Insurance-Based Products

Quick Answer

Every insurance question comes down to one test: who bears the investment risk? If the contract owner picks subaccounts and takes the risk, the product is a security (registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), sold with a prospectus). If the insurance company guarantees the return, it is insurance only, regulated by state insurance departments.

The whole unit on one sheet: fixed versus variable annuities, equity-indexed annuities, the life insurance ladder, and the "variable equals security" trigger the exam loves.


Which One-Liners Win Points?

  • The word "variable" is the trigger. Variable means subaccounts; subaccounts mean the owner bears the risk; owner risk means it is a security (SEC registration plus prospectus).
  • Fixed annuities are NOT securities. The insurance company bears the investment risk and guarantees the return; regulated by state insurance departments, not the SEC or the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).
  • Variable annuities ARE securities. The contract owner bears the investment risk through subaccounts; registered with the SEC, sold with a prospectus.
  • Equity-indexed annuities (fixed indexed annuities) are NOT securities. They link to a market index but the guaranteed floor means the insurer absorbs the downside, so the owner does not bear the full risk.
  • Among annuity types, mortality and expense (M&E) charges are unique to variable annuities. Fixed annuities do not carry them (variable life insurance can also have M&E charges).
  • Sellers of variable products need BOTH a securities license AND an insurance license.
  • On the life insurance side: term, whole, and universal life are NOT securities; variable life and variable universal life (VUL) ARE.
  • For the same premium, primary annuitant and pricing assumptions, life only generally pays most among lifetime elections. Adding beneficiary or survivor guarantees generally reduces the payment.

Which Numbers Matter Most?

ItemValue
Mortality and expense (M&E) risk chargeContract-specific annual percentage
Surrender charge scheduleContract-specific duration and percentages; allowances and waivers can apply
Early-withdrawal IRS taxgenerally 10% on the taxable portion of withdrawals before age 59 1/2, on top of ordinary income tax (absent an exception)
Example participation rate80% (index gains 10%, contract credited 8%)
Example cap rate7% (index gains 12%, contract credited only 7%)
Hypothetical credited-interest floorsWith an index loss, a 0% floor credits 0% and a 3% floor credits 3%, before charges
Term life periods10, 20, or 30 years
Joint and survivor continuation100%, 75%, or 50% to the survivor

Which Annuities Are Securities?

  • Fixed: guaranteed rate for a set period; insurance company bears the risk; predictable income; not a security; state-regulated.
  • Variable: return depends on subaccount performance (like mutual funds; the insurer's separate account is generally registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940); owner bears the risk; a security.
  • Equity-indexed: return linked to a stock index with a guaranteed minimum; insurer bears the downside via the floor; owner does not select subaccounts; not a security.
  • Tax treatment (variable, nonqualified, pre-annuitization): tax-deferred growth in the accumulation phase; the taxable portion of withdrawals is taxed as ordinary income (not capital gains); last in, first out (LIFO) means earnings come out first, so early withdrawals are taxable until earnings are exhausted.
  • Death benefit: typically guarantees beneficiaries at least the amount invested (minus withdrawals) if the owner dies during accumulation, though the exact guarantee is contract-specific; applies only in the accumulation phase.
  • Two phases: accumulation (purchase payments grow tax-deferred, death benefit guarantee applies), then annuitization/payout (converts to an income stream, amount depends on the payout option).
  • Compare payout guarantees using the same premium and pricing assumptions. Life only generally pays most among lifetime elections. Joint and survivor versus life with period certain depends on the covered ages, guarantee term and survivor percentage. Fixed-period payments depend on the chosen term rather than a lifetime ranking.

Which Life Policies Are Securities?

  • Term: pure death benefit for a set period; no cash value; least expensive; not a security.
  • Whole life (ordinary life): permanent, level fixed premiums; guaranteed fixed-rate cash value; can borrow against it; not a security.
  • Universal life: permanent with flexible premiums and adjustable death benefit; interest rate set by the insurer with a guaranteed minimum; not a security.
  • Variable life: subaccount cash value; policyholder bears the risk; a security (prospectus required); guaranteed minimum death benefit but NO guaranteed cash value (premiums fixed).
  • Variable universal life (VUL): flexible premiums plus subaccount investing; adjustable death benefit; most flexible and most complex; a security (prospectus required); policyholder bears the risk.

Which Gotchas Trip Students Up?

  • The 10% early-withdrawal tax is IN ADDITION to ordinary income tax, generally. A pre-59 1/2 withdrawal gets hit twice absent an exception.
  • LIFO means earnings come out first, so early withdrawals from a nonqualified variable annuity are taxable until the earnings are exhausted.

One-Breath Recap

Every insurance-based product turns on one question: who bears the investment risk? Fixed annuities, equity-indexed annuities, term, whole, and universal life leave the risk with the insurer, so they are insurance products regulated by state insurance departments, not securities. Variable products offer owner-selected subaccounts and investment exposure, making them securities sold with a prospectus and both securities and insurance licenses. A variable annuity can later offer fixed-dollar income at annuitization, placing the investment risk supporting that guarantee on the insurer. Lock in mortality and expense charges, last-in-first-out taxation of pre-annuitization withdrawals, the 10% additional tax before age 59 1/2 absent an exception, and the accumulation-only death benefit. Compare payout quotes under the same premium and assumptions; no universal joint-versus-period-certain ranking applies.


Need more than the recap? Read the full Insurance-Based Products unit.