Quick Answer
Physical precious metals and metal-backed exchange-traded funds are taxed at the collectibles rate (max 28%); regulated futures use a blended 60/40 rate no matter the holding period. Bitcoin is a commodity, not a security. The Howey test decides which digital tokens are securities. The tax service treats all digital assets as property.
The whole unit on one sheet: commodities, precious metals, digital assets, their tax rates, and the classification lines the exam loves.
Which One-Liners Win Points?
- Hard commodities are mined or extracted (gold, oil); soft commodities are grown or raised (wheat, coffee).
- Commodity futures and other commodity derivatives are regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), not the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC); the physical commodity itself is not a security.
- Precious metals generate NO income: return comes only from price appreciation, so they are unsuitable as a sole holding for a client needing current income.
- Precious metals are an inflation hedge (positive correlation with inflation) and a market hedge (negative correlation with equities: flight to safety).
- Physically-backed metal exchange-traded funds (ETFs) like GLD and SLV are taxed as collectibles, NOT at standard equity rates.
- Contango = futures price higher than spot (normal, reflects carrying costs); backwardation = futures price lower than spot (supply shortage or strong near-term demand). A futures ETF that rolls contracts sells the cheaper near-month and buys the pricier far-month in contango (negative roll yield), and the reverse in backwardation (positive roll yield).
- The U.S. dollar has an inverse relationship with commodity prices: a weaker dollar tends to lift commodity prices.
- An ordinary Bitcoin purchase generally lacks reliance on a central promoter's managerial efforts. Bitcoin is generally a commodity, but Howey does not assign commodity status; it tests for an investment contract.
- Calling a token a "utility token" does not make it a non-security: the SEC applies the Howey test to economic substance.
- The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) treats all digital assets as property, never as currency, even dollar-pegged stablecoins. Once the GENIUS Act takes effect, payment stablecoins fall under federal banking regulators (OCC, Fed, FDIC, NCUA), not the SEC/CFTC lane.
- A crypto token is not a Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC)-insured deposit. Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) coverage depends on asset eligibility and custody; Bitcoin and unregistered investment-contract tokens are excluded.
Which Numbers Matter Most?
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Physical precious metals and metal-backed ETFs | max 28% collectibles rate |
| Regulated futures contracts | 60% long-term / 40% short-term blended |
| Commodity producer stocks | standard long-term capital gains, max 20% |
| Bitcoin maximum supply | 21 million coins |
| Digital assets long-term capital gains | generally 0%, 15%, or 20% (some NFTs: maximum 28% collectibles rate) |
| Howey test prongs (all required) | 4 |
What Are the Four Howey Test Prongs?
- Investment of money
- Common enterprise
- Reasonable expectation of profits
- Derived from the efforts of others
If a buyer expects the development team's work to lift the token's value, it looks like a security; if the token just buys a service (like a subway token), it probably is not.
Which Gotchas Trip Students Up?
- Metal-backed ETFs get up to the 28% collectibles rate, not the 20% equity rate. The exam tests this distinction directly.
- Regulated futures get the 60/40 blended rate regardless of holding period, even a one-day trade; positions are marked to market at year-end.
- Bitcoin is a commodity (CFTC), not a security, but many other tokens that meet the Howey test ARE securities under SEC oversight. Classification follows function, not the label.
- A Howey-test token is a security under the Uniform Securities Act too, not just federal law, so it falls under a state Administrator's jurisdiction regardless of what the SEC decides.
- Every crypto sale, exchange, or crypto-to-crypto swap is a taxable event; mining and staking rewards are ordinary income when received.
- Like-kind exchange deferral does not apply to digital assets (it is limited to real property).
- Losing your private keys on a self-custody wallet with no backup recovery phrase means permanent loss of the assets: "not your keys, not your coins," with no institution to reset it.
One-Breath Recap
Commodities split into hard (mined) and soft (grown); their futures and other derivatives answer to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, not the SEC, and the physical commodity itself is not a security. Precious metals generate no income and hedge both inflation and falling equities; physical metal and metal-backed funds are taxed as collectibles at up to 28%, regulated futures at a blended 60/40 rate regardless of holding period, and producer stocks as ordinary equities, while contango means futures above spot and backwardation below. Bitcoin is a commodity; other tokens can be securities under the Howey test. Digital assets are property for tax purposes, so swaps can trigger gains or losses. Bitcoin has no deposit insurance or SIPC protection; qualifying digital securities depend on asset eligibility and custody at a SIPC-member brokerage.
Need more than the recap? Read the full Other Assets unit.