Quick Answer
The corporate-financing rule requires a member firm to file deal documents with FINRA's Public Offering System (POS): within 3 business days of SEC/state filing, or 15 business days before sale if none. It defines underwriting compensation broadly (cash, expenses, securities, warrants, rights of first refusal), requires compensation be fair and reasonable, and imposes a 180-day lock-up on compensation.
The corporate-financing rule is the FINRA principal's primary supervisory tool for public offerings. It exists because SEC registration alone does not police the economics of the underwriter's compensation. FINRA review under the corporate-financing rule fills that gap.
Filing Requirement and Timing
| Step | What | When |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Initial filing | Registration statement, proposed underwriting agreement, and any other documents that define the economics; industry-standard master forms of the selected dealer agreement and agreement among underwriters need not be filed unless FINRA requests them | If filed with SEC / state / other regulator: within 3 business days of that regulator filing. If not regulator-filed: at least 15 business days before sales commence |
| 2. Updates | Amendments and supplements affecting compensation, terms, or syndicate | Each amendment filed with the regulator must be filed with FINRA within 3 business days |
| 3. No-objection letter | FINRA POS reviewer issues a "no-objection" letter once compensation and terms clear review | Required before sales commence |
For an offering that requires FINRA filing, confidential draft submissions to the SEC also trigger the three-business-day deadline. The firm does not wait for a later public filing. Count the three business days after the filing or submission date; that date is the trigger, not day one.
A document that no regulator receives, such as a side-letter negotiated after the first FINRA filing, has no three-business-day clock of its own. The firm still adds it to the POS filing and explains the change, and the filing and FINRA's no-objection must be in place before sales commence.
A managing member or another member in the syndicate or selling group may make the required filing through FINRA's Public Offering System (POS). Other participating members need not duplicate that filing. A principal must confirm that the required filing and FINRA no-objection are in place before the firm begins sales.
Which Offerings Are Filed?
The rule reaches only a public offering. These are not public offerings, so the corporate-financing rule never reaches them:
- A private placement under the private-offering exemption or the Regulation D private-placement safe harbors
- A sale under the institutional-resale exemption, or a Regulation S offering
- Exempted securities, such as U.S. government and municipal securities
A member's own private placement, or one it places for an issuer, is filed under FINRA's private-placement filing rules instead.
Every public offering in which a member participates must be filed unless an exemption applies. The exemptions come in two kinds:
| Kind | Examples | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Exempt from filing only | Investment grade rated non-convertible debt and non-convertible preferred securities; offerings on SEC Forms S-3, F-3 or F-10 by an experienced issuer (36 months of reporting history and at least $150 million of non-affiliate voting stock, or at least $100 million plus annual trading volume of 3 million shares or more) | No filing is required, but the offering must still comply with the rule's compensation limits and prohibited terms |
| Outside the rule entirely | Municipal securities, open-end investment company shares, variable contracts, tender offers under the SEC's tender-offer rules, unit investment trusts, spin-offs distributed as a dividend, and securities registered for a merger or acquisition (other than one that makes the member publicly owned) | Neither filing nor compliance is required |
A filing exemption does not help a member whose conflict of interest requires a qualified independent underwriter: that offering must be filed and must comply with the corporate-financing rule even if it would otherwise be exempt.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The three-business-day filing clock begins with regulator filing or confidential submission; covered sales require FINRA no-objection.
What Counts as Underwriting Compensation
The corporate-financing rule defines underwriting compensation broadly. Cash spreads are obvious; everything else is what trips firms up.
| Category | Examples |
|---|---|
| Cash compensation | Underwriting discounts, selling concessions, management fees |
| Expense reimbursements | Legal, due-diligence, road-show expenses paid or reimbursed to, or paid on behalf of, the participating members |
| Securities compensation | Warrants, "compensation shares," equity participation rights |
| Financial consulting and advisory fees | Fees for advisory or consulting services provided to the issuer in connection with the offering |
| Finder's fees | Payments to finders or "introducers" who source the deal |
| Rights of first refusal (ROFR) | Right to be lead manager on a future financing |
| Other items of value | Offering-related consulting and post-deal advisory arrangements; market-rate pricing alone does not exclude an item |
Compensation is valued under formulas in the corporate-financing rule. Warrants are valued by a fixed formula in the rule, built from the public offering price, the exercise price, and the market price. It is not an option-pricing model, so volatility and time to expiration are not inputs. The valuation of warrants and other non-cash items can swamp the cash spread in determining the total compensation pool.
Some payments a member receives during the review period are generally not underwriting compensation, because they may be unrelated to the offering. The rule's own examples, which it says are not a complete list, include:
- Printing costs; SEC, state "blue sky" and other registration fees; FINRA filing fees; accountant's fees; fees of independent financial advisers; and other fees and expenses customarily borne by an issuer, even if paid through a participating member
- Cash compensation for a private placement, for providing or arranging a loan or credit facility, or for services in connection with a merger or acquisition
- Ordinary-course fees for brokerage, trust, insurance or commercial banking services provided to the issuer
By contrast, fees and expenses of the participating members' own counsel that are paid or reimbursed on their behalf are compensation, except reimbursement of blue-sky fees.
Think of it this way: FINRA does not just look at the cover-page underwriting discount. The reviewer adds up cash, valued warrants, expense reimbursements, ROFRs, and any other consideration tied to the deal. A principal who approves a deal counting only the spread misses the bigger compensation pool and creates a corporate-financing-rule violation.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Rights of first refusal, warrants and member expense reimbursements can count as compensation under the applicable valuation rules.
