Quick Answer
A covered member must notify FINRA promptly in writing, within 24 hours, for specified capital conditions, including ordinary dollar capital below 150% of minimum. Unless FINRA permits otherwise in writing, specified continuing conditions restrict expansion or require reduction after more than 15 consecutive business days, known to FINRA or the member for at least five consecutive business days.
Notification, restrictions on expansion and business reduction are separate duties. Filing a notice does not by itself impose every restriction, and the absence of a FINRA order does not excuse a restriction that applies under the continuing-condition provisions.
Who Is Covered?
The carrying or clearing provisions apply to members that carry customer accounts or clear transactions. Either activity can put a member in scope. The rule also covers a firm using the specified customer-protection exemption if it clears customer transactions under that exemption or holds customer funds in the required special bank account.
Security-based swap exposure matters too. The financial and operational rules apply their carrying or clearing requirements to a member that acts as principal counterparty to a security-based swap, clears or carries one, guarantees one or otherwise has financial exposure to one. A firm cannot establish that it is outside these requirements merely by calling itself an introducing firm.
A fully disclosed introducing firm that does not carry or clear, does not hold customer funds in the specified special bank account and does not have the relevant swap exposure does not acquire the carrying-firm requirement simply from introducing accounts. Assess its actual activities and other applicable requirements.
Scope turns on what the firm does with customer accounts and customer funds. It does not turn on how much of the firm's own net capital it holds. A firm outside the FINRA requirement still has its own net capital measured by the SEC warning tests, which apply to every broker-dealer.
The Notification Duty
For the ordinary dollar-minimum trigger, compare actual net capital with 150% of the minimum dollar requirement. The duty is to notify FINRA promptly, in writing, and in any event within 24 hours. The 24 hours are an outer limit, not permission to postpone a notice that can be given promptly.
FINRA may designate a greater percentage for this dollar test. The examples below assume it has not done so.
A carrying firm with a $250,000 minimum reaches the FINRA notification trigger below $375,000:
- $250,000 × 150% = $375,000.
- Exactly $375,000 does not meet this particular below test.
- Below $300,000 meets the ordinary SEC 120% warning test as well.
- Below $250,000 is a minimum-capital deficiency and requires same-day SEC notice.
The 150% dollar test is not the only FINRA notification trigger. Other prescribed tests cover aggregate indebtedness, the alternative method, specialized capital regimes, futures commission merchants and specified prospective capital withdrawals.
For an ordinary firm using the aggregate-indebtedness standard, FINRA notification is triggered above 1,000% of net capital; the separate SEC ratio warning uses 1,200%. Do not apply the dollar-minimum ladder to every ratio or specialized firm.
Separate Capital Measures
The ordinary alternative-standard notification test is net capital below 5% of aggregate debit items. Its automatic reduction condition is below 4%, one percentage point lower. These percentages measure debit items, rather than the firm's minimum dollar requirement.
For a futures commission merchant, the FINRA notification condition is net capital below 120% of its minimum risk-based capital requirement. Its automatic reduction condition is below 110% of that requirement. These are different from the SEC's ordinary 120%-of-minimum dollar warning.
An approved alternative-net-capital firm has separate tentative-capital and net-capital tests. Its FINRA tentative-capital notification condition is below 150% of the required minimum tentative amount. Its reduction condition uses the separately prescribed tentative-capital warning amount. The old fixed net-capital floor and old fraction-of-warning test must not be substituted for these amended measures.
For these approved firms, net-capital notification can use one-tenth of aggregate indebtedness plus 150% of the applicable additional capital component, or the alternative-standard notification level plus that 150% component. Reduction uses one-twelfth plus 125%, or one percentage point below the alternative notification level plus that 125% component. Use the prescribed component for the firm's applicable capital category.
Registered security-based swap dealers subject to the specified broker-dealer capital regime have corresponding net-capital formulas using their own prescribed additional component. A member can have swap exposure that extends the carrying-firm requirements without being registered as a swap dealer. Scope and specialized capital calculation are separate questions.
