a broker-dealer ceases to transact a securities business, the firm must continue to preserve records for the remainder of the applicable retention period.
The retention obligation does not extinguish at termination:
- A firm that ceases operations in Year 4 of a 6-year retention period must continue to preserve those records through Year 6
- The Form BDW filing does not itself end recordkeeping; the FINRA post-withdrawal custodian requirement handles the post-cessation custody mechanics
This is the substantive obligation that the FINRA custodian requirement implements at the FINRA level: the records survive the firm.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Withdrawal does not end preservation: keep records for the remaining applicable period and designate the required Form BDW custodian.
Independent Access to Outsourced Records
A broker-dealer has independent access to outsourced electronic records when it can regularly access them without outside-provider intervention and, through that access, permit regulatory examination during business hours and promptly furnish true, correct, complete and current hard copies. Direct retrieval alone does not establish every element of the definition or satisfy every other recordkeeping duty.
What "Independent Access" Means
The firm's routine access must not require the provider to take an intervening step:
- A provider-owned automated portal can qualify if the firm regularly retrieves records without provider action and meets the examination and production conditions
- Required provider approval, unlocking or decryption before each retrieval prevents independent access through that process
- Provider reputation, payment arrangements or membership status do not replace the access criteria
- The definition does not impose a universal requirement for round-the-clock access; the firm's actual examination and production capabilities still matter
The firm must also keep the information needed to access and locate its records current and provide it promptly on request.
Provider Undertakings and Continuing Responsibility
For covered outside recordkeeping services, the provider files a written undertaking with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) acknowledging the firm's ownership of the records and providing for prompt surrender, regulatory examination and production. Independent access supports a different, alternative provider undertaking for qualifying electronic systems; it does not eliminate the undertaking.
The alternative includes the provider's commitment to facilitate within its ability, and not impede or prevent, specified regulatory access and transfers. If routine retrieval requires provider intervention, that access cannot support the alternative. Assess the standard undertaking route and all other applicable requirements instead of concluding that every outsourced arrangement without independent access is categorically prohibited.
The provider undertaking is separate from the electronic-recordkeeping access undertaking given by a designated third party or executive officer. Neither outsourcing nor an undertaking relieves the broker-dealer of its own recordkeeping responsibility.
Electronic-recordkeeping requirements also call for facilities to produce records to be available at all times and for the firm to be ready to provide, and immediately provide, requested records. The business-hours examination element of independent access does not waive those separate production duties or the backup and redundancy requirements.
Assess continuity risks as well as routine access. A possible future suspension, including for nonpayment, requires attention to continuing record availability and regulatory production. Current direct access is not a safe harbor for losing required capabilities. Evaluate and address the actual risk rather than assuming every contract clause is automatically permitted or prohibited.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Automated firm retrieval can support independent access; required provider approval or decryption cannot.
- Independent access supports an alternative provider undertaking; it does not eliminate that undertaking or other storage duties.
Furnishing of Records to the SEC
Members must promptly furnish legible, true, complete, and current copies of records to a representative of the SEC upon request. This furnishing provision names only SEC representatives. Current means the record as it stands now, including any amendments. It does not mean rewriting old records; the firm keeps its earlier versions preserved and furnishes copies that include the amendments.
FINRA examiners get records through a different source. FINRA's own information-and-inspection rule lets FINRA staff require a member to provide information and to inspect and copy the member's books and records during an examination. A firm cannot limit production to the SEC.
This requirement links to the electronic-storage third-party access undertaking. A third party (or designated executive officer) executes a written undertaking filed with the firm's DEA agreeing to furnish information that the SEC, the firm's self-regulatory organizations, or a State securities regulator request, and to download a requested record if the firm fails to.
- For most broker-dealers, FINRA is the DEA
- The access undertaking backs up the furnishing obligation: the firm itself must produce requested records, and if it fails to download one, the third party (or executive officer) must
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- For most broker-dealers, FINRA is the DEA; another designated examining authority may apply.
How the Records-Retention Pieces Connect
| Area | What It Governs | Period or Standard |
|---|---|---|
| Manuals retention | Compliance, supervisory, procedures manuals | While in use and until at least 3 years after use ends, easily accessible throughout |
| Electronic storage | Electronic storage media | WORM or audit-trail alternative; backup or redundancy; information to locate records; access undertaking |
| Ceased business | Records after ceasing business | Remainder of applicable retention period |
| Outsourced storage | Covered outside recordkeeping providers | Applicable provider undertaking; qualifying independent access permits the alternative undertaking |
| Furnishing to the SEC | SEC examination access | Promptly on request |
A firm satisfies the records-retention rule only when it satisfies all applicable provisions. Format compliance, retention durations, post-cessation custody, outsourcing controls, and SEC responsiveness are independent compliance items.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Do you know that the 3-year manuals post-use period starts when use ends, whether or not a new version replaces the manual?
- Can you state the two permitted electronic-storage standards, and who may give the access undertaking besides a third party?
- Do you know that a records-retention obligation continues for the remainder of its period even after the firm ceases business?
- Can you apply all elements of independent access, distinguish the provider undertaking routes, and assess approval steps and continuity risks without treating every cloud portal as prohibited?