Marking to the Market

Quick Answer

On an uncompleted inter-member contract, the exposed member may demand collateral for the adverse price difference. Permitted deposit locations have specific conditions. Proper written demands require immediate compliance; excess collateral is refundable on demand. Noncompliance can permit close-out without further advance notice, after the rule's waiting period. Written notification and formal confirmations follow execution.

The mark-to-market rule is the inter-member mechanism for managing counterparty credit exposure on trades that have not yet settled. The principal supervising operations sees both the inter-member mark (street-side, between members) and customer margin (covered separately) operating in parallel.


How Marking to the Market Works

When two members enter into a contract for the purchase or sale of a security and the trade has not yet settled, the contract carries counterparty exposure. If the market price moves between trade date and settlement date, one member is now exposed to a loss if the contra-party defaults.

Mark-to-Market Deposit Sequence

The mark-to-market rule lets the exposed member demand a mark-to-market deposit from the contra-party. The mechanic:

StepAction
1Two members trade at a contract price (e.g., $50.00)
2The market moves before settlement (e.g., current market is now $48.00)
3The seller is exposed: the buyer has a $2.00 paper loss and could walk away from the trade
4The seller may demand a mark-to-market deposit equal to the loss ($2.00 per share × quantity)
5The buyer deposits with the demanding member or another permitted location
6Further adverse movement can support an additional deposit demand. The added amount secures the contract only after the other party deposits it
7If the market reverses, the depositor may demand return of the excess. The demand must be in writing, and the holder must comply immediately. The excess does not come back by itself

For 100 shares, the $2 decline creates $200 of exposure, so the seller may demand a $200 deposit.

Where the Funds Can Be Held

The inter-member mark rule permits a deposit:

  • Directly with the demanding member
  • With a mutually agreed depositary
  • If the parties cannot agree, with a Federal Reserve System member at an office in the financial district of the city where the unsecured party maintains its office

The depositing party cannot select any third party or bank unilaterally. The agreement and location conditions matter.

Update Frequency

Daily monitoring is a sensible risk-control practice, but the inter-member mark rule does not mandate a daily review cadence. Procedures should identify exposure, support additional demands as prices move, and ensure immediate compliance with proper written demands for deposits or refunds.


When Failure to Deposit Triggers Close-Out

If a party fails to comply with a proper deposit or refund demand, the mark rule itself permits the demanding member to close the contract by an offsetting purchase or sale in the best available market for the noncomplying party's account and liability. This remedy does not require the ordinary delivery-fail buy-in notice.

The sequence:

StepAction
1A proper written demand is delivered at the recipient's office during the business hours of Federal Reserve member banks in that community
2The recipient fails to comply immediately
3Closure must wait until regular delivery time ends in the demanding member's community on the business day following receipt of the demand
4The member may then make the offsetting trade without further advance notice, for the noncomplying party's account and liability
5As promptly as possible on the execution day, the member notifies the other party in writing and mails or delivers formal confirmation to that party, with the required committee copy

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Proper written deposit or refund demands require immediate compliance; disagreement alone does not suspend a valid demand.
  • Only deposited funds secure the open contract; an unpaid additional demand leaves the later exposure unsecured.
  • Alternative deposit locations have agreement and location conditions.

Inter-Member Mark vs. Customer Margin Maintenance

The exam pairs the inter-member mark with the customer margin maintenance regime to test the distinction. Both involve mark-to-market and deposit demands, but they operate at different levels:

RegimeWhoWhat It Protects
Inter-member markMember to memberThe demanding member's exposure on an uncompleted street-side contract
Customer margin maintenanceFirm to customerThe firm's exposure on a customer margin account

The principal supervising operations sees both:

  • Customer margin maintenance protects the firm against the customer (the firm calls additional margin when the customer's account equity drops below maintenance). FINRA's customer margin rule sets the maintenance level (25 percent of the market value of long margin securities). Regulation T sets initial credit, not maintenance.
  • The inter-member mark protects one member against another (the member demands a mark when the contra-party's contract is underwater)

A firm with weak inter-member mark procedures has unmarked street-side exposure, exactly the kind that surfaces during a market dislocation. A firm with weak customer-margin procedures has unmarked customer margin exposure.

Think of it this way: Customer margin is internal (firm vs. customer); the inter-member mark is external (firm vs. counterparty). The two operate in parallel but address different risks. The principal supervising operations is responsible for both.

Customer maintenance can apply while the street-side contract remains unsettled. Settlement timing does not replace the distinction between customer-account and inter-member exposures.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • An inter-member mark secures an uncompleted contract; customer margin protects exposure in a customer account.
  • The two demands can arise at the same time.

Why This Matters for the Supervisor

Reasonable supervisory procedures for the firm's business should address:

  • When and how the firm will demand a mark under its written supervisory procedures (WSPs)
  • How the firm responds immediately to proper deposit and refund demands
  • Monitoring open contracts and current market prices to identify exposure
  • Recording demands, deposits and refunds under the firm's procedures

A firm that sees a contract move underwater and fails to demand a mark is leaving counterparty exposure unmitigated. A firm that has a mark demanded against it and fails to deposit is in default and exposed to close-out.

Exam Tip: Gotchas

  • Demanding a mark is permissive; the amount secures the adverse price difference, not the full notional value.
  • Excess is returned on a written demand, not automatically; the holder must comply immediately.

What Should You Check on Exam Day?

  • Can you identify the permitted deposit locations and the agreement and location conditions for alternatives?
  • Can you distinguish the mark rule's waiting period, offsetting-trade remedy and post-execution notifications from the ordinary delivery-fail buy-in procedure?
  • Can you distinguish the inter-member mark (security for an open contract, not the purchase price) from customer margin maintenance, and state which counterparty each protects?
  • Do you know that the rule sets no update schedule, and that a refund of excess follows a written demand from the depositing party?
  • Do you know that disagreement alone does not delay a demand satisfying the amount, delivery and timing requirements?