Close-Out: Buy-Ins, Sell-Outs, and COD Orders

Quick Answer

The buy-in closes a buyer's failed contract: notice by 12:00 p.m. ET, at least two business days before execution, at the defaulting seller's risk. The sell-out closes a seller's failed contract without notice. Both send same-day execution notice by 6:00 p.m. ET. Reclamation: 15 days minor/currency, 45 days foreign, 30 months lost/stolen/confiscated.

Close-out is the final step in the Uniform Practice Code framework: when delivery breaks down, who closes the trade out and on what timeline. The principal must understand the buy-in (buyer's remedy for seller fail), the sell-out (seller's remedy for buyer fail), the reclamation windows, and the COD / delivery versus payment (DVP) / receive versus payment (RVP) order requirements.


Buy-In Procedures

When a seller fails to deliver securities by settlement date, the buyer may close out the contract by purchasing securities of like kind and quantity in the open market at the seller's risk.

Notice Requirement

The written buy-in notice must be delivered:

  • No later than 12:00 p.m. ET, AND
  • At least two business days before the buy-in execution

The two-business-day window gives the failing seller time to source the securities or arrange substitute delivery. A buy-in notice that arrives the morning of execution (no notice period) is invalid.

The buy-in itself may not be executed sooner than the third business day following the date delivery was due. Both the notice timing and this minimum-wait must be met before the buyer can close the contract out.

Risk and Cost Allocation

The buy-in is for the account and risk of the defaulting (selling) broker-dealer. That means:

  • The buyer purchases substitute securities in the open market
  • The executed buy-in closes the contract, whether its price is above or below the original contract price
  • If the buy-in price is higher than the original contract price, the seller owes the difference
  • The rule's text on an ordinary buy-in names that money difference. It does not list a separate charge for commission or clearing costs, so a billing memo bills the difference
  • Paragraph (h) of the buy-in rule sets the payment clock. Any money difference from the close-out is paid to the member entitled to receive it, by 3:00 p.m. ET on the business day after the settlement date of the executed buy-in. The same clock applies whether the buy-in price is higher or lower
  • For an ordinary buy-in under paragraph (h), the rule states no direction for a lower price. It only names the member entitled to receive the difference
  • A unit investment trust buy-in has an added option. If the buyer cannot use the ordinary options or agree on a substitute, the buyer may require the seller to repurchase the units
  • In that repurchase the seller bears the burden of any change in the market price. If the market price is lower than the original contract price, the repurchase is at the original contract price, with accrued interest
  • Members must be prepared to defend the price at which the buy-in is executed against the current market at the time of the buy-in

In practice, buy-ins almost always close at a price unfavorable to the defaulting seller, because the buy-in pressure is well known to the market.

Operational Requirements

Members must maintain a buy-in section/desk that is adequately staffed to:

  • Process and research buy-in notices within the rule's time frames
  • Issue buy-in notices on time
  • Coordinate with stock-loan and trading desks to source substitute securities

A firm without an operational buy-in capability has not satisfied the rule's expectations.

Notice After Execution

The buyer that executes the buy-in must notify the seller of the quantity purchased and the price paid immediately upon execution, and no later than 6:00 p.m. ET that day, in written or electronic form with immediate-receipt capability. A formal confirmation follows by 9:30 a.m. ET the next business day.

Retransmitted Notices

Buy-in notices may be retransmitted in some cases when the failing seller is itself awaiting delivery from another counterparty. The retransmission moves the buy-in pressure up the chain to the original failing party.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The buyer closes a seller’s delivery fail at the defaulting seller’s risk; notice is due by noon at least two business days before execution.
  • Pay the money difference to the entitled member by 3 p.m. ET on the business day after the executed buy-in settles.
  • Maintain a buy-in desk capable of meeting the deadlines.

Selling-Out

When the buyer fails to accept delivery in accordance with the contract and has not delivered a properly executed Uniform Reclamation Form, the seller may, without notice, "sell out" the securities in the best available market at the account and risk of the defaulting buyer.

Key Differences from a Buy-In

ElementBuy-InSell-Out
Failing partySeller fails to deliverBuyer fails to accept delivery
Closing partyBuyerSeller
Notice requirement12:00 p.m. ET, two business days before executionNO notice required
Notification afterImmediately upon execution, no later than 6:00 p.m. ET that day, written or electronic with immediate-receipt capability; formal confirmation by 9:30 a.m. ET the next business dayAs promptly as possible on the day of execution, no later than 6:00 p.m. ET, in writing or electronic with immediate-receipt capability
Risk and costDefaulting seller's account and riskDefaulting buyer's account and risk

Why No Notice for Sell-Outs

The sell-out is symmetric to the buy-in but does not require advance notice. The asymmetry exists because:

  • A failing seller (no delivery) has the burden of finding the security to deliver
  • A failing buyer (no acceptance of delivery) has already received the goods or refused them; the seller has no remedy other than disposing of the held securities

The seller's recourse is immediate: sell the securities and pursue the difference from the buyer.

Notification Form

The seller must notify the buyer as promptly as possible on the day of execution, and no later than 6:00 p.m. ET, in writing or electronic form with immediate-receipt capability, including the quantity and price. A formal confirmation follows as promptly as possible.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A seller may sell out a buyer’s failure to accept without advance notice, subject to the reclamation-form condition.
  • Notify as promptly as possible on execution day, no later than 6 p.m. ET.

