Quick Answer
FINRA content standards require every communication to rest on fair dealing and good faith, be fair and balanced, and give a sound basis for evaluating facts about any security, industry, or service, with no false, exaggerated, unwarranted, promissory, or misleading statements and no omission of material facts. Strict limits apply to performance projections, testimonials, hyperlinks, and public-appearance statements.
The content standards are the substance layer of communications regulation. Classification tells the firm how to handle a piece of content; the content standards tell the firm what the content can say. A piece that clears classification and approval but fails the content test still violates the communications framework.
The General Standards
The general communications standard requires every communication, regardless of category, to satisfy four general standards:
- Principles of fair dealing and good faith: communications cannot mislead, deceive, or take advantage of investor naïveté
- Fair and balanced: any presentation of benefits must be balanced with a discussion of risks; any selective performance comparison must include the appropriate counterpoint
- Sound basis for evaluation: enough information must be provided that the recipient can evaluate the facts about the security, industry, or service
- Nature of the audience: details and explanations appropriate for an institutional audience may not be suitable for retail; the firm must consider who is reading
In addition, the standards explicitly prohibit:
- False, exaggerated, unwarranted, promissory, or misleading statements or claims
- Omission of material facts or qualifications, if the omission would render the communication misleading
- Implications that the firm's services are guaranteed, certain, or superior to others without a factual basis
Think of it this way: The general standards are a balanced-presentation rule. Anything you say about an investment must be paired with the relevant context that a reasonable investor would need to evaluate the claim.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Audience matters: an institutional explanation may mislead retail investors.
- True statements can mislead through omission of material context.
Performance Projections and Forecasts
Communications generally may not predict or project investment performance, imply that past performance will recur, or make exaggerated or unwarranted forecasts. Adding assumptions, methodology or risk disclosures does not create a general exception for a strategy's target return range. Disclosures also do not cure an unsupported promise of certain market returns.
The current rule lists three exceptions:
- Mathematical illustrations that demonstrate principles without predicting the performance of an investment or strategy
- Investment-analysis tools or their written reports that meet the applicable tool requirements
- Price targets in debt or equity research reports with a reasonable basis, disclosed valuation methods and accompanying risks that may impede achievement
A research price target is distinct from a general advertised target return for a fund or strategy. The target's supporting analysis and disclosures matter; calling a number a target does not by itself create an exception.
Investment-Analysis Tools
A qualifying tool is interactive technology that produces simulations and statistical analyses of the likelihood of investment outcomes. For the tool, its written output reports and related retail communications, the requirements include:
- Criteria and methodology, including limitations and key assumptions
- An explanation that results may vary with each use and over time
- Where applicable, the investment universe, selection method, whether and why securities are favored, and the possibility of similar or superior omitted investments
- The prescribed hypothetical-results disclosure stating that the modeled outcomes do not reflect actual investment results and are not guarantees of future results
Required information must be clear and prominent, in written narrative form, which may be electronic. A boilerplate disclaimer or probability label does not establish compliance. The tool and its communications must also satisfy the other applicable content standards.
An incidental reference that merely mentions the tool as an available service need not carry the tool disclosures. A more detailed retail description that provides neither access nor results must include the variability and prescribed hypothetical-results disclosures, but may omit the methodology and investment-selection disclosures.
Hypothetical or back-tested investment performance is not generally permitted merely because it has context and disclaimers. Check an actual applicable exception and its conditions. A mathematical illustration must avoid predicting investment or strategy performance.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Disclaimers do not cure unsupported guarantees; research price targets have a distinct conditional exception.
- Investment-analysis tools and related communications must meet their applicable methodology, variability and hypothetical-results requirements.
Testimonials
Retail communications and correspondence using testimonials about a member's investment advice or investment performance must prominently disclose:
- The testimonial may not represent other customers' experience
- The testimonial does not guarantee future performance or success
- The testimonial is paid, when more than $100 in value is paid for it
The payment provision requires disclosure of paid status, rather than the exact amount. A testimonial about a technical aspect of investing also requires its provider to have the knowledge and experience to form a valid opinion.
A related testimonial-advertising framework applies to SEC-registered investment advisers under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. For broker-dealers, the FINRA content standards control.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Testimonial disclosures cover investment advice as well as performance; paid status is disclosed when payment exceeds $100 in value.