Anticipated voluntary or committed withdrawals, including subordinated-liability maturities during the next six months, and specified special deductions can trigger notification if deducting them would create a notification condition. The automatic reduction provision separately tests scheduled next-six-month withdrawals and deductions against its deeper conditions. A firm must not wait for an anticipated withdrawal to occur before assessing the notice test.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Identify the authority, firm category and capital measure; notification, expansion restrictions and reduction obligations have different conditions.
When Expansion Is Restricted
Unless FINRA otherwise permits in writing, a member that carries customer accounts or clears transactions may not expand while a specified notification condition continues for more than 15 consecutive business days, provided it has been known to FINRA or the member for at least five consecutive business days.
The two tests can run together. The rule does not require five days of knowledge followed by a separate 15-day waiting period.
| Test | What must be established |
|---|---|
| Continued condition | More than 15 consecutive business days |
| Knowledge | FINRA or the member has known for at least five consecutive business days |
| Written relief | No applicable written FINRA permission allowing the proposed expansion |
For example, a qualifying condition that has continued for 20 consecutive business days and been known to the member throughout satisfies both time tests. Without applicable written permission, the firm cannot avoid the restriction by pointing out that FINRA has not issued a separate order.
At Day 8, the continuation test has not been met. That answers only whether this automatic provision applies; it does not establish that every proposed expansion is otherwise authorized.
What Counts as Expansion?
Examples specified by the rule include:
- A net increase in registered representatives or other producing personnel.
- Capital commitments for market making, block positioning or underwriting above the relevant prior three-month averages.
- Starting market making in new securities or specified new proprietary commitments, subject to the stated riskless-trade exception.
- Opening new branch offices.
- Starting a new line of business or deliberately expanding an existing one.
- Making unsecured or partially secured loans, advances or similar receivables.
The receivables example also includes drawings and guarantees. The proprietary-commitment example excludes the specified riskless trades associated with customer orders; this exception does not exempt every trade involving a customer.
The examples are not a complete list. Assess the actual restriction and proposed activity. A replacement hire is not necessarily a net increase; old onboarding paperwork is not a blanket exemption; and a fixed baseline for every firm's account count or transaction volume is not prescribed by these examples.
An expansion restriction does not itself require all existing operations to stop. The firm must still comply with any separate capital, customer-protection, reduction or other restrictions that apply.
FINRA's Separate Direction
FINRA can restrict expansion for any financial or operational reason through the prescribed notice process. A member may not expand while that restriction applies. This route does not depend on the automatic provision's five-day and more-than-15-day tests.
FINRA may also issue a notice directing compliance with the automatic provision. Its power to send that notice does not make a separate order a prerequisite to the member's own obligation.
Examples supporting FINRA's independent discretion include risky changes in processing, deficient books and records, inability to comply or demonstrate capital or customer-protection compliance, failure to clear and settle promptly, and other overall financial or operational difficulty. This power is not confined to a dollar-capital breach. Restrictions on a carrying or clearing firm can also require limits on the correspondent business it handles.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Knowledge by FINRA or the member counts; distinguish the automatic restriction from a separate FINRA direction.
When Business Must Be Reduced
Business reduction is not limited to a discretionary request from FINRA staff. Unless FINRA permits otherwise in writing, a carrying or clearing member must reduce its business when a specified deeper capital condition persists for more than 15 consecutive business days and has been known to FINRA or the member for at least five consecutive business days.
For the ordinary dollar-minimum test, the reduction condition is net capital below 125% of the minimum dollar requirement, or a greater percentage designated by FINRA. Other tests address aggregate indebtedness, the alternative method, specialized firms and specified capital withdrawals. The required reduction must enable available capital to exceed the applicable notification standards; merely returning above the lower reduction trigger does not describe the full obligation.
For an aggregate-indebtedness firm, the automatic reduction condition is indebtedness over 1,200% of net capital, distinct from FINRA's 1,000% notification condition. The same more-than-15-day continuation and at-least-five-day knowledge conditions apply, subject to written FINRA permission. The knowledge and continuation periods can run together.
