Margin Requirements for Credit Default Swaps

Quick Answer

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) security-based-swap margin framework covers members that are not registered security-based swap dealers. Subject to exceptions, cleared swaps use clearing-agency margin. For uncleared accounts, compute initial margin and current exposure by counterparty, collect any initial-margin deficit, and collect or deliver variation margin accordingly. Qualifying same-counterparty combinations differ from firm-wide netting.

The current framework covers security-based swaps (SBS), including qualifying credit default swaps (CDS). It replaced the temporary CDS-only pilot. A member registered as a security-based swap dealer instead follows the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) margin framework specified for those dealers.

Qualifying derivatives in portfolio-margin accounts and swaps carried in specified authorized commodity accounts can fall under separate exceptions. A general election to net every equity and swap position across the firm is not one of those exceptions. Apply the actual account, product and authorization conditions.


What CDS Are

A basic single-name credit default swap exchanges a fixed payment or periodic payments for a payment triggered by specified credit events affecting a reference entity, such as bankruptcy or payment default. Settlement can involve cash or payment against delivery of eligible obligations. A basic narrow-based-index CDS consists of multiple component basic single-name CDS.

The party buying protection pays for the credit-event protection; the seller takes the corresponding payment obligation. The margin treatment below addresses these products within the security-based-swap framework.

A CDS is a derivative, not an insurance policy. It pays on a credit event without any proof of the buyer's loss, as noted below. The Securities Exchange Act provides that a security-based swap may not be regulated as an insurance contract under any provision of State law. A broker-dealer therefore issues no insurance policies through its CDS book. This does not mean a state has no authority of any kind: State antifraud laws of general applicability still apply.

The protection buyer need not own the referenced debt. A bondholder can use protection to hedge owned debt, while an otherwise eligible investor without that debt can take a credit position. Payments follow the contract's credit-event and settlement terms; they do not require proof of the buyer's individual bond loss or guarantee reimbursement of that loss. A hedge can therefore leave a residual loss.


Cleared vs. Uncleared: The Core Distinction

For a covered member, distinguish the cleared treatment from the standard uncleared-account computations, then check applicable exceptions:

CDS TypeWho Sets the Margin
Cleared CDSThe clearing agency through which it is cleared sets the margin requirement, subject to applicable exceptions
Uncleared CDSThe member computes current exposure and initial margin for each counterparty's uncleared account, then collects or delivers amounts as required

For a cleared CDS, FINRA adopts the clearing agency's margin requirement rather than imposing the uncleared-account calculation as a second FINRA layer on the same cleared swap. This distinction does not establish a general prohibition on higher firm requirements.

For uncleared CDS, the standard method applies by counterparty account. An account includes all uncleared swaps between the member and that counterparty, together with the specified margin balances. Do not replace that account analysis with the member's aggregate exposure across unrelated counterparties.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • First identify the member’s regulatory status, whether the swap is cleared, and whether an exception applies.

The Uncleared-CDS Margin Framework

For a covered, non-exempt uncleared account, the member computes current exposure and an initial-margin requirement as of the close of business each business day:

Margin TypeSubstance
Initial marginAddresses potential future exposure; collect collateral with value at least equal to any initial-margin deficit
Variation marginAddresses current exposure; collect from the counterparty when the member has exposure, or deliver to the counterparty when the exposure runs the other way

The initial-margin deficit accounts for initial collateral already held and the counterparty's qualifying excess in its margin account. A requirement to compute both categories does not mean that a positive amount of both must always be collected on every individual contract.

How Margin Is Computed

For a basic uncleared CDS, initial margin uses the prescribed net-capital haircut method. That method uses contract maturity, credit spread and notional amount, with specified treatment of protection bought or sold and qualifying offsets. It is not an unrestricted firm-selected exposure model.

For standalone protection sold, the same current spread and maturity categories produce the same haircut percentage. With no offsets or higher firm requirements, applying that percentage to $50 million rather than $10 million notional produces five times the computed initial-margin requirement. The deficit to collect also depends on qualifying collateral already held and margin-account excess; it need not increase in the same proportion.