Comparisons With Other Firms or Products
Comparisons of the firm's services with those of other entities are permitted only if material differences are disclosed. A side-by-side fee table that omits the comparator's superior service offering, or that omits the firm's higher minimum, can be misleading by omission.
The same standard applies to comparisons of:
- Investment products (one fund versus another)
- Performance histories
- Service models (full-service versus discount, advisory versus brokerage)
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Comparisons must disclose material differences, including those unfavorable to the firm.
Hyperlinks and Adopted Content
A firm is responsible for the content of a hyperlink in its communication if the firm has adopted or become entangled with the linked content. The adoption-and-entanglement test asks:
- Did the firm endorse, approve, or vouch for the linked content?
- Did the firm prepare or contribute to the linked content (entanglement)?
- Did the firm link to it as if the content reflects the firm's view?
Pure factual references (a link to the SEC's website for a public filing, a link to a prospectus on the issuer's site) generally do not implicate adoption. A link to a third-party blog post that touts the firm's services, presented as if endorsed, is adopted content.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Linked content is assessed for adoption or entanglement; adopted material must satisfy applicable content standards.
Recommendations and Past Recommendations
A retail communication that recommends a security must have a reasonable basis and must disclose, if applicable:
- That the member was making a market in the security, or will buy from or sell to customers as principal
- That the member, or an associated person directly and materially involved in preparing the content, has a non-nominal financial interest in the issuer's securities, and its nature
- That the member was manager or co-manager of a public offering of the issuer's securities within the past 12 months
The member must also provide, or offer to furnish on request, available investment information supporting the recommendation. For a corporate equity security, it must give the price at the time of the recommendation.
Past Specific Recommendations
A retail communication or correspondence may not refer to past specific recommendations that were or would have been profitable. It may instead set out, or offer to furnish, a list of all the member's recommendations of the same type, kind, grade, or classification of securities from the immediately preceding period of not less than one year.
The list must state each security's name, the date and nature of each recommendation (buy, sell, or hold), the market price then, the price at which it was to be acted on, and the most recent practicable market price.
The list must also carry this legend prominently: "it should not be assumed that recommendations made in the future will be profitable or will equal the performance of the securities in this list."
These recommendation provisions do not apply to a research report that includes the disclosures the research rules require. The disclosure and past-recommendation provisions also do not apply to a communication recommending only registered investment companies or variable insurance products, which still needs a reasonable basis.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- A past-recommendation list must include all recommendations of the same type over the required period, with prices and the cautionary legend.
Public Appearances
The communications content standards extend to statements made by an associated person in a public appearance (interview, seminar, webinar, conference). The same fair, balanced, not-misleading standard applies. A registered representative recommending a security also must satisfy these duties:
- A reasonable basis for the recommendation
- Disclosure of any non-nominal financial interest the representative has in the issuer's securities and the nature of that interest
- Disclosure of any other actual, material conflict of the representative or firm that the representative knows or has reason to know at the time of the appearance
A material firm ownership position, market-making relationship, or investment banking engagement can require disclosure under the material-conflict duty when the representative knows or has reason to know of it. The nominal-interest exception applies only to the representative's financial-interest disclosure, not to other actual, material conflicts. Failure to make a required disclosure violates the content standards independent of any approval or filing rule.
These two disclosure duties do not apply to recommendations of investment company securities or variable insurance products, or to research analyst appearances that include the required separate research disclosures. A reasonable basis remains required.
Think of it this way: Public-appearance content is governed by the same content standards as written content, but the approval and filing rules drop out. The substantive truth-and-disclosure rules stay.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- A representative’s lack of personal holdings does not eliminate disclosure of other known or reasonably known actual material conflicts.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you list the four general communication standards: fair dealing and good faith, fair and balanced, sound basis, and audience-appropriate?
- Can you identify the disclosures for a retail or correspondence testimonial about investment advice or performance: possible unrepresentativeness, no guarantee of future performance or success, and paid status when payment exceeds $100 in value?
- Can you state the adoption-and-entanglement test for hyperlink content: did the firm endorse, prepare, or link to it as its own view?
- Can you distinguish the non-nominal personal financial-interest disclosure from disclosure of other actual, material conflicts known or reasonably known to the representative?
- Do you know that a communication may cite past recommendations only through a list of all recommendations of that type from a period of at least one year, with prices and the cautionary legend?