FINRA can separately direct reduction for any financial or operational reason through the prescribed notice process. That direction has its own force and does not wait for the automatic time tests.
Depending on the circumstances, reduction can include:
- Reducing inventory or market-making activity.
- Closing branch offices or introducing business to another firm on a fully disclosed basis.
- Returning customer free credit balances or delivering fully paid securities promptly.
- Collecting unsecured receivables.
- Accepting no new accounts or only unsolicited orders.
- Restricting specified payments to owners, officers or associated persons.
Market making appears in both lists, with a different job in each. In the expansion list, market-making capital commitments above the prior three-month average are a limit on growth. In the reduction list, FINRA can direct a firm to reduce or cease market making. Underwriting commitments are named only in the expansion list; the reduction list is open, so FINRA can still direct a cut there.
The payment example includes salaries or other sums to partners, officers, directors, shareholders or associated persons. Reduction can also include liquidating or closing customer or proprietary transactions.
The list ends with a catch-all for such other activities as FINRA deems appropriate in the public interest or for the protection of investors. A measure the list does not name, such as a cap on daily trading activity, can therefore still be directed. These examples are open: they do not categorically exclude branch expenses or other measures merely because someone labels them general overhead.
For a $250,000-minimum firm, 125% is $312,500. If net capital is $310,000 and the required time and knowledge conditions are met, the dollar-based reduction obligation can apply even though capital remains above the ordinary SEC 120% warning level of $300,000. Do not assume reduction must wait until capital falls below the SEC warning or minimum.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Expansion restriction limits growth; reduction shrinks activity. Both can apply without a minimum-capital breach.
Comparing the Ordinary Dollar Tests
The following comparison concerns a firm with an ordinary $250,000 minimum and no designated higher percentage. It does not replace the separate ratio, specialized-firm or operational provisions.
| Capital condition | Dollar boundary | Relevant consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Below 150% of minimum | Below $375,000 | Prompt written FINRA notice, no later than 24 hours; expansion restriction if its additional conditions are met |
| Below 125% of minimum | Below $312,500 | Business reduction if its additional conditions are met, unless FINRA permits otherwise in writing |
| Below 120% of minimum | Below $300,000 | Prompt SEC early-warning notice, within 24 hours |
| Below the required minimum | Below $250,000 | Same-day SEC capital-deficiency notice |
Each is a below test. Exactly reaching a boundary does not trigger that particular test, although another applicable test or FINRA direction may still apply.
SEC Notices Have Their Own Scope
SEC capital notices go to the prescribed Commission offices or published email address and the firm's designated examining authority. A broker-dealer also registered as a futures commission merchant must include the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. The SEC framework distinguishes broker-dealers, specialized derivatives firms and firms subject to the separate security-based swap notification regime; the same rule does not apply to every swap entity.
Other SEC notice events include the prescribed aggregate-indebtedness and alternative-standard tests, backtesting exceptions and securities-financing leverage. Failure to make and keep required books and records current requires same-day notice plus a corrective report within 48 hours of that notice. A discovered or accountant-reported material inadequacy or weakness uses 24-hour notice, then a corrective report within 48 hours of notice. These are distinct clocks.
Failure to make the required security-based swap customer reserve deposit requires immediate written notice. These additional duties do not convert every 150% FINRA warning into a minimum-capital deficiency, nor does a FINRA filing discharge an independent SEC notice obligation.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Have you identified the firm's actual activities, including relevant customer-fund handling and security-based swap exposure?
- Can you apply the knowledge and continuation tests together, with FINRA's written-permission exception?
- Does the question concern the automatic provision or a separate FINRA direction?
- Can you distinguish the 150% notification condition, 125% ordinary reduction condition and SEC 120% warning, without treating them as the only possible triggers?
- Are you assessing actual business expansion rather than assuming every hire or old contract determines the result?