Quick Answer
Firms meeting qualifying thresholds must record telephone conversations between registered persons and existing or potential customers unless relief applies. Keep recordings at least three years from creation, with the first two easily accessible. First-time staffing reduction requires meeting the 30-day deadline, written-notice conditions and 180-day rehire restriction. Exceptional exemption is a separate written-application route; filing alone is not a grant.
The Taping Rule imposes heightened supervision on firms meeting its qualifying thresholds. A required program covers all registered persons' telephone conversations with existing or potential customers.
Purpose: Targeting "Cockroach Firms"
The Taping Rule is designed to prevent fraudulent and improper sales practices at firms that absorb registered persons from previously expelled or revoked firms. The regulatory concern: when a disciplined firm shuts down, its registered persons often migrate together to a new firm, bringing the same sales-practice culture with them.
The taping requirement creates a paper trail that supervisors and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) can review for misconduct.
A firm is sometimes called a "cockroach firm" or taping firm when it crosses the rule's thresholds; both terms refer to the heightened-supervision status.
What Counts as a "Disciplined Firm"
A "disciplined firm" meets one of three specified routes:
- Member route: A FINRA member, in connection with securities sales practices, is expelled from membership or participation in any securities industry self-regulatory organization, or is subject to a Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) order revoking broker-dealer registration.
- Resolved-charges route: A futures commission merchant or introducing broker is formally charged by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission or a registered futures association with deceptive telemarketing practices or promotional material relating to security futures. The charges are resolved, and the firm is closed down and permanently barred from the futures industry as a result.
- Security-futures revocation route: A futures commission merchant or introducing broker is subject to an SEC order revoking registration as a broker or dealer in connection with sales practices involving security futures.
Complaints, investigation, ordinary fines, suspension and voluntary closure alone do not meet these specified events. The definition does not include an open-ended "other misconduct" category.
FINRA publishes a list of firms meeting the definition and describes the list as covering firms disciplined within the last three years. The list can assist checking; apply the actual disciplinary criteria. The rule's three-year association lookback is a separate part of the staffing calculation.
At each current concentration assessment, look back three years. Check the member's current registered persons for registered-capacity associations with disciplined firms in that window. Departure dates show when associations ended; they do not start a forward-running waiting period or permanently fix the result at the original hiring date.
Exclude a person with ninety days or less in aggregate at disciplined firms within the window and no qualifying disciplinary history. Both conditions must apply. The history definition concerns specified regulatory violation findings within five years, rather than every complaint or sanction. An excluded person remains in total registered-person headcount.
For example, sixty days at one disciplined firm and forty-five at another totals 105 days, so the short-tenure exclusion does not apply. A person whose only association ended four years ago is outside the current window. Aging out of the numerator does not by itself shorten an already required procedure-maintenance period.
The Concentration Thresholds
The rule's thresholds are tied to firm size:
| Member Firm Size (Registered Persons) | Trigger Concentration |
|---|---|
| 5-9 registered persons | 40% or more from disciplined firms |
| 10-19 registered persons | 4 or more from disciplined firms (absolute count) |
| 20+ registered persons | 20% or more from disciplined firms |
The middle band uses an absolute count (4) instead of a percentage. The other two bands use percentages.
Threshold Examples
Apply the association window and short-tenure/history exclusion first. The following examples use qualifying registered persons after those tests and the firm's current total registered-person headcount:
- A 7-person firm with 3 qualifying persons: 3/7 is about 42.9%, meeting the 40% threshold
- A 200-person firm with the same 3 qualifying persons: 3/200 is 1.5%, below the 20% threshold
- A 12-person firm with 4 qualifying persons meets the middle band's fixed count of 4, regardless of percentage
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Use total registered-person headcount and the correct size band: the middle band counts four qualifying persons, not a percentage.
- Apply the current three-year lookback and the short-tenure/no-history exclusion before counting qualifying persons.
Required Procedures
A firm subject to the Taping Rule must:
- Tape record all telephone conversations between the firm's registered persons and existing and potential customers
- Establish, maintain, and enforce written supervisory procedures (WSPs) for the taping system, establishing and implementing them within 60 days of FINRA notice or actual knowledge of taping-firm status
- Keep the special procedures in place for 3 years from the date the firm establishes and implements them
- Conduct periodic review of recordings to confirm compliance with securities laws and FINRA rules
- Catalog retained tapes by registered person and date
- File quarterly reports with FINRA, due by the 30th day of the month following the end of each calendar quarter, describing the firm's supervision of registered persons subject to the rule
The taping must be comprehensive, not selective:
- The firm cannot record only "high-risk" calls
- The firm cannot record only certain registered persons
- All registered-person-to-customer telephone conversations are subject to the rule
Device policies must achieve capture of covered calls. Routing calls through a recording system or restricting business use that cannot be recorded can help. A restriction is one possible control, not the only legally permitted approach. Personal ownership, home location, market hours and brevity do not independently exempt an otherwise covered customer conversation. A later signed policy cannot retroactively create missing recordings.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Record all covered registered-person telephone conversations with existing and potential customers, not just selected calls.
- Quarterly supervision reports go to FINRA by the 30th day of the month after each calendar quarter.
- Distinguish the three-year association lookback, procedure-maintenance period and recording-retention period; their starting events differ.
