Quick Answer
A firm with five to nine registered persons meets the taping threshold when 40% or more have qualifying disciplined-firm associations within three years. Apply the short-tenure exclusion and count the firm's total registered persons. Recalculate after staffing changes; exactly 40% is sufficient, and a staffing reduction can increase concentration.
The Taping Rule targets firms with qualifying concentrations of registered persons formerly associated with disciplined firms. Hiring and departures can change that concentration.
The required taping procedures cover all telephone conversations between the firm's registered persons and existing or potential customers. The recording population includes registered principals and people without qualifying disciplined-firm associations. Both incoming and outgoing conversations are covered.
When the Taping Rule Triggers
A firm meets the "taping firm" definition when its qualifying registered-person count or concentration reaches one of the following size-based thresholds. Equality counts; the percentage does not have to exceed the stated level.
| Firm Size (Registered Persons) | Threshold to Become a Taping Firm |
|---|---|
| 5 to 9 registered persons | At least 40% are from one or more disciplined firms |
| 10 to 19 registered persons | Four or more are from disciplined firms |
| 20 or more registered persons | At least 20% are from disciplined firms |
Use the firm's total registered-person headcount for the size band and denominator. In the disciplined-firm numerator, count registered associations within the last three years, but exclude a person with 90 days or less in aggregate at those firms and no qualifying regulatory violation findings within five years. Both conditions must be met. The excluded person remains in the firm's total headcount.
The reference point is the current concentration assessment. Examine the preceding three years of registered-capacity associations, rather than freezing the person's original hiring-date result. Departure dates locate the end of associations within or outside that window. Add tenure across disciplined firms within the window: sixty days at one and forty-five at another totals 105 days, exceeding the short-tenure limit.
Short tenure alone does not exclude someone with qualifying disciplinary history. For example, a Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) finding of unauthorized trading under the commercial-honor standard within five years qualifies as disciplinary history. A person with that finding and 90 days of disciplined-firm registration remains in the numerator.
Recalculate after staffing changes. A firm moving from two qualifying people among seven total to three among eight moves from about 28.6% to 37.5%, still below 40%. One further qualifying hire would make four of nine, about 44.4%. A departure also matters: removing one nonqualifying person from three among eight produces three of seven, about 42.9%.
The same denominator discipline applies at larger firms. Nineteen qualifying people among 100 total become twenty among 101 after a qualifying hire: about 19.8%, still below 20%. Ninety-nine among 500 become 100 among 501: about 19.96%, also below. One further qualifying hire produces 101 among 502, about 20.12%. Do not round a below-threshold concentration upward to establish status.
A "disciplined firm" meets one of three specified routes:
- A FINRA member, in connection with securities sales practices, is expelled from membership or participation in any securities industry self-regulatory organization, or is subject to a Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) order revoking broker-dealer registration.
- A futures commission merchant or introducing broker is formally charged by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission or a registered futures association with deceptive telemarketing practices or promotional material relating to security futures. The charges are resolved, and the firm is closed down and permanently barred from the futures industry as a result.
- A futures commission merchant or introducing broker is subject to an SEC order revoking registration as a broker or dealer in connection with sales practices involving security futures.
Complaints, investigations, ordinary fines, suspension and voluntary closure alone do not meet these events. An association with a prior employer lacking qualifying status does not contribute to the disciplined-firm numerator merely because that employer closed.
FINRA publishes a list of firms meeting the definition, described as firms disciplined within the last three years. The list is a checking aid; the actual disciplinary criteria govern. The rule's association lookback is a separate part of the staffing calculation.
FINRA notifies the firm when the threshold is crossed, or the firm has actual knowledge.
Think of it this way: Select the band from the current headcount, then apply its test. Five to nine uses 40% or more; ten to nineteen uses four qualifying people; twenty or more uses 20% or more. Moving from nineteen to twenty total registered persons switches from a fixed count to a percentage. The middle band has no universal 25% threshold.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Use the current three-year association window and qualifying disciplined-firm criteria; ordinary closure alone is insufficient.
- Apply the short-tenure and history exclusion, then the correct headcount band and threshold.
Taping-Firm Obligations Once Triggered
Once the Taping Rule triggers, the firm must:
- Establish and implement special written supervisory procedures within 60 days from the earlier of FINRA notice or actual knowledge of taping-firm status. Writing or approving the document alone is insufficient
- Maintain those special procedures for 3 years from the date the firm establishes and implements them
- Tape-record all telephone conversations between registered persons of the firm and existing or potential customers, including covered conversations on personal mobile phones
- Review the recordings for compliance with applicable rules (suitability, communications standards, anti-money laundering red flags, churning, unauthorized trading)
- File quarterly reports with FINRA by the 30th day of the month following each calendar quarter, describing the firm's supervision of its registered persons' telemarketing activities
The telephone-recording duty is not limited to recommendations, office landlines, or market hours. A registered principal who mainly works internally still has a covered conversation when speaking by telephone with a prospect about opening an account.
Covered calls must actually be captured. Routing through a recording system or restricting unrecordable business use can be controls; the provision does not prescribe one universal personal-device ban. Personal ownership does not exempt a covered call. A later signed device policy can guide future conduct but cannot retroactively supply missing recordings.
