Comparisons, Confirmations, and DK Notices

Quick Answer

Both parties send a Uniform Comparison by the end of the trade date. A discrepancy is fixed by the party in error's corrected comparison. If a member gets no comparison back, it may send a Don't Know (DK) notice; the contra has one business day to respond, or the trade is DK'd with no further liability.

The comparison and confirmation framework is the broker-to-broker procedure for documenting trades. The principal must understand the deadlines (when comparisons must be exchanged), the content (what the comparison must contain), and the DK procedure (how a member that gets no comparison back makes the contra confirm or DK the trade).


Uniform Comparison/Confirmation

When two members trade with each other in a trade the Uniform Practice Code covers, each side must send the other a Uniform Comparison or Confirmation documenting the trade.

The Code does not cover every inter-member trade. It excludes trades compared, cleared, or settled through a registered clearing agency, exempted securities, municipal securities, most redeemable investment-company securities, and most direct participation program (DPP) interests. Municipal trades between members follow MSRB rules instead, for every trade type, cash or otherwise. The lesson on UPC scope and clearing lists each exclusion.

Timing Requirements

Trade TypeWhen the Comparison Must Be Sent
All transactions (cash or non-cash)By the end of the trade date

The rule sets a single deadline for every trade. It does not give regular-way (non-cash) trades an extra day. A cash trade settles the same day and a regular-way trade settles later, but that gap does not change the comparison deadline. The deadline comes from the comparison rule itself.

Required Contents

The comparison must include:

  • Trade date
  • Settlement date
  • Security (CUSIP, name, type)
  • Quantity (number of shares or par amount)
  • Price
  • Parties to the trade
  • Capacity: principal or agent
  • Special terms (if any)

A comparison missing any of these elements is incomplete, and the party in error sends a corrected comparison.

Why Both Sides Send

The comparison is mutual. Each member sends one to the other. This double-entry matching is what catches discrepancies:

  • If both sides report the same trade with the same terms, the comparison matches and settlement proceeds
  • If the terms differ on price, quantity, security, or capacity, the mismatch surfaces immediately

Think of it this way: The inter-member comparison is the broker-to-broker version of "two parties agree on what just happened." Without it, the two firms could carry mismatched bookings into settlement and the fail wouldn't surface until delivery breaks down.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Both members send comparisons by trade-date end; a customer confirmation is a separate requirement.

Don't Know (DK) Notice Procedure

The DK notice procedure is written for one situation: a member sends its own comparison and gets nothing back (no comparison and no signed DK) by the end of the trade date.

The rule also names a signed DK as an answer the contra can send: a member that receives a comparison for a trade it has no record of can answer with a signed DK instead of its own comparison. A discrepancy between two comparisons that both arrived is different. The party in error corrects it by sending a corrected comparison, not a DK notice.

When the DK Procedure Is Available

A DK notice applies to non-receipt, not to a plain term discrepancy:

  • The submitting member received no comparison or signed DK from the contra-party by the end of the trade date

A member that has no record of a trade it was sent a comparison for answers with a signed DK; that is the contra's answer, not the notice procedure.

A discrepancy between two comparisons that both arrived is not a DK trigger. The party in error sends a corrected comparison (price, quantity, security, capacity, or settlement date).

The procedure is available, not mandatory: the rule says it "may be utilized." The DK notice is the formal way a member that has heard nothing back tells its contra: confirm this trade or DK it.

On timing, the rule says two things:

  • The procedure opens at the end of the trade date.
  • The member that sends the notice has no deadline of its own. The rule states no later cutoff for sending it.

The only clock in the rule belongs to the contra, and it starts when the contra receives the notice (see the next section).

The Response Window

After a DK notice is issued, the contra-member has one business day after receipt of the DK to:

  • Confirm the trade as compared by the member that sent the notice, OR
  • DK the trade (rejecting it; the trade does not settle)

If the contra-member fails to respond within that one-business-day window, the trade is treated as DK'd. The confirming member then has no further liability on the trade.

This is not the same as saying no cost exists anywhere. A DK'd trade never becomes a matched, completed transaction between the two firms, so there is nothing left for the confirming member to settle: no delivery owed, no payment owed.

"No further liability" describes this one interbroker trade, not the firm's broader market position. If the firm still needs the security or the proceeds, it has to source them through a new trade.

The DK Sequence in Practice

DayEvent
Trade Date (T)Two members execute a trade
Trade date (close)Both members should have exchanged Uniform Comparisons
Trade date or laterMember A sent its comparison but receives no comparison from B by the trade date. Member A issues a DK notice to B
DK + 1 business dayMember B must respond: confirm or DK
DK + 1 business day (no response)Trade is treated as DK'd. Member A has no further liability

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • The sender may issue a DK notice after receiving neither a comparison nor signed DK by trade-date end; no later sender deadline is stated.
  • The contra has one business day after receipt to respond; silence treats the trade as DK’d.
  • A discrepancy between received comparisons calls for the party in error to send a corrected comparison.

The Confirmation Trap

The Function 4 exam outline lists "trade confirmation requirements and disclosures" under the comparison and confirmation framework. This is the street-side broker-to-broker comparison process, not the customer-facing confirmation requirement.

The exam will distinguish these two:

SourceWho Sends to WhomWhat It Documents
Customer-confirmation requirementsBroker-dealer to customerCustomer-facing confirmation (covered in the Recommendations and Disclosures unit, Customer-Related Activities chapter)
Inter-member comparison ruleMember to memberBroker-to-broker comparison/confirmation

A fact pattern about the firm sending a confirmation to its customer points to the customer-confirmation requirement. A fact pattern about two firms exchanging trade details points to the inter-member comparison rule. The exam tests this distinction directly. If the complaint is in writing, the firm also counts it in its quarterly statistical and summary report of written customer complaints to FINRA.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Customer confirmations and inter-member comparisons serve different recipients and rules.
  • A customer dispute is handled by the customer’s firm, not by sending a DK notice on the customer’s behalf.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you state the deadline for sending a Uniform Comparison or Confirmation between members: by the end of the trade date?
  • Do you know a discrepancy between two received comparisons is fixed by the party in error sending a corrected comparison, while a DK notice is for non-receipt, when the member's own comparison drew neither a comparison nor a signed DK?
  • Do you know a contra-member has one business day after receiving a DK notice to confirm or DK the trade?
  • Can you state what happens if the contra-member does not respond to a DK notice within one business day?
  • Do you know the difference between the inter-member comparison, broker to broker, and the customer-confirmation requirement, broker-dealer to customer?