Other Assets

Quick Answer

Commodity futures and options fall under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Exchange-traded fund shares and mining stocks are securities overseen by the Securities and Exchange Commission. Howey identifies investment contracts; tokenized stocks or bonds can qualify under other securities categories. Non-security cryptocurrencies lack FDIC insurance and SIPC protection.

Review classifications, regulators, ownership costs, and risks.


Which One-Liners Win Points?

  • The CFTC regulates commodity futures and options, not the SEC.
  • A commodity-related security (an ETF holding commodity futures) IS regulated by the SEC because the ETF itself is a security.
  • Physical gold bars and coins are NOT securities; a gold ETF or a mining stock IS a security.
  • A commodity pool works like a mutual fund for futures and options; the commodity pool operator (CPO) generally must register with the CFTC, unless an exclusion or exemption applies.
  • Hedging locks in a price to reduce risk (an airline buys crude oil futures); speculation takes a position purely to profit from price moves.
  • Bitcoin is generally NOT sold as a security: buyers aren't relying on a central promoter's efforts to profit.
  • Initial Coin Offering (ICO) token sales are often securities transactions: investors buy expecting a development team to build value, which can satisfy all four Howey prongs (each offering is analyzed on its own facts).
  • Lost private keys can mean permanently lost assets for self-custody without a recovery phrase. There is generally no institution to restore access and no "reset password" option.

Who Regulates Commodities and Precious Metals?

  • Commodities are physical goods in three categories: agricultural (wheat, corn, soybeans), energy (crude oil, natural gas), and metals (gold, silver, copper). Standardized futures contracts on these goods trade on regulated derivatives exchanges.
  • Traded mainly through futures contracts on exchanges like the CME Group and ICE (Intercontinental Exchange); prices move on supply and demand, weather, geopolitics, and currency swings.
  • The four primary precious metals: gold, silver, platinum, and palladium; often held as a hedge against inflation and currency devaluation, with gold the classic safe haven.
  • Security or not: physical coins and bars (no), futures contracts (no, commodity, CFTC), ETFs like GLD and SLV (yes, SEC), mining company stocks (yes, SEC).
  • Physical metals pay no dividends or interest; returns depend only on price appreciation, and storage, insurance, and dealer markups cut into net returns.

When Is a Digital Asset a Security?

  • Digital assets include cryptocurrencies, tokens, and other blockchain-based assets; they exist only as entries on a distributed ledger, not in physical form.
  • Cryptocurrencies are decentralized digital currencies, not issued or backed by any government or central authority; they are not securities by default, though tokens sold as investment contracts may be.
  • Blockchain records transactions across a network in a tamper-resistant ledger. Records normally remain unchanged, but history can change. Access and governance vary; Bitcoin's ledger is public and decentralized.
  • Wallets store the private keys that access crypto: a hot wallet is online (lower security, frequent trading), a cold wallet is offline hardware (higher security, long-term storage).
  • The Howey Test (SEC) applies to a specific offer or sale, not permanently to the asset; the arrangement qualifies as an investment contract only if ALL four prongs are met: investment of money, common enterprise, reasonable expectation of profits, and profits derived from the efforts of others. Tokenized stocks or bonds can be securities under other categories.
  • Digital assets can be highly volatile and have unstable correlation with stocks or bonds. Non-security cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin have no corporate earnings or dividends; tokenized securities can have business valuation inputs.
  • Key risks: volatility, regulatory (evolving framework), cybersecurity (exchange hacks, wallet compromises, stolen keys), liquidity (some assets trade thinly), technology (bugs, network failures, forks), and fraud (scams, pump-and-dump, unregistered offerings).

Which Numbers Matter Most?

ItemValue
Primary precious metalsgold, silver, platinum, palladium
Howey Test prongs (all must be met)4
SIPC protection for cryptogenerally none
FDIC insurance for cryptogenerally none

Which Gotchas Trip Students Up?

  • If you see "physical" precious metals, think not a security (owning bullion isn't CFTC-registered either, it's simply outside securities regulation); if you see an ETF or mining stock, think SEC and security; if you see a futures contract, think CFTC.
  • Generally no SIPC or FDIC protection for crypto holdings. If an exchange fails or is hacked, investors typically have no federal safety net and may lose everything (a registered security or qualifying cash sweep may receive limited protection).
  • The exam asks you to apply the Howey Test to a scenario, not to memorize which specific coins are securities.
  • Regulatory risk: changes in legal classification or trading restrictions can affect an asset's availability and value.
  • A sender generally cannot obtain a chargeback of a confirmed cryptocurrency transfer; recovery often depends on the recipient's cooperation.

One-Breath Recap

Check whether an asset is a security and who regulates it. Commodity futures and options fall under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, physical precious metals are not securities at all, a commodity Exchange-Traded Fund or a mining stock is a security under the SEC, and a commodity pool operator generally must register unless an exclusion or exemption applies. Digital assets turn on the Howey Test applied to the offer or sale (investment of money, common enterprise, expectation of profits, efforts of others, all four required), so Bitcoin is generally not sold as a security while many initial coin offering token sales are. Crypto generally has no Securities Investor Protection Corporation or Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation protection, lost private keys can mean lost assets in self-custody, and regulatory changes can affect value and availability.


Need more than the recap? Read the full Other Assets unit.