Tape Retention
| Requirement | Detail |
|---|---|
| Retention period | At least 3 years from the date the recording was created |
| Easily accessible | First 2 years must be in an easily accessible place |
Three years is a minimum, not a destruction deadline or maximum. Five years is permitted, but it is not the required minimum. The accessibility window is the first two years from creation, rather than any two later years. Catalog retained recordings by registered person and date.
Each recording keeps its own creation-based clock. At one year old, it needs at least two more years of retention, including one more year of easy access. Ending the separate three-year procedure-maintenance period does not shorten the retention period of recordings made later in the program.
The One-Time Staffing-Reduction Option (30 Days)
A member becoming a taping firm for the first time may reduce staffing below the applicable threshold within 30 days of the earlier of notice or actual knowledge. First-time eligibility cannot be saved for later: a firm that operated its first taping program without using reduction does not gain an unused reduction entitlement at a subsequent trigger.
An accidental crossing is not an eligibility condition. Planned hiring that creates a firm's first taping trigger does not itself bar reduction relief. The firm must still meet the actual timing, staffing, written-notice and rehire conditions.
| Element | Detail |
|---|---|
| Window | 30 days from the earlier of notice or actual knowledge |
| Mechanism | Reduce staffing below the applicable threshold; recalculate both headcount and qualifying persons |
| Written status notice | Promptly notify the regulator's Department of Member Regulation in writing of becoming subject to the rule |
| Terminated-person notice | Identify the terminated persons in writing on or before the actual reduction |
| No-rehire bar | Persons terminated to accomplish the reduction cannot be rehired for 180 days |
| Availability | First-time taping firms only; reduction and exceptional exemption cannot be combined for the current trigger |
Merely lowering the qualifying count is insufficient. Three qualifying persons among six total become two among five after one qualifying termination. The resulting 40% still meets the five-to-nine-person trigger, so that reduction does not obtain relief. Four qualifying persons among twelve total become three among eleven after one qualifying termination, falling below the middle-band trigger of four.
Use the size band after the reduction. A firm with ten registered persons, including four qualifying persons, moves into the five-to-nine band when one person leaves. If that person is nonqualifying, four among nine is about 44.4% and still triggers. If that person is qualifying, three among nine is about 33.3% and falls below the 40% trigger. The timing, written-notice and rehire conditions still apply.
Exceptional exemption remains a separate route for any taping firm. Submit a written application within 30 days of the earlier of notice or actual knowledge. The regulator considers relevant factors and may grant unconditional relief or specified terms and conditions. Filing alone is not a grant. Prior taping or reduction does not permanently bar a later exceptional exemption, but a firm cannot seek current relief by both first-time reduction and an exemption application.
Without applicable relief, the firm must meet the taping duties and the original 60-day deadline to establish and implement procedures. Later notice or a late reduction does not restart that deadline.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- First-time reduction requires timely action and both written notices; identify terminated persons on or before reduction.
- Recalculate both headcount and qualifying persons: the result must fall below the applicable threshold.
- The 180-day rehire restriction applies to persons terminated to accomplish reduction; a later exceptional exemption remains possible.
BrokerCheck Disclosure
A member's BrokerCheck report publicly identifies whether it is subject to the Taping Rule. Official guidance explains that the alert informs investors of heightened procedures and may encourage closer research into a broker's background. It does not guarantee the member's practices or investments, and it does not make the firm's recordings publicly available.
Public disclosure and member advertising are separate. Omitting status from a printed brochure does not remove accurate information from BrokerCheck. Eligible parties may dispute alleged factual inaccuracies through a written notice with available supporting documentation; unfavorable business reactions do not make accurate information false.
Separate website requirements call for a readily apparent BrokerCheck reference and hyperlink on the initial retail-investor page and on member webpages profiling registered persons who conduct retail business. Exceptions cover members providing no retail products or services and directories limited to names and contact details. This is not a requirement that every printed promotion reproduce a BrokerCheck report.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Taping-firm status is publicly disclosed on BrokerCheck.
How the Rule Pieces Fit Together
| Element | Detail |
|---|---|
| Trigger | Qualifying disciplined-firm associations within three years meet the size-based threshold using current registered-person counts |
| Substantive obligation | Tape all customer telephone calls; WSPs; periodic review; quarterly FINRA reports; cataloging |
| Procedure period | Established and implemented within 60 days; maintained 3 years from implementation |
| Retention | 3 years (first 2 easily accessible) |
| Reduction relief | First-time only; below threshold within 30 days of the earlier trigger, with required written notices and the 180-day person-specific rehire bar |
| Exceptional exemption | Separate written application within 30 days of the earlier trigger; conditional or unconditional relief may be granted |
| Public disclosure | BrokerCheck flag |
Recording, review and required reports are supervisory duties; public status disclosure helps investors research the firm. A BrokerCheck alert or member website does not substitute for implementing the required recording program.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you state the three concentration thresholds by firm size, and which size band uses an absolute count instead of a percentage?
- Do you know the tape retention period, how many of those years must be easily accessible, and how long the special procedures must stay in place?
- Can you distinguish first-time reduction eligibility, its notice and rehire conditions, and the separate exceptional-exemption route?
- Do you know that taping-firm status is publicly disclosed on BrokerCheck rather than kept confidential?