Specified combinations of basic CDS and securities may receive combined initial-margin treatment when covered by a legally enforceable netting or collateral agreement with the counterparty and the other requirements are satisfied. Positions cannot be counted in more than one such combination. Permitted combinations within one counterparty relationship do not authorize netting unrelated counterparties together.

Current exposure uses the account's net swap value, adjusted for variation margin already collected or delivered and not returned or applied. Its direction determines whether the member must collect or deliver variation margin. It is an account computation rather than a separate gross payment on every contract.

Required collection or delivery must occur as promptly as possible and no later than the close of business on the next business day after the computation date. Unless FINRA grants additional time, failure to collect required margin by the close of the third business day requires prompt steps to liquidate enough positions to eliminate the deficiency.

When variation margin must be delivered or returned while initial margin must be collected, the member must net those opposed flows. When variation margin must be collected and initial margin may be returned, the member may net that permitted return against the collection. A return or withdrawal must not create or increase an initial-margin deficit.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • For a covered uncleared account, amounts and direction depend on the initial-margin deficit and current exposure.

Exceptions and Supervisory Checks

Exceptions have specific predicates; they are not a blanket waiver for a creditworthy customer. Examples include:

  • Clearing agencies: the rule does not require the member to deliver variation margin to, or collect initial or variation margin from, a clearing agency
  • Financial market intermediaries: variation-margin duties remain; the member may omit initial-margin collection if it takes the specified net-capital deduction
  • Certain sovereign counterparties: qualifying minimal-credit-risk determinations can permit the specified initial-margin treatment, with a net-capital deduction; variation-margin duties remain
  • Specified legacy swaps and other counterparties: other exceptions have contractual, counterparty and capital-treatment conditions that must be checked before omitting collection

The member must monitor uncleared-account risks and maintain a comprehensive written risk analysis methodology. That includes documenting enforceability of netting or collateral agreements, monitoring exposure by counterparty and in the aggregate, stress testing, and considering higher margin for concentration, volatility or other risks.

Recommendation review and margin calculation serve distinct purposes. Where customer-specific suitability applies, evaluate the customer's investment profile, including financial situation, objectives, experience, liquidity needs and risk tolerance; demographics alone are insufficient. Basic-CDS initial margin uses the prescribed haircut method. Separate assessments of additional margin can consider counterparty creditworthiness and contract risk. Satisfying margin does not establish that a recommendation fits the customer.

Extreme volatility requires more frequent current-exposure and initial-margin calculations. Unusually volatile positions also call for assessing the need for higher firm margin. A stable current account value does not remove those duties. Volatility alone does not automatically change the prescribed basic-CDS haircut percentage when the applicable spread and maturity categories and position treatment are unchanged. Market stress reaches the haircut only through the swap's own current spread: if that spread moves into a wider band of the prescribed table, the percentage rises.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A small firm-wide net exposure does not erase counterparty-account duties; qualifying same-counterparty combinations and exceptions have conditions.

Where the CDS-Margin Requirement Fits in the Margin Framework

Security-based-swap margin has defined links to conventional margin accounts, including permitted combinations and qualifying account exceptions. Those links do not create an unrestricted election to combine all products and unrelated counterparties into one firm-wide figure.

A member must apply the framework appropriate to its regulatory status, products and accounts. A net-capital haircut used to compute basic CDS initial margin does not automatically replace collateral collection from every counterparty; any capital-charge alternative must satisfy the applicable exception.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you distinguish a covered non-dealer member from a registered security-based swap dealer?
  • Can you distinguish clearing-agency margin from uncleared counterparty-account computations?
  • Can you determine when an initial-margin deficit and current exposure require collection, and when variation margin must instead be delivered?
  • Can you distinguish permitted same-counterparty combinations from unrelated firm-wide netting?
  • Can you identify the applicable collection deadline and check a claimed exception before allowing margin to be omitted?