Payments to Unregistered Persons

Quick Answer

A member or associated person cannot compensate someone who is unregistered but required to register as a broker-dealer because of the payments and related activities. The firm must reasonably support and record its registration determination. Continuing commissions for retiring representatives and initial-referral compensation for qualifying foreign finders have separate conditions. These arrangements do not waive federal registration requirements.

The analysis turns on the recipient's activities and compensation, not just a job title or payment label. A payment outside the two conditional arrangements is not automatically prohibited: the firm must assess whether registration is required and whether other applicable requirements are satisfied.


The General Prohibition

No member or associated person (AP) may, directly or indirectly, pay any compensation, fees, concessions, discounts, commissions, or other allowances to any person that is not registered as a broker-dealer under the SEA's broker-dealer registration requirement but is, by reason of the payments and related activities, required to be registered.

Payments to an appropriately registered associated person must also comply with applicable federal securities laws, SEC rules, and FINRA rules. Registration alone does not make every payment permissible.

The rule's supplementary material places the work on the member firm. FINRA expects the firm to:

  • Make a determination that the proposed activities would not require the recipient to register as a broker-dealer
  • Reasonably support the determination. A firm that is uncertain can draw support from, among other things:
    • Previously published releases, no-action letters, or interpretations from the SEC or its staff that apply to the firm's facts and circumstances
    • A no-action letter that the firm seeks from SEC staff
    • A legal opinion from independent, reputable U.S.-licensed counsel knowledgeable in the area
  • Keep the determination reasonable under the circumstances. It should be reviewed periodically if payments are ongoing
  • Maintain books and records that reflect the determination

These support methods are nonexclusive. Under the published-authority approach, the firm may use advice from in-house or foreign counsel to apply relevant SEC guidance. A separate outside legal opinion is not universally required. A factual questionnaire may inform the firm's analysis; a recipient's bare claim that registration is unnecessary does not replace a reasonably supported member determination.

For ongoing payments, annual review generally would be reasonable absent red flags in the recipient's activities. This is not a universal annual deadline. Changed activities can require earlier attention to keep the determination reasonable. The firm must keep records reflecting its determination, even when no new outside opinion is needed.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A favorable letter must fit the actual arrangement; payment form alone does not determine whether registration is required.
  • Indirect and non-cash compensation can fall within the prohibition when the unregistered recipient must register.

Retiring Representative Continuing Commissions

A retiring registered representative retires from the member and leaves the securities industry, including retirement due to total disability. Unrelated work outside the securities industry is not automatically disqualifying. A member may pay continuing commissions derived from accounts held for that representative's continuing customers when the following conditions are satisfied.

#Precondition
1A bona fide payment contract with that member, entered in good faith while the person was its registered representative
2The contract prohibits the retiree from soliciting new business, opening new accounts, or servicing the accounts generating the continuing commissions
3The arrangement complies with applicable federal securities laws and SEC rules

What "Bona Fide" and "Continuing" Mean

  • Bona fide means the contract was entered for a legitimate business purpose, not as a pretext for paying compensation to an unregistered person who will keep doing broker activity informally
  • The rule permits continuing commissions regardless of whether funds or securities are added to continuing customers' accounts during retirement. New activity handled by a registered successor does not by itself defeat a qualifying arrangement
  • Servicing the payment-generating accounts includes recommending reallocations, discussing specific investment decisions with customers, or directing the successor's decisions for those accounts. Mere internal meeting attendance, scheduling, or social thanks does not establish those activities

Conditional SEC Staff Relief

The SEC staff's retirement no-action position has its own conditions, including written conduct acknowledgments, a commission-sharing term of no more than five years, specified tenure and conduct standards, industry separation, and annual certifications and customer checks. Those conditions apply when using that particular route. They are not universal tenure or duration requirements in FINRA's retirement paragraph.

Related staff relief permits compensation on new accounts opened by continuing customers, as well as new money, when the firm, retiree, and receiving representative satisfy the specified conditions. It does not permit the retiree to open accounts. Both staff responses concern conditional enforcement positions, not legal conclusions or approval under FINRA rules.

Death of the Retiring Rep

After the retiree dies, the beneficiary designated in the written contract, or the estate if none is designated, may receive the agreement's benefits. This identifies permitted beneficiaries; it does not create payments the contract never provides. Beneficiary status alone grants no right to access customer accounts or service them.

The order matters. The rule looks to the contract first. The estate, and so the will, comes into play only when the contract names no beneficiary. A will does not replace a beneficiary the written contract already names.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The bona fide contract must be formed with the member while the retiree is its registered representative.
  • A registered successor does not cure the retiree servicing accounts that generate continuing commissions.

Foreign Finders

A member may pay a non-registered foreign finder transaction-related compensation based on the business of customers the finder directs to the member, provided all seven of the following conditions are met.

#Condition
1The member has assured itself that the finder is not required to register in the U.S. as a broker-dealer, is not subject to a disqualification under FINRA's By-Laws, and that the compensation arrangement does not violate applicable foreign law
2The finder is a foreign national (not a U.S. citizen) or a foreign entity domiciled abroad
3The customers are foreign nationals (not U.S. citizens) or foreign entities domiciled abroad, transacting in foreign or U.S. securities
4The customers receive a descriptive document, similar to the document specified by the former adviser cash-solicitation provision, that discloses the compensation being paid to finders
5The customers give the member a written acknowledgment of the compensation arrangement, which the member retains and makes available for FINRA inspection
6The member keeps records of payments to finders on its books, and the finder agreements are available for FINRA inspection
7Each transaction confirmation states that a referral or finder's fee is being paid under an agreement

The Finder's Own Activities

FINRA's foreign-finder guidance limits the arrangement to the initial referral of qualifying non-U.S. customers and the ongoing transaction-related compensation arising from that referred business. The referred accounts must be carried on the member's books, and the member must maintain reasonable procedures for the arrangement's limited scope.

A finder that takes or relays orders, recommends securities, or performs other activities beyond the initial referral cannot rely on this exception for compensation for those additional activities. The member must separately determine whether the activities require U.S. broker-dealer registration; the disclosure and acknowledgment conditions do not expand the exception.

Customer Acknowledgment

The customer must acknowledge in writing that the finder is being compensated. This acknowledgment serves both the customer-protection purpose (the customer knows the finder has a financial interest) and the firm-protection purpose (the firm has documentation that the customer was informed).

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Both finder and customer must meet the applicable foreign-national or foreign-entity criteria.
  • The member must also assure itself about U.S. registration, disqualification and applicable foreign law; the other finder conditions remain.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you state the three preconditions for paying continuing commissions to a retiring registered representative?
  • Can you distinguish a contract formed while the person was that member's registered representative from an agreement first formed after departure?
  • Can you list the seven foreign-finder conditions, including the two that concern the finder itself?
  • Do you know how a firm can reasonably support its determination that an unregistered recipient need not register, that it should review the determination periodically while payments are ongoing, and that it must keep records of it?