- Distinguish the member’s expenses from costs ordinarily borne by the issuer.
Standards of Fairness
Compensation must be fair and reasonable considering:
- The size of the offering (smaller offerings tolerate higher percentages)
- The type of security (riskier securities tolerate higher compensation)
- The risk to the underwriter (best-efforts vs. firm commitment)
- Market conditions
| Offering Size | Approximate FINRA Compensation Cap |
|---|---|
| Very small offerings (< $5M) | Up to ~10% |
| Mid-size offerings | ~6-8% typical |
| Large offerings ($100M+) | ~3-5% typical |
The FINRA staff publishes guidelines and adjusts them based on market conditions. The principal supervising a deal must verify the compensation falls within current guidelines and that the deal does not include a prohibited term.
Prohibited terms. Beyond the general fair-and-reasonable test, the corporate-financing rule names specific unreasonable terms and arrangements that are prohibited outright:
| Area | What is prohibited |
|---|---|
| Unvalued compensation | Any underwriting compensation, including securities, whose value cannot be determined |
| Expense allowances | An accountable expense allowance that pays for general overhead, salaries, supplies or similar normal-business expenses; a non-accountable expense allowance over 3% of offering proceeds |
| Payment before sales | Any underwriting compensation paid before sales commence, except (1) an advance against accountable expenses actually anticipated, which must be reimbursed to the issuer to the extent not incurred, or (2) advisory or consulting fees for offering services, if the offering is later completed |
| Offering not completed | Any compensation, except reimbursement of accountable expenses actually incurred, or a termination fee or right of first refusal under a written agreement that gives the issuer a right of termination for cause; the issuer owes a termination fee only if an offering or other transaction named in the agreement closes within 2 years after the issuer terminates the engagement |
| Rights of first refusal | A right of first refusal lasting more than 3 years from the commencement of sales or the termination of the engagement, or with more than one opportunity to waive or terminate it for a payment; any payment to waive or terminate the right must be in cash |
| Compensation warrants | An option, warrant or convertible security that is exercisable more than 5 years after sales commence, has more than one demand registration right at the issuer's expense, has a demand registration right lasting more than 5 years or a piggyback registration right lasting more than 7 years, or has anti-dilution terms that give the members more shares or a lower price when public shareholders are not proportionally affected, or that let them receive or accrue cash dividends before exercise |
| Overallotment | In a firm-commitment offering, an overallotment option of more than 15% of the securities offered |
The rule's list also reaches two narrower cases:
- Compensation on a later exercise of warrants sold in the offering in specified cases, for example an unsolicited exercise or an out-of-the-money warrant
- A member's participation in an offering for which the issuer hires persons mainly to sell it, unless those persons comply with broker-dealer registration law, or the safe harbor for an issuer's associated persons, and state law
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- Fairness depends on offering circumstances; separately check expressly prohibited terms.
- Rights of first refusal and compensation warrants have specific duration limits, regardless of offering size.
Lock-Up on Compensation Securities
Covered securities received as underwriting compensation in a public equity offering are locked up for 180 days beginning when sales commence. During the lock-up:
- No sale, transfer, hedge, or pledge of the covered securities unless an applicable exception permits it; changing the holder does not itself release the securities or reset the clock
- Exceptions depend on the security and transaction. For example, a permitted transfer to a participating member or its covered personnel leaves the securities locked up for the remainder of the period; exercise or conversion also leaves the resulting securities locked up
This lock-up applies on top of any contractual lock-up between the issuer and other shareholders. The 180-day clock runs from the date sales of the public offering commence (not the effective date, the closing date, or any later date).
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- The 180-day compensation-securities lock-up begins when public offering sales commence.
- It also covers hedges and pledges, subject to applicable exceptions.
Related FINRA Rules: Fixed-Offering-Price and Selling-Group Disclosure
Two related rules govern conduct within the offering:
| Rule | What It Does |
|---|---|
| Fixed-offering-price rule | Members may not sell at a reduced public offering price during a fixed-price offering. Specified selling concessions and allowances to brokers or dealers in the syndicate or selling group are permitted. |
| Selling-group disclosure rule | Disclosure of price and concessions in selling-group agreements: agreements must disclose the public offering price, concession to dealers, and any reallowance terms |
Rebating part of the spread to a public customer reduces the public offering price. Offering the same rebate to every syndicate member does not authorize passing it to customers. Distinguish permitted dealer concessions from a reduced public customer price.
The selling-group disclosure rule is the disclosure backbone that makes the fixed-offering-price discipline enforceable. Selected dealers must know exactly what concession and reallowance they receive, so that any deviation is visible.
Exam Tip: Gotchas
- A dealer concession does not authorize a reduced public offering price to customers.
- Selling-group agreements disclose price, concession and reallowance terms to selected dealers.
What Should You Check on Exam Day?
- Can you state the corporate-financing rule's filing deadline: 3 business days after a regulator filing, or 15 business days before sale if none?
- Do you know when the 180-day lock-up clock starts, and that it runs from the date sales commence, not the effective date?
- Can you state the flat limits regardless of deal size: a right of first refusal of 3 years, compensation warrants exercisable within 5 years (demand right 5 years, piggyback right 7 years), and a non-accountable expense allowance of 3%?
- Can you tell an offering that is exempt only from filing (such as investment grade rated non-convertible debt) from one the rule never reaches (such as a private placement or a municipal offering)?
- Can you distinguish a permitted dealer concession from a prohibited reduction in the public offering price?