Reclamation

A reclamation is the right to return improperly delivered securities. The reclamation rules set the windows by category:

Type of DefectReclamation Window
Minor irregularity that affects only the security's currency in the market15 days from the day of original delivery
Same minor irregularity, security issued under a foreign country's jurisdiction45 days from the day of original delivery
Wrong form of certificate that can be exchanged without charge for a good-delivery certificate15 days from the day of original delivery
Irregular delivery (including wrong, duplicate, misdirected, or over-deliveries)30 months after settlement date
Transfer refused by the transfer agent30 months after settlement date
Lost / stolen / confiscated30 months after settlement date

"Currency" here means the security's general acceptance in the market, not money; the 45-day row turns on where the security was issued, not on any foreign-exchange conversion. The short windows run from the day of original delivery, while the 30-month windows run from the settlement date of the contract.

What Happens Without a Proper Reclamation Form

A security returned without a properly executed Uniform Reclamation Form may be sold out by the receiving broker, no later than 3 business days after receipt.

The Uniform Reclamation Form is the procedural document that supports a return. A return without the form is treated as an improper delivery; the receiver can sell out the held securities and pursue the difference.

Why the 30-Month Window for Lost/Stolen

The 30-month window, shared by irregular deliveries, refused transfers, and lost, stolen, or confiscated securities, is unusually long. The reason: these certificate problems often surface only when the buyer attempts to sell or transfer the security and the transfer agent flags it. The 30-month window covers the typical interval between original purchase and discovery.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Minor irregularities generally have 15 days from original delivery, or 45 days for foreign-issued securities.
  • Irregular delivery, refused transfer and lost, stolen or confiscated securities have 30 months from settlement, not discovery.
  • A return without a properly executed reclamation form may be sold out within three business days of receipt.

Rights and Warrants

Special close-out rules apply to fails involving rights and warrants because of their short exercise windows. Close-outs must be timed before expiration of the exercise period, or the value evaporates.

If a fail involves rights or warrants, the standard buy-in is not the only route. The receiving firm may issue a Liability Notice as an alternative, or, if it does not, buy in without prior notice on the expiration date.

The expiration date is the latest time and date on which the securities must be delivered or surrendered, up to and including the last day of any protect period.

The no-notice buy-in takes place after normal delivery hours on that date, for the account and risk of the failing member.

So "before expiration" and "on the expiration date" describe the same deadline: the close-out must finish no later than that date. A buy-in completed after the exercise window has lost the underlying value.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • For expiring rights or warrants, a Liability Notice is an alternative; otherwise a no-notice buy-in may occur on expiration date.

COD / DVP-RVP Orders

A COD (Collect on Delivery) or POD (Payment on Delivery) order is a customer order where settlement happens through the customer's agent or custodian (DVP/RVP arrangement). The COD/POD settlement rule sets the procedural requirements.

Marking the Order

Each order accepted under a COD or POD arrangement must be marked as such. The marking flags the operational pathway; orders are routed to the customer's custodian for settlement, not to the firm's own customer account.

Before Accepting a COD/DVP Order

Before accepting a COD/DVP order, the member must obtain from the customer:

  • Name and address of the customer's agent/custodian
  • Customer's account number at that agent
  • Institution number (where appropriate)

Without this information, the firm cannot route the trade for settlement; the rule requires the data up front.

Confirmation Delivery

The member must deliver to the customer a confirmation (or all relevant data customarily on a confirmation) by end of the trade date. This is a same-day requirement, parallel to the same-day affirmation framework.

Same-Day Affirmation Linkage

The COD/POD settlement rule bars a member from accepting a COD/DVP order unless every one of its listed procedures is followed. One of them applies prior to accepting the order: the member must have entered into the written agreement OR established written policies and procedures required by the same-day-allocation rule for any resulting transaction. A firm with neither cannot accept the order.

COD/DVP orders are precisely the post-trade-allocation case that the same-day affirmation framework was designed to support.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Obtain agent and account information before accepting a collect-on-delivery order; institution number is required where appropriate.
  • Deliver confirmation or customary confirmation data by trade-date end.
  • Before acceptance, have the required written agreement or written policies and procedures for same-day allocation.

How the Close-Out Pieces Connect

The close-out framework operates as a structured framework for resolving fails:

Failure TypeClosing PartyMechanismNotice Requirement
Seller fails to deliverBuyerBuy-in12:00 p.m. ET, two business days before
Buyer fails to acceptSellerSell-outNone (notify 6:00 p.m. ET day of)
Improper delivery (return without reclamation form)ReceiverReclamation sell-out3 business days after receipt
Failure to markDemanding memberClose-outStandard buy-in/sell-out timing
Rights/warrants failEither sideLiability Notice or no-notice buy-inOn the expiration date

The principal supervising operations must:

  • Verify written supervisory procedures cover each close-out type
  • Verify the firm has operational capability to issue notices on time
  • Verify recordkeeping captures every close-out (buy-in notice, execution, defaulting party billing)
  • Verify the COD/DVP pre-acceptance and confirmation requirements are met for every COD/DVP order

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • A buy-in addresses the seller’s failure to deliver; a sell-out addresses the buyer’s failure to accept.
  • Buy-in advance notice differs from sell-out; both have execution-day notice deadlines.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you state the buy-in notice deadline, 12:00 p.m. ET, at least two business days before execution, and who bears the risk?
  • Do you know a sell-out requires no advance notice, but the seller must notify the buyer by 6:00 p.m. ET the same day?
  • Can you state the three reclamation windows: 15 days for minor irregularities, 45 days foreign, 30 months for irregular delivery, refused transfer, or lost or stolen?
  • Do you know what information a firm must collect before accepting a COD or DVP order, and when confirmation is due?