Digital recording is a method, not a broader communication category. The provision permits electronic or digital recordings that meet its requirements. It does not turn this specific telephone-recording duty into a requirement to tape emails. Other applicable supervision and recordkeeping duties still govern written messages.
The firm must maintain and enforce the procedures once they are in place. The 60-day period starts with the first trigger: FINRA notice or actual knowledge. Later notice does not restart a clock already running from knowledge.
Waiting for notice does not automatically establish a missed deadline. If notice arrives ten days after knowledge and the firm establishes and implements the procedures fifty days after knowledge, the timing is compliant. If it instead plans implementation sixty days after that notice, completion would be seventy days after knowledge and late.
Check the elapsed time and both establishment and implementation, rather than treating any waiting as a violation. These examples assume no applicable relief.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Record covered customer calls of all registered persons, not only qualifying hires.
- Establish and implement procedures within 60 days from the earlier of notice or knowledge; maintain them three years from establishment and implementation.
Retention of Recordings
Tape recordings are subject to a specific retention schedule:
- At least 3 years from the creation of each recording
- First 2 years in an easily accessible place
- Catalog retained recordings by registered person and date
FINRA can reach the recordings through its regulatory authority. In an examination or investigation, FINRA staff can inspect and copy a member's books and records that are in the member's possession, custody or control. FINRA does not buy the recordings, needs no court order, and does not go through the firm's clearing agent. The taping firm keeps the duty to retain, catalog and produce its own recordings.
Each recording has its own clock. Later review, updates to written procedures, or completion of the program's procedure-maintenance period do not restart or shorten that recording's retention period. An 18-month-old recording needs at least 18 more months of retention, including six more months of easy access.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Retain each recording at least three years from creation, first two easily accessible, and catalog by registered person and date.
The 30-Day Reduction Window
First-time eligibility cannot be saved for later. If a firm operated its first required taping program without using reduction relief, it cannot claim an unused reduction option when a later hiring change makes it a taping firm again.
A member becoming a taping firm for the first time may reduce staffing below the threshold within 30 days of the earlier of notice or actual knowledge. Later notice does not restart a clock already running from knowledge. Recalculate both headcount and qualifying persons after the terminations. A firm moving from four qualifying persons among twelve total to two among ten falls below the middle-band trigger of four.
The member must promptly notify the regulator's Department of Member Regulation in writing that it has become subject to the rule. It must also provide written identification of terminated persons on or before the reduction. An initial status notice does not replace that identification.
Persons terminated to accomplish the reduction cannot be rehired for 180 days, even if a proposed rehire would leave the firm below the threshold. This restriction applies to those terminated persons, not all possible new hires.
Exceptional exemption is a separate route. Any taping firm may file a written application within 30 days of the earlier of notice or actual knowledge. The regulator considers all relevant factors and may grant unconditional relief or specified terms and conditions. Filing alone is not a grant. Prior use of staffing reduction prevents repeating that first-time option, but does not permanently prevent an exceptional exemption on a later trigger. A firm cannot seek relief by both reducing under the first-time option and requesting an exemption.
Without applicable relief, the firm must meet the taping requirements, including the original 60-day deadline to establish and implement procedures. A late reduction or later notice does not restart that deadline.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- First-time reduction and exceptional exemption are separate relief routes.
- The earlier of notice or knowledge starts the 30-day window; identify terminated persons in writing on or before reduction.
Why This Rule Matters in the Communications Context
Recording and review supplement the firm's applicable telemarketing controls. They do not replace them.
- National do-not-call list: Apply the prohibition on covered outbound solicitation calls to listed numbers and the available exceptions for an established business relationship, signed written permission, or the caller's qualifying personal relationship. An error safe harbor requires implemented written procedures, trained personnel, a maintained list of numbers not to contact, and a documented prevention process using registry data obtained no more than 31 days before the call.
- Firm-specific do-not-call list: Record requests when received and honor them within a reasonable time, no later than 30 days. The national-list exceptions and error safe harbor do not excuse calls prohibited by the firm's own list. A firm-specific request also ends that firm's established-business-relationship exception to the national list.
- Calling hours: Apply the restriction on outbound solicitation calls to residences before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. at the called party's location, together with the provision's exceptions. Other applicable federal and state requirements still apply.
- Recording retention: The Taping Rule itself requires at least three years from each recording's creation, with the first two years easily accessible and a catalog by registered person and date.
A telemarketing failure must be assessed under the applicable telemarketing requirements. Assess the firm's separate recording, review, and procedure-enforcement duties on the actual facts; a prohibited call does not automatically establish every element of a taping-rule violation.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Recording a prohibited call does not cure a telemarketing violation.
Disclosure to Customers
The Taping Rule does not require express disclosure to customers that calls are being recorded. Recording a call may separately implicate federal and state wiretap-consent law, which the firm's compliance procedures address; that requirement comes from outside the taping rule.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The Taping Rule itself does not require customer recording notice; separate consent law may apply.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you state the taping-firm threshold for a 10-to-19-person firm: four or more registered persons from disciplined firms?
- Can you identify the earlier trigger and determine whether the firm both established and implemented its written taping procedures within 60 days?
- Can you distinguish the one-time 30-day reduction window from the ongoing taping obligation once the threshold is crossed?
- Do you know the Taping Rule itself does not require the firm to notify customers that calls are recorded?
For a comparison of the three thresholds, see the taping-rule threshold table.